Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband going through bin for cat food

364 replies

mrsgumpy · 02/11/2025 20:25

So I need some perspective on this. And yes I know it is ridiculous to be arguing about cat food.

My husband hates waste. He thinks I don't get all the cat food out of the sachet when I feed the cat. I try to squeeze all the cat food out but I find it disgusting so I am not going to use a teaspoon and scrap every last bit out of the sachet. I prefer to get as much as I can out by squeezing the sachet and then chucking it in the bin. However, every time I feed the cat, DH goes into the rubbish bin, finds the sachet and then scraps the rest of the cat food out. It drove me a bit crazy for a while and then I just decided to let him go for it. This morning it started to irritated me all over again to see DH rummaging in the bin and then trying to scrap out tiny morsels of cat food from the sachet.

I am the first up in the morning, which is why I feed the cat otherwise I would just leave him to it. Whenever he feeds the cat it is such a palaver that the poor cat is almost beside himself with waiting for something to eat. DH also likes to ration the cat's food to avoid waste so he eeks out the cat food in small portions over the course of the day, which means we have a constantly meowing cat around the house. Drives me crazy.

Ok, so what do you think? Am I being unreasonable? Should I just let DH rummage through the bin for cat food and not care about it?

OP posts:
SunnySideDeepDown · 04/11/2025 17:21

This would infuriate me. He needs to get over it.

Im actually wondering if you’re my SIL as my brother sounds like this 😬

LarryIsMyRomanEmpire · 04/11/2025 17:19

Yes, biscuits is dry food, actually known as kittie cookies in my house.

LarryIsMyRomanEmpire · 04/11/2025 17:18

My cats have unlimited dry food, but only whiskas as they won't eat any other brand, a pouch a day each and treats every night before bed, they're fine on this at 14 and 13, all cats are different but I think it's clear that OPs husband is too stingy to care about them, or ever adjust to their needs like any good cat owner would.

Davros · 04/11/2025 17:16

Can I just ask, when people say “biscuits” for the cat, do they mean dry food? I don’t want my cat missing out on something

DBD1975 · 04/11/2025 16:22

CuddlyPug · 04/11/2025 15:52

My cat has breakfast, lunch, dinner and supper sachets with a constant bowl of biscuits. She has put a tiny bit of weight on and the vet is pleased because she was underweight before. She's still a small skinny cat. She is a Tonkinese though and they are known for their love of food. Your cat sounds half-starved and your husband is definitely scrooge-like.

Mine as well, also has Dreamies but still thinks he is hard done by! 😂

CuddlyPug · 04/11/2025 15:52

My cat has breakfast, lunch, dinner and supper sachets with a constant bowl of biscuits. She has put a tiny bit of weight on and the vet is pleased because she was underweight before. She's still a small skinny cat. She is a Tonkinese though and they are known for their love of food. Your cat sounds half-starved and your husband is definitely scrooge-like.

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 04/11/2025 15:36

but cat doesn't seem to actually like the dry cat food - bulk bought from somewhere like Costco. and it seems to be own brand too.

Miserable and mean.

HeadDeskHeadDesk · 04/11/2025 10:34

maybeinanotherlife06 · 04/11/2025 07:00

This is animal cruelty. Cat is starving . Would he do that too a child ? Would you be on here writing about it ? No . Sort it out or rehome . How would you feel being hungry all day ? Every day . If starve your husband for a while .

Cat isn't starving. Cat has dry kibble down and only the wet food is rationed, presumably due to the cost. He obviously doesn't like to see it dry up and get wasted if it isn't all eaten straight away. Which is fair enough, but half a pouch at a time and if the cat finishes it, give the other half. All this ekeing it out in tiny portions and scraping out every last scrap is ridiculous.

