Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Could Zack Polanski be any more of an obnoxious twat?

510 replies

HeadDeskHeadDesk · 23/04/2026 19:11

Just seen him saying this:

'I am concerned about the rise in antisemitism and we know Jewish communities are saying they feel unsafe. There is a conversation to be had over whether it's a perception that they feel unsafe or whether they are actually unsafe.'

WTAF? Can you imagine if a politician said that to Muslims after a series of absolutely awful targeted attacks where people have died?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Wearenotborg · 25/04/2026 09:47

HRTQueen · 25/04/2026 09:46

its a difference of opinion on views about the trans issue

Ok. That’s fine. What part of “that’s nice dear” says it not?

HRTQueen · 25/04/2026 09:46

Wearenotborg · 25/04/2026 09:44

That’s nice dear.

its a difference of opinion on views about the trans issue

ScarlettOYara · 25/04/2026 09:46

yebba2026 · 25/04/2026 09:41

Which nobody has done in any of the threads that go around in circles!

This is specifically about Polanski, the Greens and antisemitism. Some posters are bringing other minority groups into the discussion, not to develop and explain, but quite the opposite.
I think it's entirely possible to be very concerned about both Reform and the Greens and how they are exploiting racism.

Wearenotborg · 25/04/2026 09:44

HRTQueen · 25/04/2026 09:43

I do care about women’s rights being a woman myself

but I am not feeling the treat of the trans issue as some are and it’s not my most concerning issue, it’s way down the list

so I shall continue to vote Labour

That’s nice dear.

HRTQueen · 25/04/2026 09:43

Wearenotborg · 25/04/2026 09:37

And don’t vote Labour or Tory if you care about women’s rights. So no party is worthy to run the country really.

I do care about women’s rights being a woman myself

but I am not feeling the treat of the trans issue as some are and it’s not my most concerning issue, it’s way down the list

so I shall continue to vote Labour

yebba2026 · 25/04/2026 09:41

ScarlettOYara · 25/04/2026 09:40

There is no hierarchy of racism, I agree absolutely 100% .
Which is why it is wrong to dismiss, deny or minimise antisemitism.

Which nobody has done in any of the threads that go around in circles!

ScarlettOYara · 25/04/2026 09:40

There is no hierarchy of racism, I agree absolutely 100% .
Which is why it is wrong to dismiss, deny or minimise antisemitism.

yebba2026 · 25/04/2026 09:37

I'm not putting this here to bait anyone, nor am I remotely interested in having any sort of debate - because a few of you have created an echo chamber here and there is zero point.

I just need to say this. There are some comments on here which I feel are unacceptable and not reflective of how many people feel - although I expect that a lot of people would not want to wade in to say anything for fear of being shouted down or accused of something that they are not doing.

  • It is NOT a blood libel to suggest there is a genocide in Gaza, Lebanon or anywhere else that is being attacked by the Israeli government.
  • It is okay to be Jewish and Anti-Zionist. It is just as valid for Jewish people (whether that is defined by their ethnicity, religion or both) to hold their own views. That does NOT make them "self-hating", it means that they have a differing opinion to some of the people shouting loudly on here. It is not okay to police other people's values or opinions. They are not less of a Jew that you are (I mean you if you are reading this and shaking your head in disagreement!)
  • This attempted hierarchy of racism is totally unacceptable. Again, nobody should be making sweeping statements that one group is more persecuted that another group. That is not only nonsensical but also extremely upsetting and triggering for people to read. A man has just been jailed for life for following and brutally raping a woman based on her skin colour and because he thought she was a Muslim.

If the same people insist on dragging what they believe to be antisemitism onto AIBU, please be ready to accept that the idea of it is that you are inviting opinions - and that it is fine to disagree. Nobody should be made to feel that they can't because they might be piled on.

Some of you can do a lot better, in my opinion.

Wearenotborg · 25/04/2026 09:37

HRTQueen · 25/04/2026 09:15

^ this

it couldn’t not be clearer

And don’t vote Labour or Tory if you care about women’s rights. So no party is worthy to run the country really.

HRTQueen · 25/04/2026 09:15

Twiglets1 · 25/04/2026 09:06

It's quite straightforward: don't vote Green or Reform if you care about racism.

^ this

it couldn’t not be clearer

Twiglets1 · 25/04/2026 09:06

It's quite straightforward: don't vote Green or Reform if you care about racism.

ScarlettOYara · 25/04/2026 09:05

Wearenotborg · 25/04/2026 05:49

So hold on, antisemitism is bad if reform do it, but it’s ok if the Green Party do it because…. Why? Or are you trying to distract from the absolute sheer disgusting comment of the Green Party by “noooo don’t look at them, look at reform, they’re worse?

Make it make sense!

Wearenotborg · 25/04/2026 05:49

Summerhillsquare · 23/04/2026 19:56

Totally disingenuous OP. As if Reform are not a massive threat to Jewish Brits, or indeed women, Muslims. Yeah let's distract and pretend the Green Party are the problem. Reform have literally had representatives bribed by Russia.

