Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the expectations of grandfathers vs grandmothers are miles apart?

40 replies

Blaainey · 24/04/2026 20:36

There are so many threads about women complaining their DM/MIL is not gra not doing childcare, not helping enough, not being “hands on” enough. Cue outrage. Cue dissecting her personality, her priorities, her supposed selfishness.
But where are the grandfathers in all this?

They seem to exist in the background and no one expects anything. If a grandfather takes a child to the park once a month he’s basically up for sainthood. Meanwhile a grandmother can be doing regular childcare and still get criticised for not doing more or not doing it in the “right” way. She is criticised for not helping especially if she dared have help herself.

Even in real life I see it. Grandmothers are assumed to be available, involved, emotionally invested, practically useful. Grandfathers are optional extras. Nice if they engage, but no big deal if they don’t.

It is not just about practical help, it’s the emotional expectation too. Grandmothers are meant to remember birthdays, organise things, build relationships. Grandfathers can just turn up.

I never see a thread where someone is complaining the grandfather refuses to help with childcare.

I know it’s not all grandfathers and there are amazing, involved ones out there – I KNOW. But as a general pattern, the bar just seems so much lower for them.
AIBU to think it’s a bit unfair that one grandparent is scrutinised

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JoshLymanSwagger · 27/04/2026 14:07

Blaainey · 25/04/2026 14:33

Only seen one grandfather behaviour thread. Quite a few male nursery workers.

If women are so worried about men, why have a baby with them in the first place?

Edited

Biologically, it's fucking impossible without TBH.
Unless you're using a sperm donor - which frankly a lot of men are. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Thechaseison71 · 25/04/2026 14:47

LameBorzoi · 25/04/2026 08:37

That's a race to the bottom. Kids benefit significantly from having actively engaged grandparents.

Can be engaged without doing childcare

DuskOPorter · 25/04/2026 14:44

Blaainey · 25/04/2026 14:33

Only seen one grandfather behaviour thread. Quite a few male nursery workers.

If women are so worried about men, why have a baby with them in the first place?

Edited

Ok you’ve only seen one thread, there are more.

I don’t know why these women have babies with men but if you want to find out reasons for anything you have to ask people and then listen to what they say not respond all argumentatively and defensively at them and not accept other reasons because it conflicts with what you believe.

There are many reasons for many things people do because people are complex.

Blaainey · 25/04/2026 14:33

DuskOPorter · 25/04/2026 14:24

Read through threads here about women questioning grandfather’s behaviour with their children, male nursery workers and you will find people are far, far more skeptical of men looking after children than you are.

Edited

Only seen one grandfather behaviour thread. Quite a few male nursery workers.

If women are so worried about men, why have a baby with them in the first place?

OP posts:
DuskOPorter · 25/04/2026 14:24

Blaainey · 25/04/2026 12:33

That is a massive leap.

Yes, abuse and violence are real issues. No one is denying that. But going from that to basically saying it makes sense that grandfathers aren’t expected to do much doesn’t really add up.

Most harm to children comes from a small minority of people, not men as a whole. If you start applying worst case statistics to entire groups, you end up justifying treating loads of normal people with suspicion, which most of us don’t actually do in real life.

In real life, women do trust men with children all the time. Fathers, brothers, uncles, teachers, doctors. Kids aren’t being kept away from men as a rule. So it’s not this deep, universal thing where women are too wary to let men be involved. It’s more that men often aren’t expected to be as involved in the first place.

That’s the bit that gets overlooked. Expectations shape everything.

Grandmothers are assumed to be hands on, reliable, emotionally involved, so they get judged against that. Grandfathers aren’t held to the same standard, so they don’t get criticised in the same way.

The whole bear in the woods thing is about a hypothetical stranger in a dangerous situation. It doesn’t translate to how families operate day to day with people they know and trust.

It doesn't explain why one grandparent gets held to a really high bar and the other can just drift along.

Read through threads here about women questioning grandfather’s behaviour with their children, male nursery workers and you will find people are far, far more skeptical of men looking after children than you are.

Blaainey · 25/04/2026 12:33

DuskOPorter · 25/04/2026 11:34

Women rely much more on other women for support because men abuse women and children at such a high rate that even if it is so utterly deep down most women are extremely skeptical of men looking after children.

They cannot imprison the vast majority of men who are looking at child porn because the courts are flooded with them and the conviction for rapes could be as little as 1-2% of the overall number of rapes and that prevalence is high, add it together with DV and child abuse and I think that is why the pressure falls disproportionately to women. Also it is almost always men known to women and children who harm them.

Look at the bear vs strange man in the woods question.

That is a massive leap.

Yes, abuse and violence are real issues. No one is denying that. But going from that to basically saying it makes sense that grandfathers aren’t expected to do much doesn’t really add up.

Most harm to children comes from a small minority of people, not men as a whole. If you start applying worst case statistics to entire groups, you end up justifying treating loads of normal people with suspicion, which most of us don’t actually do in real life.