Perhaps they should move to tinned cat food and freeze it in large ice cube blocks then put them loose in a freezer bag. Then they can remove as many as the cat needs each night, leave them to defrost in the fridge ready for the next day and serve them up as required. Zero waste so long as you don't dish up too many cubes at once. All this cutting open and scraping out pouches seems a tad obsessive to me.

NigellaAwesome · 04/11/2025 08:31

The relationship aspect aside, which sounds wearisome, we have one of those M&S oblong soup containers in the door of the fridge that we keep opened cat food sachets in. Its shape keeps it contained and upright. Could you do similar and leave the half opened sachets in there and let your DH scrape them out at his leisure? I also cook a chicken breast for our cat and cut it into tiny chunks - much nicer than icky pouches and it works out the same in price.

maybeinanotherlife06 · 04/11/2025 07:00

This is animal cruelty. Cat is starving . Would he do that too a child ? Would you be on here writing about it ? No . Sort it out or rehome . How would you feel being hungry all day ? Every day . If starve your husband for a while .

limetrees32 · 04/11/2025 06:36

I've not read whole thread but a knife is easier to scrape sides.
And he sounds awful.
Hope he has redeeming features

Gilgogirl · 03/11/2025 23:57

mrsgumpy · 03/11/2025 01:28

The soap story I can barely bring myself to write as I know it is probably even more messed up than the cat food nonsense. But since people have already spotted that the cat food issue likely extends to soap ... The gist is that his grandmother was one of the WW2/depression-era types who kept all the small pieces of soap and then made them into one piece of soap. When she moved into a rest home, he went to visit her and help clear out her house and ... brought back all those pieces of soap for us to use. So not only did we now have lots of tiny pieces of soap to use, but they had already been used by his grandmother.

The kettle story is familiar. I received a fry pan for the last three gift occasions (birthday, anniversary) not because I asked for one but because he wanted them and you can get them with credit card points.

That’s disgusting. I wouldn’t use it and let him enjoy it all by himself. If I were you, I’d keep a lock box of your things just for you. Even if you have to hide it. And as far as the pan thing goes my husband used to buy me Swarovski, I hate it and told him every time he bought me a piece so he didn’t stop I started to buy him Swarovski for his every occasion. He finally got the hint. It took a couple of years. I still have the crap. I’d sell it but it’s worth nothing..

mrsgumpy · 03/11/2025 22:50

Thanks everyone for all the input. It has been really helpful.

So in the short term, I have tried rinsing out the sachets and tipping into the dish as suggested but there is so little in there (it is the jelly brand so most of it just comes out in one blob) although it does help with giving more water and making the bin less smelly. I have been giving the cat a whole sachet in the morning and did again in the evening yesterday (gobbled up). With his favourite biscuits during the day (also gobbled up). So my plan is to be firmer on that.

Now need to work on standing up to husband more. I also find stinginess extremely unattractive. I didn't grow up like this, even when we had little money we were miserly. He didn't used to be as extreme as this. I think I have been a frog in slowly boiling water not realising what has been going on. It has been really helpful reading everyone's replies.

OP posts:
SusiQ18472638 · 03/11/2025 22:18

Nothing less attractive than a miserly, stingy tight arse. I have a friend whose husband is like this, and they earn good money between them. I couldn’t put up with it!

sheistheslayer · 03/11/2025 22:06

CalzoneOnLegs · 03/11/2025 15:16

@GasPanic even a tiny sized cat needs more than 85g of food a day. My cat is large but he has five x 85g sachets plus kibbbles and chicken snacks. He’s a healthy weight for his build. I feel so sad for this cat

See my cat is 7.5kg but he gets 2 x 85g tins and that’s it, no biscuits
he maintains on that and I really need to cut him down to 1.5 tins but it’s hard

Midgetgemsplease · 03/11/2025 21:27

Oldraver · 03/11/2025 20:54

Hold the pouch at the bottom and just flick it side to side, it gets the food out of the creases at the bottom.
I would then wash it out straight away

In the meantime throttle the other half

Or maybe reverse those actions in to the correct order 🤣Seriously tho OP. He won't change. It really depends if you can bear to live like this. My ex would cut a current in half. I divorced him. Skint but happy.

