Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I’ll be stuck at 16 stone forever

762 replies

justmeandthedogs · 23/04/2026 06:45

I’m in the process of losing weight and since the start of the year I’ve lost about 13lbs.

But I seem to be in a loop. I’ll hit 16 stone 0.3 on the scales and then go back up to 16 stone 4, then go back down, then back up. It’s like an annoying cycle.

I eat well:

breakfast - yoghurt with berries and sometimes a drizzle of honey. On low protein days I’ll add some skyr.

lunch - something from home. Usually soup, a salad or a bit of meat with some veg.

dinner - again something prepped. Can be another big salad, cottage pie, pasta bake.

I eat 1550 calories a day, which is a deficit for my height and weight. I go to the gym twice a week (under the direction of a PT, to lift weights), try to run 3 times a week but I’m waiting on some new running shoes, and the other two days a week I’ll walk 10k steps minimum. I try to drink 4 litres of water a day at least.

my clothes fit better but the scale just won’t change 😥 do I just accept I’m stuck here?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
DeepRubySwan · 23/04/2026 08:00

How do you accurately track your calories though if you are eating home cooked food? Or are you eating ready made meals? I found using Lean Cuisine helped me lose weight. The other things that really helped was eating two meals a day. Try buying a bunch of frozen meals and soups and just eating that tracking your calories that way and cut to 1200 a day. You will lose weight trust me. If you.dont on that you may have a thyroid issue.

RoseField1 · 23/04/2026 07:59

timeforteaandcakes · 23/04/2026 07:42

Look up the set point theory. Your body seems to be happy at 16st or just above so when you go below that it will slow you metabolism down so you can’t lose more.
calories in/out does not take account of hormones and insulin and metabolism.
if you qualify wli would help with this

That's not what set point theory says. Set point theory suggests that the body can adapt to a certain weight when maintained for a significant period of time and this leads to natural adaptation in appetite/calorie intake/energy expenditure to maintain that weight. This is theorised to happen in both directions so when weight is gained and lost. This theory may explain why most people stay around the same weight without paying attention to their calorie intake. Not that the body finds a 'happy weight' all by itself randomly and then wants to stay there.

BunnyLake · 23/04/2026 07:58

I would carry on as you are, scrap the scales for now and choose one item of clothing you want to get into but can’t. Preferably something with a zip, like trousers. Once a week at the same time try on the trousers. This will give you a much better idea of your weight loss.

canyon2000 · 23/04/2026 07:58

I don't really believe in calories in/calories out any more! I think it is more complicated than that. I'm 53 and trying to maintain my weight and I am finding it increasingly hard. I don't eat breakfast. Lunch is the mythical 'massive salad' with a bit of cottage cheese on then a piece of fruit. Dinner is a small portion of whatever we are having plus lots of veg, pudding is kefir yogurt with fruit in. I don't drink alcohol. I walk an average of 25,000 steps a day. I can maintain my weight on this but not lose any but when I was younger I would lose 2-3 pounds a week doing this. It seems bonkers to me!

Wolffie17 · 23/04/2026 07:58

If your clothes are fitting better, is it possible you’ve swapped fat for muscle? So your weight hasn’t changed but your shape has?

justmeandthedogs · 23/04/2026 07:58

DramaFrontRowSeatWPopcorn · 23/04/2026 07:53

Unless you are definitely doing the running you mention you are not doing any cardio. Weights are strength training.

Could you add in a spin/cycle class? I found these the best way for me to shed the pounds.

Why would I lie about the cardio I’m doing?

OP posts:
VividDeer · 23/04/2026 07:57

Try intermittent fasting and push breakfast back or skip a few days a week.
You have done well so far.

Theysucceededintheend · 23/04/2026 07:56

Spaghettifountain · 23/04/2026 06:48

With respect, you're not eating 1550 calories a day. That's what I eat to lose a few pounds and I'm 8.5 stone and a reasonable athlete (which is why occasionally I want to cut, for performance).

You are eating more than you think. I'm half your mass and can lose weight on 1550.