In real life, women do trust men with children all the time. Fathers, brothers, uncles, teachers, doctors. Kids aren’t being kept away from men as a rule. So it’s not this deep, universal thing where women are too wary to let men be involved. It’s more that men often aren’t expected to be as involved in the first place.

That’s the bit that gets overlooked. Expectations shape everything.

Grandmothers are assumed to be hands on, reliable, emotionally involved, so they get judged against that. Grandfathers aren’t held to the same standard, so they don’t get criticised in the same way.

The whole bear in the woods thing is about a hypothetical stranger in a dangerous situation. It doesn’t translate to how families operate day to day with people they know and trust.

It doesn't explain why one grandparent gets held to a really high bar and the other can just drift along.

OP posts:
PollyBell · 25/04/2026 12:29

DuskOPorter · 25/04/2026 11:34

Women rely much more on other women for support because men abuse women and children at such a high rate that even if it is so utterly deep down most women are extremely skeptical of men looking after children.

They cannot imprison the vast majority of men who are looking at child porn because the courts are flooded with them and the conviction for rapes could be as little as 1-2% of the overall number of rapes and that prevalence is high, add it together with DV and child abuse and I think that is why the pressure falls disproportionately to women. Also it is almost always men known to women and children who harm them.

Look at the bear vs strange man in the woods question.

So men are ok enough to breed with but that is where their services end?

Blaainey · 25/04/2026 12:26

Monty36 · 25/04/2026 11:46

Because granny did the childcare in terms of feeding, nappies etc. They know the ropes.
Grandad is more likely to have been involved with playtime. But would not be familiar with nappies or feeding arrangements. They didn’t do it first time around. Asking them to learn would be unkind.
Work around the home was in the past more often in households clearly defined. Men cut the grass, dealt with anything around the house that needed maintaining including the car. Women did cookery and washing and ironing. And most of the childcare.

So nobody really expects Grandad to do nappies. He hasn’t a clue where to begin.
That is why. Ask him to mow the lawn and you might be in luck.

Grandad is more likely to have been involved with playtime. But would not be familiar with nappies or feeding arrangements. They didn’t do it first time around. Asking them to learn would be unkind.

Lets be kind and get granny to do it. We must be kind to grandfathers not grandmothers because they are used to changing shitty nappies anyway

OP posts:
Blaainey · 25/04/2026 12:24

LadyMacbethssweetArabianhand · 25/04/2026 11:38

I look after my grandsons 2 days a week. My son in laws dad also looks after them 2 days a week. His wife is still working. So your premise isnt my reality

Hence saying:

I know it’s not all grandfathers and there are amazing, involved ones out there – I KNOW.

OP posts:
Monty36 · 25/04/2026 11:47

As the decades go by, this may change. As you will have Grandad who will have done nappies etc.

Monty36 · 25/04/2026 11:46

Because granny did the childcare in terms of feeding, nappies etc. They know the ropes.
Grandad is more likely to have been involved with playtime. But would not be familiar with nappies or feeding arrangements. They didn’t do it first time around. Asking them to learn would be unkind.
Work around the home was in the past more often in households clearly defined. Men cut the grass, dealt with anything around the house that needed maintaining including the car. Women did cookery and washing and ironing. And most of the childcare.

So nobody really expects Grandad to do nappies. He hasn’t a clue where to begin.
That is why. Ask him to mow the lawn and you might be in luck.

LadyMacbethssweetArabianhand · 25/04/2026 11:38

I look after my grandsons 2 days a week. My son in laws dad also looks after them 2 days a week. His wife is still working. So your premise isnt my reality

DuskOPorter · 25/04/2026 11:34

Women rely much more on other women for support because men abuse women and children at such a high rate that even if it is so utterly deep down most women are extremely skeptical of men looking after children.

They cannot imprison the vast majority of men who are looking at child porn because the courts are flooded with them and the conviction for rapes could be as little as 1-2% of the overall number of rapes and that prevalence is high, add it together with DV and child abuse and I think that is why the pressure falls disproportionately to women. Also it is almost always men known to women and children who harm them.

Look at the bear vs strange man in the woods question.

Credittocress · 25/04/2026 11:28

Blaainey · 25/04/2026 08:16

It is these threads that people object to, not the endless dogs in cafes, parking and inheritance issues 🙄

Nah people object to those to. It’s boring as shit.

Credittocress · 25/04/2026 11:26

Fuck me. This again 10 in a fortnight? Just don’t look after your grandkids.

We could equally talk about the unfair expectations of the elderly on daughters to step up and provide care compared to sons.

Ponoka7 · 25/04/2026 11:23

StephQ1 · 25/04/2026 10:50

My DS’s grandfathers were both dead before he was born so that sorted the problem for us. I don’t know how the rest of you cope with such a huge issue.