So hold on, antisemitism is bad if reform do it, but it’s ok if the Green Party do it because…. Why? Or are you trying to distract from the absolute sheer disgusting comment of the Green Party by “noooo don’t look at them, look at reform, they’re worse?

Bollihobs · 25/04/2026 01:01

Summerhillsquare · 23/04/2026 19:37

Wilfully naive are you OP? Or just showing your cards?

Reform Ltd members have called for deportation and violence against UK Muslims. They are an openly racist group.

Can you link to some examples of these calls for violence @Summerhillsquare

InertBird · 25/04/2026 00:55

Francine84 · 24/04/2026 23:17

Being anti-Israel and criticising genocide in Gaza is not being antisemitic

There has been no genocide in Gaza. That is a blood libel and it is antisemitic.

Underthinker · 24/04/2026 23:34

Francine84 · 24/04/2026 23:17

Being anti-Israel and criticising genocide in Gaza is not being antisemitic

And BNP members being "proud of their country" isn't racist, but we know in both cases members' views are often more extreme than these bland sanitised statements.

Francine84 · 24/04/2026 23:17

SpottyAlpaca · 23/04/2026 19:16

He’s Jewish himself, of course. He’s also leading a party which is riddled with antisemitism from top to bottom, and trying to appeal to a profoundly antisemitic demographic. That’s quite a lot of cognitive dissonance to deal with, hence comments like this.

Being anti-Israel and criticising genocide in Gaza is not being antisemitic

ElenOfTheWays · 24/04/2026 23:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What an odd and puerile non response.

Why should I be crying?

Sausagenbacon · 24/04/2026 22:26

Green MP Hannah Spencer was on Question Time tonight and, frankly, she comes across as thick.

JustSawJohnny · 24/04/2026 22:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ScarlettOYara · 24/04/2026 20:40

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 24/04/2026 19:55

Yes.

It’s not just stupidity.’

Its the militant, unapologetic stupidity that has its roots in the general dumbing down of everything, tolerated, accepted and indulged.

Everything now needs to be brought down to the lowest common denominator.

Politics as slogans and chants and badges. Simplistic and foolish.

ScarlettOYara · 24/04/2026 20:39

Ihatetomatoes · 24/04/2026 20:36

It's also vile that people either make excuses for antisemitism and violence against Jewish people in this country or pretend it isn't happening. The facts speak for themselves.

What happened in Gaza has sod all to do with British Jews and everything to do with plain and simple hatred. Shame on those who minimise, excuse or whataboutery their hatred.

Absolutely. It's shocking. I can't believe it's happening in this country, with people justifying and minimising it. Those of us who aren't Jewish need to step up and make sure it's constantly challenged.
What's that phrase about evil succeeding because good people do nothing?.

Ihatetomatoes · 24/04/2026 20:36

BunfightBetty · 24/04/2026 09:43

What a horrible way to have to live, because of others' prejudice and hatred.

I've seen the fear my Jewish friends feel increase since the October 7 atrocity, and it makes me feel ashamed of those of my compatriots who harbour such hate in their hearts. That we have mainstream politicians egging it on is not something I thought I'd ever see in this country, and it sickens me.

It's also vile that people either make excuses for antisemitism and violence against Jewish people in this country or pretend it isn't happening. The facts speak for themselves.

What happened in Gaza has sod all to do with British Jews and everything to do with plain and simple hatred. Shame on those who minimise, excuse or whataboutery their hatred.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 24/04/2026 19:55

HeadDeskHeadDesk · 24/04/2026 19:44

That would have sounded implausible to me at one time and even now I'm inclined to think it has to be a massive exaggeration. However, my son runs a business and needs to communicate daily with dozens of members of the public via email. He said 'mum, my business partner warned me that the average person is incredibly stupid and I thought he was being unfair. But no, it turns out he's right. I am staggered every day by just how incredibly stupid so many people are.'

He's given me some examples and wow, he's not wrong. 😂

Yes.

It’s not just stupidity.’

Its the militant, unapologetic stupidity that has its roots in the general dumbing down of everything, tolerated, accepted and indulged.

Everything now needs to be brought down to the lowest common denominator.

HeadDeskHeadDesk · 24/04/2026 19:44

BunfightBetty · 24/04/2026 18:53

I do hope you're right. And previously I thought this too.

The student politics ARE ridiculous. Yet I see so many grown adults falling for them, despite them being laughably absurd, that I do wonder.

I used to have an ex who worked in a government type role, where the brief was to provide financial literacy education to the public at large. One time I expressed surprise at how simplistic/dumbed down one of the awareness campaigns were, and he explained it by saying "what you have to realise is that 50% of the population aren't able to calculate 50%".

If we're really dealing with that level of intelligence/education/skills in the general population it's a worry.

That would have sounded implausible to me at one time and even now I'm inclined to think it has to be a massive exaggeration. However, my son runs a business and needs to communicate daily with dozens of members of the public via email. He said 'mum, my business partner warned me that the average person is incredibly stupid and I thought he was being unfair. But no, it turns out he's right. I am staggered every day by just how incredibly stupid so many people are.'

He's given me some examples and wow, he's not wrong. 😂

OP posts: