Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We don't want the government to lurch to the left

583 replies

Bargepole45 · 10/02/2026 13:57

I am absolutely astounded that Labour think it's democratic to decide that they can lurch to the left despite being elected with a very clear promise to not tax and spend. I believe this is absolutely not what the general public want and I am really worried that the economy isn't going to survive this and we will end up with an IMF bailout that will lead to very painful spending cuts for our most vulnerable.

Please vote:
YABU :I want Labour to lurch to the left in order to increase taxation and spending
YANBU: I don't want Labour to lurch to the left and would be against further tax and spending rises

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
treeowl · 10/02/2026 16:53

whilst I am not an ‘older voter’ I don’t blame any demographic. That’s far too simplistic and simply an easy blame gameThe bullies and the selfish, the takers and the givers, the hardworking and work shy …which way do they vote. It’s not an age thing it’s an attitude thing

But governments and the electorate have ignored the young for years and the impact is playing out now. Look at wage stagnation, housing costs vs salaries, the job market, cost of childcare, education funding etc.

Bargepole45 · 10/02/2026 16:53

BlackCatDiscoClub · 10/02/2026 16:49

Hmm, all these adult DCs with mental health problems, who was in government while they were growing up? And why are MH and SEN higher in deprived areas? And why are those areas deprived? And why are we having poverty in homes were people work?

OP maybe if your business isn't doing well and you cant pay staff or afford your own tax, then you just need to accept the market forces are dictating that there's less demand for what you're offering?

Perhaps all businesses that are finding it difficult should just close down? I mean if they're struggling to fund a rocketing minimum wage and increasing tax burden.... 30% of small businesses have reported themselves to be struggling and needing to downsize and potentially close. If they close then that's at least 5 million people out of work not to mention the knock on effect these closures would have on other businesses and staff they employ. Have you any idea what they would do to our economy?

OP posts:
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 10/02/2026 16:53

Irate😂

Just enjoying winding you up really. Much more fun than getting irate.

Feeling pretty chilled really. Just hate right wing. And people who tell me what to do. Like ‘step away’

Who the fuck do you think you are? Step away😂

NanFlanders · 10/02/2026 16:51

Bargepole45 · 10/02/2026 16:35

Higher taxation absolutely doesn't work for the individual if you are a net contributor. Especially once it goes beyond a certain level and all the arguments about a 'civilised society' can't be made. Clearly some people would be financially better off in a low tax economy where they fund just their own needs privately. This is why Dubai etc is attracting a lot of these people. You can think whatever you want about the ethics of this but it's clear that the people going there feel that they are better off there.

It is fundamentally selfish to want tax increases funded by someone else to fund spending that will be spent on you. You are essentially asking one family to fund another. It isn't a selfless stance to take when you're the beneficiary. It is by definition selfish.

I disagree. You never know when you will need what the welfare state provides. DH and I have decent salaries and I would have said were 'net contributors' - up until the point where our daughter became seriously ill. The amount the NHS spent on her over 3 years was in the 100s of 1000s (making us net beneficiaries now I guess). I would much rather have the peace of mind that publicly funded healthcare is there. My ex-flatmate was American and her (middle class, insured) father was crucified by health care costs. (Happily DD is now recovered and at uni - hopefully she will get a job that helps her pay some back, but I'm more than happy to pay taxes so other sick kids are looked after).

EasternStandard · 10/02/2026 16:51

BlackCatDiscoClub · 10/02/2026 16:49

Hmm, all these adult DCs with mental health problems, who was in government while they were growing up? And why are MH and SEN higher in deprived areas? And why are those areas deprived? And why are we having poverty in homes were people work?

OP maybe if your business isn't doing well and you cant pay staff or afford your own tax, then you just need to accept the market forces are dictating that there's less demand for what you're offering?

No in this case they have MH issues due to lack of work. Read the threads. Of course it’s tough on a young person to apply to a huge amount of jobs and get nowhere.

Read the ‘brutal job market’ thread and the engineering ones.

DiySteve · 10/02/2026 16:51

treeowl · 10/02/2026 16:47

The public did not want the two child cap to be abolished

I’m not against this as don’t want more dc in poverty.

You subscribe to the majority of funds reaching the children?

DrPrunesqualer · 10/02/2026 16:51

I agree
it is a travesty and the increasing numbers leaving really needs to be addressed.
however

whilst I am not an ‘older voter’ I don’t blame any demographic. That’s far too simplistic and simply an easy blame game
The bullies and the selfish, the takers and the givers, the hardworking and work shy …which way do they vote. It’s not an age thing it’s an attitude thing
Perhaps if everyone jumped back to life in the 40s,50s,60s they might be more aware and point the finger less.

Dragonflytamer · 10/02/2026 16:50

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/02/2026 16:46

There is a fair bit of ground between "high" wages and looking to the likes of Nigel Farage to do away with NMW because in an ideal world you'd like a return to "casual" contracts with no employment rights, and a typical hourly rate of £5 per hour.

If you are in the latter situation, then you are either a mercenary profiteering shitehouse, in which case I have no sympathy for you, or you are running a business which isn't viable, in which case I have a degree of sympathy for you but still draw the line at gutting employment law just to prop up your failed venture.

I would get rid of the minimum wage. We are already subsidise people to a certain level. It would be far better to be getting business to pick up more of that bill and get services delivered than to just keep the same bill and have people sitting on their arses. There are lots of roles that just don't exist because the economic value is less than the minimum wage. You would say those businesses are unviable and the worker don't deserve those jobs and are better unemployed. I would say that those workers are being doing a job than wasting their lives on their sofa.

Everyone working funded by the state - how much more left wing can you get.

treeowl · 10/02/2026 16:49

@DiySteve so how do you recruit & retain staff into the NHS by reducing the pension, would you increase their salaries? The ones on the great pensions will of course be the experienced highly qualified staff eg consultants as opposed to porters so have more job opportunities in general.

DiySteve · 10/02/2026 16:49

Bargepole45 · 10/02/2026 16:48

Fair enough! I have got behind myself on my work getting stuck into this. I do believe this forum is left leaning. Interestingly I found this though:

https://www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/mumsnet-poll-shows-reform-uk-on-top-lg0cgdzp0#:~:text=Roberts%20said%20Mumsnet%20users%20had,JACK%20TAYLOR/REUTERS

I guess this proves that the thread is misleading as you would never guess Reform were the most popular party based on posts here.

Don’t worry, OP.

There is probably a strong correlation between being a welfare recipient, and being in favour of a Labour government.

BlackCatDiscoClub · 10/02/2026 16:49

EasternStandard · 10/02/2026 16:43

Don’t worry payroll employment is down under Labour already and more taking benefits. So fewer jobs for dc and threads from stressed posters re adult dc suffering MH due to being stuck at home.

Hmm, all these adult DCs with mental health problems, who was in government while they were growing up? And why are MH and SEN higher in deprived areas? And why are those areas deprived? And why are we having poverty in homes were people work?

OP maybe if your business isn't doing well and you cant pay staff or afford your own tax, then you just need to accept the market forces are dictating that there's less demand for what you're offering?

AnnPerkins · 10/02/2026 16:48

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 10/02/2026 16:35

They could afford to pay out a bit more. They just don’t want ro.

How else do you suggest we raise our wages to the equivalent of the rest of the Wearwrn world.

They just don't want to🙄

I give up.

Bargepole45 · 10/02/2026 16:48

givemesteel · 10/02/2026 16:45

OP, you put this post up in the middle of day on a working day and have already got 258 replies.

Perhaps that points towards a skewed sample. Same with opinion polls, people who work / run businesses are too busy to participate.

Fair enough! I have got behind myself on my work getting stuck into this. I do believe this forum is left leaning. Interestingly I found this though:

https://www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/mumsnet-poll-shows-reform-uk-on-top-lg0cgdzp0#:~:text=Roberts%20said%20Mumsnet%20users%20had,JACK%20TAYLOR/REUTERS

I guess this proves that the thread is misleading as you would never guess Reform were the most popular party based on posts here.

Mumsnet mothers have always leaned Labour. Now Reform is ahead

Rising support for Nigel Farage’s party — if not the man himself — may worry the government

https://www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/mumsnet-poll-shows-reform-uk-on-top-lg0cgdzp0#:~:text=Roberts%20said%20Mumsnet%20users%20had,JACK%20TAYLOR/REUTERS

OP posts:
treeowl · 10/02/2026 16:47

The public did not want the two child cap to be abolished

I’m not against this as don’t want more dc in poverty.

District66 · 10/02/2026 16:47

Dragonflytamer · 10/02/2026 16:43

So you'd close most carehomes, nurseries, restaurants, shops as unviable businesses. Great I'd love to live in a country like that.