Women being default carers, not just for children, but elderly/disabled family etc is a huge issue. I'd have hoped it would die out by now. I'm my DD's childcare, I do this willingly and enjoy it. But a lot of my friends are helping out with grandchildren, while their husbands decide not to. I know if it was the granddad doing the care and the grandmother refused to get involved, there'd be a lot of negative gossip about her.
I came from a family were there's a 60(woman)/40 split, but the women worked less. Now I see women doing 60+, while working full time and using savings for maternity leave. Yet the government wonders why we have a birth rate problem.

At my GCs school there is a good mix, across pick-ups, inspire events etc. A lot of Dads put a lot of time into running sport activities etc. But it isn't reflective of every area. I don't think that it's doing us any favours to have immigrantion from countries were women are the housekeepers etc.

StephQ1 · 25/04/2026 10:50

My DS’s grandfathers were both dead before he was born so that sorted the problem for us. I don’t know how the rest of you cope with such a huge issue.

huuskymam · 25/04/2026 10:48

khaa2091 · 25/04/2026 01:10

My parents are very traditional and my Dad was away for long periods of time when I was a child.

They have always had my daughter overnight fairly frequently as I do shift work. My mother utterly smashed her dominant shoulder the week before I went back to work and so my father rapidly upped his game and learnt how to prepare bottles, change nappies and bathe babies. Initially done under my mothers supervision, but my daughter still goes to Grandpa if she wakes up in the night.

I do 3 full days of childcare for my 2 year old grand daughter. From 7 till 1 its just me and her. Then at 1 grandad gets home, then her mam is home by half 3. On the days I dont have her, she'll be out with mam all day and when she walks in the door (they live with us) the little madam blanks me and runs straight to grandad.

LameBorzoi · 25/04/2026 10:43

Blaainey · 25/04/2026 10:28

When people say there are lots of grandfathers who do childcare too, this is the difference. The grandmothers will do more of the care like prepping food, feeding, helping with toilet training and cleaning up. Grandfathers will do more playing and pick ups.

Edited

And this is what older generations were taught to do. Changing these patterns for younger generations took a great deal of hard work. Changing these for older generations is probably more emotional and mental labour than most parents of young kids really want to take on.

Blaainey · 25/04/2026 10:28

dajen · 25/04/2026 08:38

My husband thinks he shares the childcare when we have our young grandchildren to stay. His contribution is usually snacks on demand and resorting to TV or iPad. I’m the one playing games, baking with them, organising crafts, reading with them, getting them to bed, to eat fruit and vegetables and clean their teeth.

The children are already savvy enough to know that grandma is hands on and grandad just sits in his chair and lets life happen around him .

When people say there are lots of grandfathers who do childcare too, this is the difference. The grandmothers will do more of the care like prepping food, feeding, helping with toilet training and cleaning up. Grandfathers will do more playing and pick ups.

OP posts:
Blaainey · 25/04/2026 10:27

JoshLymanSwagger · 25/04/2026 08:49

It's pretty tedious now, isn't it?

Not as tedious as to keep commenting on a post you are not interested instead of moving on 🙄

OP posts:
JoshLymanSwagger · 25/04/2026 08:49

OneNaiceSnail · 25/04/2026 08:14

Oh dear lord will these threads never end 🤦🏼‍♀️

It's pretty tedious now, isn't it?

InterestedDad37 · 25/04/2026 08:46

notnowmaud · 25/04/2026 00:58

A few weeks back dh and I were talking about grandkids, dd mentioned she didn’t want any, and I whole heartedly agreed with her, dh then pipped up and said she’d likely change her mind and we (eg ME) would do the child care we both gave him a hard look, dd told him where he could stick it where the sun don’t shine (that’s my girl!) and I told him hell would freeze over before I did any child care again, I’ve only just got back into full time work now dc are in secondary, and want to enjoy work and then retirement, which does not include childcare, however I told him, he was welcome to offer anytime, but I’ll be off doing all the things I couldn’t do over the last 16 years! He looked shocked and told me I’d change my mind, I told him he was an arrogant prat, and should know by now I don’t change my mind (we’ve been married for 20 years).

How have you made it to 20 years? Presumably his attitude isn't a new thing?

dajen · 25/04/2026 08:38

My husband thinks he shares the childcare when we have our young grandchildren to stay. His contribution is usually snacks on demand and resorting to TV or iPad. I’m the one playing games, baking with them, organising crafts, reading with them, getting them to bed, to eat fruit and vegetables and clean their teeth.

The children are already savvy enough to know that grandma is hands on and grandad just sits in his chair and lets life happen around him .

LameBorzoi · 25/04/2026 08:37

Ace56 · 25/04/2026 08:26

No, of course this attitude isn’t right but we can’t be surprised now that men in their 60s and above don’t generally do a lot of solo childcare! If grandmothers want to ‘relax in their retirement’ they need to tell their adult DC that they can’t look after their kids all the time. There should be no expectations on them either.

That's a race to the bottom. Kids benefit significantly from having actively engaged grandparents.