That's not on.
You can't come and tell the OP she's NOT eating the amount of calories she says she's eating.
Don't accuse her of not knowing what calorie intake she's eating, it's unbearably condescending.
Being an athlete, you will have high muscle mass which burns calories faster and means you can consume a certain amount of calories and lose weight compared to someone with much lower muscle mass who eats the same amount of calories. Plus your athletic training will burn through way more energy compared to the 'regular person' level of ordinary exercise OP is doing.
I'm really surprised - being an athlete and all - that you don't already have this knowledge base, actually.

RoseField1 · 23/04/2026 07:56

Pandasarethebest · 23/04/2026 07:36

I know nothing about weight loss. But muscle weighs more than fat, if you are doing weight training?
It sounds like you are doing well and losing inches. Keep on going x

Women don't gain significant amounts of muscle in calorie deficit. Thats not how our bodies work.

itsgettingweird · 23/04/2026 07:55

sweetpickle2 · 23/04/2026 07:35

Actually quite sad how many people here are scared of carbs.

As OP has said, you could eat your daily calorie deficit made up entirely of bread and you'd lose weight that's how calorie deficits work!

I think carbs don’t work for me as they cause water retention for some reason.

im wheat free and maybe it’s that type of bread/pasta? Also they are higher in fat/calories for less so I get more calories if I avoid them!

bewilderedhedgehog · 23/04/2026 07:55

OP I would suggest a blood test to include thyroid as that could be affecting your metabolism. The other thought is that you could also be converting fat to muscle which weighs more

MrsJeanLuc · 23/04/2026 07:55

RoseField1 · 23/04/2026 07:49

Women don't gain significant muscle in calorie deficit. This is just not a reasonable explanation for stalled weight loss.

Anyone who is pushing weights will gain muscle!

And how else do you explain clothes being looser while weight stays the same.

Unless the scales themselves are faulty I suppose. I never really trust domestic bathroom scales - maybe op should get some new scales?

RoseField1 · 23/04/2026 07:54

Rocketpants50 · 23/04/2026 07:29

I could have written this. I am 50 and the weight just doesnt shift. I eat really healthy, track calories, gym 3/4 times a week - weights/ circuits, run once a week around 8k, walk daily between 8k and 18k steps daily. Sleep well. And in the last 2 months I have managed to lose about 5 pounds - this is about the same 5 pounds I put on in 1 weekend (and I didnt go crazy!) I only have to look at a glass of wine to put on the weight.
Like you I know I have lost a few cm's but not loads but everyone keeps saying stay away from the scales but I know weighing over 13 stone is not good for me. Am going to up my step count, maybe walk faster! Like you am just stuck. What worked before definitely doesnt at this age. Any over 50's found what does?

You know you don't gain fat like that right? 'Gaining' 5lbs in a weekend is all water retention and over the next week or so it will go back down again. A 5lb fat loss is a significant amount and cannot be regained with a couple of days of excess.

LolaLouise · 23/04/2026 07:54

whilst TDEE and science etc has a place, its not an exact science. There are many, many other factors that affect what your personal calorie target should be, its not the same maths for everyone. Even at my biggest i had to be on a small amount of cals to loose, even when the science said 1500, id lose nothing, cos the science doesnt take into account other factors.

My advice having lost 60% of my body weight (some with GLP1 assisstance) is trail and error your cals. Try 1400 and see if that kick starts you again. Or go the other way and do a week of 1700 and then back down to 1550

OvernightBloats · 23/04/2026 07:53

Cut out the snacks. It's hard at first, then it quickly becomes the new norm. I got into not having snacks (even fruit) because I had invisalign braces and since then continued to do this.

Not having snacks cuts out a few extra calories without making it feel like an ordeal. Also it makes it much easier to listen to your body's signals of being truly hungry (not bored) and satisfied with the food you have eaten.

Try it and you will see results!

DramaFrontRowSeatWPopcorn · 23/04/2026 07:53

justmeandthedogs · 23/04/2026 06:55

Because I’ve tried lower calories before and it spirals into a place where I end up with very unhealthy habits. Carbs are nothing to be afraid of and needed if you’re doing a lot of cardio and exercise. I mainly eat wholewheat pasta and lots of lovely wholemeal sourdough

Unless you are definitely doing the running you mention you are not doing any cardio. Weights are strength training.

Could you add in a spin/cycle class? I found these the best way for me to shed the pounds.

Dolphinnoises · 23/04/2026 07:52

You were asked upthread how old you are? In perimenopause your body holds hard onto fat as it likes the oestrogen it provides

Applesonthelawn · 23/04/2026 07:51

You're doing really well, and don't be discouraged - keep at it! But you are eating a lot more calories than you think.

I find the only way to avoid hunger on a 1500 diet is to eat a lot of veg.
The source of the calories also matter - try to minimise the complex carbs and sugars (even fruit) and keep it to moderate protein, small amount of dairy and a lot of veg.

Hankunamatata · 23/04/2026 07:51

You could try a blood sugar monitor?

YeahNoCoolCrap · 23/04/2026 07:51

There are three factors which might be in play:

  1. If you are weight training, you may be converting fat to muscle, which would make you slimmer and more toned, but not lighter. Using a tape measure to measure yourself once a week is the best way to see if this is happening. If you are getting slimmer, but not lighter, that isn't something to worry about and should eventually settle.
  2. TDEE is not an exact science, unfortunately. The calculator might be overestimating what you are burning, so you might need to eat less. If you are 1200 approx at sedentary and 1500 at the activity level you have entered, the 'correct' figure might lie between those two and it will be a case of trial and error to reduce the amount until the scales start shifting.
  3. It's possible you might be experiencing portion creep - from experience, it's easy to fall into this, increasing your portion sizes a little can add up over a week. The best way to deal with this is to weigh/measure strictly for a week and make sure you factor in any drinks that are not calorie free.
RoseField1 · 23/04/2026 07:50

Satsuma55 · 23/04/2026 07:25

Stop eating " lots of lovely sourdough ", it's just bread...if I ate lots of bread I'd put weight on.

That's not how weight loss works

MrsJeanLuc · 23/04/2026 07:50

justmeandthedogs · 23/04/2026 07:07

I’m guessing it’s because of my weight. Used to it to be honest. It’s just really frustrating because I know I am doing everything right but the scale just will not budge! Clothes that were bordering on too tight on me a few weeks ago now fit me really well so it’s obviously moving, just not on the scales

It's easy to get fixated on the scales @justmeandthedogs . I take it that you have been increasing the amount of exercise you do? If your clothes are looser then you are losing fat, it's just that you are building up muscle at the same time - which is a good thing, you'll feel better and look better.

Also don't worry so much about the ups and downs of your cycle. You're still losing weight all month, it's just that you need to compare against the same place in last month's cycle (if you see what I mean).

Lastly I agree with the people who have said try something different. Maybe increase calories for a couple of weeks, or try cutting carbs out for a few weeks - it doesn't really matter what, it's about trying to "kick start" your metabolism.

Blondeshavemorefun · 23/04/2026 07:50

justmeandthedogs · 23/04/2026 07:20

My TDEE is around 2100, at a sedentary level, according to multiple websites.

What’s your height

that seems high

knock off 300c s day and I’m sure you will lose weight

RoseField1 · 23/04/2026 07:49

MyPolitePeachSloth · 23/04/2026 07:23

Not sure if anyone has said this as I haven’t read all the replies but if you are exercising (which it sounds like you are) you could be gaining muscle as you loose fat. Muscle weighs more than fat so you might find you hit a certain weight and stay there for a while until you stop gaining as much muscle and carry on loosing fat. Ignore the scales, one pint of water weighs one pound, so if you have a big wee before weighing yourself the scales will show a loss. If you drink a pint of water then get on the scales it will show a gain.
concentrate on how your clothes feel and your body looks, don’t worry about the scales and keep doing what you are doing

Women don't gain significant muscle in calorie deficit. This is just not a reasonable explanation for stalled weight loss.

Geminispark · 23/04/2026 07:49

whoopwhoo · 23/04/2026 07:06

I would suggest fasting. So I only eat between 12 and 8pm. Eat in two or three blocks. Read about intermittent fasting. The science really makes sense.

Agree, especially not eating in the evening

Swipe left for the next trending thread