Whatever did we do 20 years ago for care homes restaurants, nurseries shops?
Oh yes, they paid decent wages and the price of the things that they bought without Credit adjusted accordingly
It was only once we had these surges of credit cards introduced to the economy that things started to go tits up very much like America
And now nobody can manage without it

DiySteve · 10/02/2026 16:47

ChoccieCornflake · 10/02/2026 14:13

I pay tax. I would be happy to pay more, as more is needed to improve the NHS and social care.

Thank you for your generosity - you can of course make voluntary payments direct to HMRC.

In the interim and FYI.

NHS pension costs represent a significant portion of the health budget, with employer contributions rising to 23.7% of pensionable pay as of April 2024, up from 20.6%. Total taxpayer-funded employer contributions for NHS pensions reached over £17bn in 2024-25, and with total pension liabilities exceeding £457bn, the scheme is unfunded and underwritten by the Treasury.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/02/2026 16:46

Bargepole45 · 10/02/2026 16:42

No, there is a point where high wages kills employment. Look at Sweden as an example and their minimum wage and astronomical youth unemployment rates. You can deter employment.

There is a fair bit of ground between "high" wages and looking to the likes of Nigel Farage to do away with NMW because in an ideal world you'd like a return to "casual" contracts with no employment rights, and a typical hourly rate of £5 per hour.

If you are in the latter situation, then you are either a mercenary profiteering shitehouse, in which case I have no sympathy for you, or you are running a business which isn't viable, in which case I have a degree of sympathy for you but still draw the line at gutting employment law just to prop up your failed venture.

treeowl · 10/02/2026 16:46

All governments have gone along with in work benefits however we have loads of people deliberately working part time to keto benefits going. It’s not all about poor wages. Lots of the issues are about not working full time

I work p/t partly for ease (small dc) but full time mean any extra earnings are taxed at the higher rate. The cliff edges also have an impact.

givemesteel · 10/02/2026 16:45

OP, you put this post up in the middle of day on a working day and have already got 258 replies.

Perhaps that points towards a skewed sample. Same with opinion polls, people who work / run businesses are too busy to participate.

District66 · 10/02/2026 16:45

I don’t think we will be taxed any more on PAYE as a result of labours actions
Lots of people sat on their arse is doing very little for their compounded interest should be taxed until they squeak
Hopefully, they will be

Bargepole45 · 10/02/2026 16:45

BlackCatDiscoClub · 10/02/2026 16:42

Can you show me the polls where people said they cared more about avoiding tax and spend than child poverty? I mean Labour did win the election, so it seems theres quite a few people who prefer centre left to centre right? And thats with a lot of socialists holding their nose as they voted too.

Labour specifically said they would not increase taxes on working people. They were elected on the grounds. The implication was clear, they wouldn't tax and spend.

The public did not want the two child cap to be abolished
yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/survey-results/daily/2025/07/15/6143b/2

OP posts:
girljulian · 10/02/2026 16:44

Bloody well wish we could get a left wing government in this country but don't think it's ever going to happen.

EasternStandard · 10/02/2026 16:43

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/02/2026 16:40

This.

"I can't afford to pay a decent wage!!!" is as straightforward an indicator as there is that your business isn't viable.

If you want to hobble along working 18 hour days and never taking a holiday, fine, you are within your rights to kill yourself through work. You have no right to expect anyone else to live in penury though just because your business struggles to pay their NMW.

Edited

Don’t worry payroll employment is down under Labour already and more taking benefits. So fewer jobs for dc and threads from stressed posters re adult dc suffering MH due to being stuck at home.

Dragonflytamer · 10/02/2026 16:43

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/02/2026 16:40

This.

"I can't afford to pay a decent wage!!!" is as straightforward an indicator as there is that your business isn't viable.

If you want to hobble along working 18 hour days and never taking a holiday, fine, you are within your rights to kill yourself through work. You have no right to expect anyone else to live in penury though just because your business struggles to pay their NMW.

Edited

So you'd close most carehomes, nurseries, restaurants, shops as unviable businesses. Great I'd love to live in a country like that.

Bargepole45 · 10/02/2026 16:42

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/02/2026 16:40

This.

"I can't afford to pay a decent wage!!!" is as straightforward an indicator as there is that your business isn't viable.

If you want to hobble along working 18 hour days and never taking a holiday, fine, you are within your rights to kill yourself through work. You have no right to expect anyone else to live in penury though just because your business struggles to pay their NMW.

Edited

No, there is a point where high wages kills employment. Look at Sweden as an example and their minimum wage and astronomical youth unemployment rates. You can deter employment.

OP posts: