Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Labour Voters. Honest question

484 replies

Tryingtodobetter82 · 29/12/2025 23:46

I’m not looking to start an argument on this subject. I know it’s a very heated and emotive topic.

I have strong views on political issues. What with algorithms and biased news organisations, it’s very easy to end up only seeing information that confirms what we already believe. Because of that, you don’t often hear the other side of the political divide.

I’m honestly curious whether those who voted Labour at the last General Election, for reference I did not, would vote the same way if there were an early GE in January, purely hypothetical of course.

If so, I’d really appreciate you sharing what you feel they’ve done right so far in their term. I’m asking as I genuinely want to understand different perspectives.

YABU - I would vote labour again
YANBU - I wouldn’t vote for them again (or ever have)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
Livelovebehappy · 30/12/2025 12:53

luckylavender · 30/12/2025 11:03

Slightly goady post I think but however. I’m a Labour voter and would definitely vote Labour and indeed Starmer again.
They've made mistakes and their Comms is not where it should be. They have also done a lot of good things.

But the right wing media is unforgivingly hostile.
Putting 14 years of carnage right is far from a straight forward task
No one is really questioning Farage, he’s allowed to lie with impunity like he always has
And no one really cross questions Tory ex ministers who suddenly have all the right answers

I have to say if anyone has received constant attacks and dirt digging it has to be Farage. It's really stepped up a notch in recent months. I think parties, particularly Labour, have been desperately trying to bring him down because they're panicking that the threat of Reform getting in at the next GE is very real. But unfortunately Labour have instead had to switch their focus to controlling corruption in their own party over the last 6 months.

MandingoAteMyBaby · 30/12/2025 12:52

peacefulpeach · 30/12/2025 12:19

@MandingoAteMyBaby ‘Big improvements round here almost immediately.’

What are the immediate improvements you’ve seen where you live?

Our MP changed from a long-standing and particularly ineffective and absent Conservative to a young, ambitious Labour. Prescriptions are now filled faster, we suddenly got a whole load of roads resurfaced - even rurally. And building projects unstalled after years of NIMBYism.

Things started to actually change where they had been frozen in time with the previous guy.

peacefulpeach · 30/12/2025 12:48

Dragonscaledaisy · 30/12/2025 12:39

They didn't. Those are just figures that were in their manifesto. Meaningless drivel.

💯 agreed. It’s like someone (forget who) in a newspaper article said recently - Labour politicians and people supporting Labour spout the same old shit slogans and statements, on repeat, with zero facts to back them up.

Slogans and soundbites like ‘smash the gangs’ and ‘end child poverty’ are designed to short-circuit thought and leave reason at the door. Used to tremendous success by the communists and nazis.

Embarrassing really. To say the least.

Livelovebehappy · 30/12/2025 12:47

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 30/12/2025 10:45

Yes I would- my only major disappointment of their term to date was rolling back of the winter fuel tax which I think should be tightly means tested. They’re making positive changes but decades of corruption, greed and lies take a while to fix

You are also referring to Raynor, Reeves, Mandelson too I'm guessing with the corruption and lies?

BoxesBoxesEverywhere · 30/12/2025 12:45

peacefulpeach · 30/12/2025 12:19

@MandingoAteMyBaby ‘Big improvements round here almost immediately.’

What are the immediate improvements you’ve seen where you live?

I'm not the person you're referring to, but I've also seen improvements around here, where I am.
Police on the streets, which I haven't seen for years.
Kind of nice and reassuring to have a "bobby on the beat" again, who you can pass "hellos" to as they go by.
Ringing up the doctors at 8am in the morning and actually getting an appointment for the same day instead of hearing "you are 29th in the queue" then when you eventually get through an hour or so later they've all gone and "ring back tomorrow" 🙄 for more of the same
Just two off the top of my head.

roshi42 · 30/12/2025 12:43

What a heartening thread! Thanks for posting so goadily OP, and thanks for taking the time to answer seriously everyone. There’s a load of good stuff happening that it’s easy to forget and overlook. Plus some big mistakes too which have been well pointed out.

I didn’t vote Labour as I had to vote Lib Dem in my constituency to get the Tories out, and prior to that I was in Caroline Lucas’ constituency and voted for her - regardless of party I thought she was an excellent and valuable voice to have in parliament. But to answer the point behind your question - who would you like to see form the next government: Labour. Absolutely. Because the Tories and Reform are evil and corrupt and inept. And no one else is a serious contender.

At least with Labour I believe that there are serious people with half a brain at least trying to make things better for ordinary people rather than just getting as much as they can for themselves. Even though they are by no means perfect and I could moan about them for ages!

Dragonscaledaisy · 30/12/2025 12:39

FerrisWheelsandLilacs · 30/12/2025 11:49

Genuine question - where did the 1,000 more GPs and 6,500 more teachers come from? Did we have this many qualified, jobless people before and now the new roles have opened they’ve all been filled? Or are there more open but unfilled roles?

These aren’t roles you magically fill out of nowhere so I always wonder how they can achieve this in 18 months,

They didn't. Those are just figures that were in their manifesto. Meaningless drivel.

Rusalina · 30/12/2025 12:37

Imbrocator · 30/12/2025 11:46

I find it hard to believe in Labour currently given the way they present themselves and the decisions they make. However I can’t honestly say I feel the other parties would do any better (likely they’d be much worse). Here are some issues that I feel were especially poorly handled:

  • Bridget Philipson’s delaying tactic’s and refusal to lay the updated EHRC guidelines before Parliament.
  • The greenlighting of solar farms on high grade farm land.
  • Labour’s rejection of a significant number of buildings being Listed.
  • Their proposed introduction of an Islamophobia definition.
  • The farmers’ inheritance tax.
  • The transition from EU farming subsidies to a sustainable model for UK farmers - lots scrapped.
  • Their delays closing loopholes that make the UK attractive to illegal immigrants.
  • Lowering of training standards and training time in trades in order to meet quotas, essentially impoverishing our trades in the long term.

There isn’t a single party that honestly and straightforwardly represents the issues I would be most likely to vote for (tackling climate change, protecting and improving the NHS, controlling immigration to prevent endless population growth, women’s rights, supporting farmers, protecting UK heritage), so it comes down to the question of which party is likely to do the least damage long term. Currently, despite my disappointment, it’s probably still Labour.

Ha, this is nearly an exact list of the issues I care about too. I rarely seem find people with the same combination of priorities/opinions as me.

I have always voted Labour, but I don’t feel particularly thrilled with them anymore. I feel quite politically homeless. However, if a GE was called right now I suspect they’d get my vote purely for lack of an appealing alternative.

Trixibell1234 · 30/12/2025 12:34

TopPocketFind · 30/12/2025 12:26

Johnson did the lying all himself

Agree

Trixibell1234 · 30/12/2025 12:33

letsallchant · 30/12/2025 12:26

The major reason for the Tories being labelled corrupt was the Labour campaign of lies

Now you're having a laugh. Contracts for their mates to make millions during Covid? Johnson and his dodgy Russian contacts, his parties, his putting some unknown young woman in the House of Lords? And that's the tip of the iceberg. They were labelled corrupt because they are corrupt, on a scale visible to Stevie Wonder. That's why they are polling at something like 5%

I agree with this. Plus there’s been no accountability from the Tories. So no I don’t feel like I can trust them.

RainbowBagels · 30/12/2025 12:33

NellieJean · 30/12/2025 11:55

The electorate wants simple answers to complex, long standing, structural issues. We are a low productivity country living beyond its means. We have a press that panders to ignorance and prejudice and is largely inherently anti Labour. They have not made a good start and need to get a grip in the next year or they will lose even more support. As for who to vote for next time the alternatives are pretty unpalatable to me. Polanski and Farage are two sides of the same coin, eloquent chancers.

I agree about Polanski and Farage. Bith chancers. However, Reforms support comes in areas which have a larger than average ( in Farages case double) the number of welfare and PIP claimants than the National average. Once Reform has to put actual policies out he will be in the same bind as Labour. Rich backers who want reduced wefare and a free matket and people who are anti immigration but also dependent on welfare so dont/ cannot work but vote Reform. Polanskis votes are mainly from the Further Left which will hold much better. Although the Mango Greens may not be happy as hes completely abandoned anything environmental in favour of building over the countryside, trans rights and Gaza . There is a distinct possibility that both of those parties will collapse under scrutiny come 2029 because party memberships dont win election ( as Jeremy Corbyn discovered)

peacefulpeach · 30/12/2025 12:26

EffinMagicFairy · 30/12/2025 11:03

Am disappointed, I voted, will never get my vote again, killed the job market for our young people, part time jobs to keep DC going at Uni are non existent, very lucky if they can get one. Making benefits seen as attractive, what message does that give to youngsters, may be right wing propaganda but even so, the seed has to be there. I should have taking my fathers advice and never voted labour, any subsequent government will have even more of a mess to sort out, the conservatives couldn’t do it in 14 years, it was a mess when they came in, so we are just digging a bigger hole, I don’t want Reform, but the way labour are carrying on that’s what we are going to get and I will be seriously pissed off.

💯 agree with everything you’ve written.

Dragonscaledaisy · 30/12/2025 12:26

Maddy70 · 30/12/2025 00:01

They are up against right wing press so the good news doesn't get out , you so have to look for it they are not as left wing as I would like but they are making good changes and getting the job done. I like having a steady hand rather than a "showman" for a pm . So far (and there are more ..
1000 more GPs
Shortened NHS waiting lists
Ended train strike
Increased minimum wage
Renationalising railways
Banned no fault eviction and gave renters rights
Planning reform
Guaranteed homes for veterans/ Care leavers & domestic abuse survivors
Introduced legislation to smash the people smugglers
6500 more teachers
30 hours free childcare
450,000 kids out of poverty
Introduced breakfast clubs
Largest pay award ever for the armed forces

Several of those points aren't true but regardless, nothing in that list goes any way to offsetting the grave damage Labour has already caused to this country. There is never any good news with the current government.

EyeLevelStick · 30/12/2025 12:26

The poll doesn’t reflect the thread title, and I suspect, because the OP hasn’t come back, deliberately so.

TopPocketFind · 30/12/2025 12:26

DenizenOfAisleOfShame · 30/12/2025 12:12

More trustworthy? You really are having a laugh. The major reason for the Tories being labelled corrupt was the Labour campaign of lies.

That’s not a comment in support of Reform, by the way. They’re a bunch of shysters.

Johnson did the lying all himself

letsallchant · 30/12/2025 12:26

DenizenOfAisleOfShame · 30/12/2025 12:12

More trustworthy? You really are having a laugh. The major reason for the Tories being labelled corrupt was the Labour campaign of lies.

That’s not a comment in support of Reform, by the way. They’re a bunch of shysters.

The major reason for the Tories being labelled corrupt was the Labour campaign of lies

Now you're having a laugh. Contracts for their mates to make millions during Covid? Johnson and his dodgy Russian contacts, his parties, his putting some unknown young woman in the House of Lords? And that's the tip of the iceberg. They were labelled corrupt because they are corrupt, on a scale visible to Stevie Wonder. That's why they are polling at something like 5%

peacefulpeach · 30/12/2025 12:22

..this sums up Labour. Economically illiterate - and when running a country, that is a particularly terrible thing. But I understand that those in receipt of free cash won’t care about this, until their free cash stops.

Labour Voters. Honest question
peacefulpeach · 30/12/2025 12:19

@MandingoAteMyBaby ‘Big improvements round here almost immediately.’

What are the immediate improvements you’ve seen where you live?

DenizenOfAisleOfShame · 30/12/2025 12:12

Trixibell1234 · 30/12/2025 12:05

Yes.

I think they should be given time.

Plus agree with PP, what’s the alternative? They are more trustworthy than the Tories and Reform.

More trustworthy? You really are having a laugh. The major reason for the Tories being labelled corrupt was the Labour campaign of lies.

That’s not a comment in support of Reform, by the way. They’re a bunch of shysters.

ScholesPanda · 30/12/2025 12:12

I voted for them and would again.

Briefly:
NHS waiting lists are falling.
Interest rates are falling.
Net migration is falling.
Workers rights have been improved.
In two minds about the two child cap being scrapped, but I don't think children should be punished for the sins of their parents.

I don't really care whether my nearest lamppost has an England flag on it or not, it's not a priority to me, so I wouldn't vote Reform.

The Tories don't actually have a better, more imaginative, or very different answer to a lot of the structural problems the country faces in my opinion. They mostly seem to be a Reform tribute act. With an add on of criticising things that they did or started to do themselves whilst in government.

I'd like to see some more support for small businesses, particularly pubs, and also a bit more radicalism and confidence in delivery. If they could project more of an air of competence and direction whilst doing it that would also be good.

Trixibell1234 · 30/12/2025 12:05

Yes.

I think they should be given time.

Plus agree with PP, what’s the alternative? They are more trustworthy than the Tories and Reform.

NellieJean · 30/12/2025 11:55

The electorate wants simple answers to complex, long standing, structural issues. We are a low productivity country living beyond its means. We have a press that panders to ignorance and prejudice and is largely inherently anti Labour. They have not made a good start and need to get a grip in the next year or they will lose even more support. As for who to vote for next time the alternatives are pretty unpalatable to me. Polanski and Farage are two sides of the same coin, eloquent chancers.

ShesTheAlbatross · 30/12/2025 11:54

Yes I would.
Partly because of my local constituency MP - she’s quite good, and Reform came second in the last election I believe so I think I would vote for pretty much anyone to keep those absolute incompetent arseholes out.

But party due to them being the ones I disagree with/dislike least, rather than any real sense of them winning me over etc.
I won’t vote Reform. Ever.
I don’t like the Lib Dems, in particular the local candidate last time (but would vote for them if the constituency was between them and Reform)
I don’t like the Tories (but as per Lib Dems, would vote for them)
I think Zack Polanski is truly just a complete idiot (but in the unlikely event of a Green/Reform constituency, I would pick him over Farage).

Happyholidays78 · 30/12/2025 11:54

Labour voter here & I would vote for them again, same reasons as above really. It'll take years to try & sort the shit show of the Torys. I'm so fed up with politics becoming a vote for personalities l such as Farage/Trump/Boris. For me good leadership is being honest, thoughtful & having integrity & quietly getting on with the job & accepting that difficult decisions have to be made.

FerrisWheelsandLilacs · 30/12/2025 11:52

Maddy70 · 30/12/2025 10:59

These points I can't fathom.
Digital id. We already have it in so many ways, this will be one efficient card
Pay per mile, we all have to pay to use roads and it's services it's far less than using fossil fuels
Cashless society isn't in their manifesto
Jury trials are notoriously unrealiable. Having a panel of legal experts it's far superior than having some biased person deciding your future because they don't like the look of you

Most defendants, where given the choice, choose jury trials over a magistrates trial, so while it might be the right decision for justice (because decisions aren’t made based on how you look) - it’s not the choice most defendants would make (who overwhelming would prefer to give the decision to someone who might judge them on how they look).