Claire1995 · 03/11/2025 21:05

mrsgumpy · 03/11/2025 20:23

As well-meaning as this post is, this whole scenario sketched out has made me realised how insane my situation is. That reads like an abused wife hiding make up or her secret cellphone from her husband.

Good! I was being sarcastic.

I think I read you have a tuxedo cat I do too.

They are such handsome creatures and he gets so many compliments when he goes to the vets.

My one is very elderly and is on numerous medications a day. He lost a lot of weight and had to be put on thyroid medicine to make him eat more.

Sometimes I feed him and he turns his nose up and he gets another sachet of a different brand until he eats it! Sometimes he eats two sachets in a go and I am delighted!!

Oldraver · 03/11/2025 20:54

Hold the pouch at the bottom and just flick it side to side, it gets the food out of the creases at the bottom.
I would then wash it out straight away

In the meantime throttle the other half

Millytante · 03/11/2025 20:43

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 03/11/2025 15:38

I was just about to say this. Jelly ones are the way to go.

Try that with my two and they'd have me up before the RSPCA, so much do they loathe that jelly. The fussy little minxes. Now they are very old, like meself, and they want maximum slop, interspersed with expensive tiny kibble (tiny owing to scarcity of teef)

Gettingbysomehow · 03/11/2025 20:23

mrsgumpy · 03/11/2025 20:19

Very insightful! I gather from this answer that you have experience with this type of person and how our female empathy can become toxic towards ourselves...

Yet another weird male behaviour apologist 🙄 You wouldnt ever catch me going through bins for a teaspoon of cat leftovers.

mrsgumpy · 03/11/2025 20:23

Claire1995 · 03/11/2025 12:00

There is such a simple and easy way to rectify this, I'm surprised no one has offered it as a solution.

If you are up first thing in the morning feed the cat a whole sachet. You then hide the empty sachet by wrapping it up and putting it in your handbag.

You then refeed the cat again but only give it half a portion, your husband can then eek out the rest of the sachet throughout the course of the day and he can ensure the sachet is fully emptied before binning it.

You then disposed of the original empty sachet at your leisure when you leave the house in a public bin.

This way everyone is happy, the cat is well fed, you don't have to watch your miserly husband rooting through the bin and your husband still gets the pleasure of thinking he is ensuring no waste is allowed to happen.

As well-meaning as this post is, this whole scenario sketched out has made me realised how insane my situation is. That reads like an abused wife hiding make up or her secret cellphone from her husband.

OP posts:
mrsgumpy · 03/11/2025 20:19

Haffiana · 03/11/2025 11:15

OP, why don't you post on the relationships board? This isn't a cat food issue at all.

You must be really miserable, and like all women in your position, at some point you will find that consoling yourself with feeling how understanding and sympathetic you are to your partner's awful upbringing/mental health/difficulties/whatever will not be enough for you. That daily demonstrating how careful you are with money and not wasting stuff etc etc, and that surely he can trust you and relax a bit blah blah, will NEVER make a difference and will NEVER be enough.

Post on relationships and get some help in considering the next steps in the rest of your life.

Very insightful! I gather from this answer that you have experience with this type of person and how our female empathy can become toxic towards ourselves...

OP posts:
randomgeneratedusername1 · 03/11/2025 16:00

I have 4 cats and I use a knife to get there food out of the sachets because I can’t bear to get it on my hands 😂 it does all come out though . They have their own knife too. 😂

Nearly50omg · 03/11/2025 15:55

GaudySocks · 02/11/2025 20:32

When you say he rations the cat food out, are you saying he’s deliberately underfeeding the cat? If so, LTB

Starving the poor cat!!! Leave the bastard!! Start rationing his food out and see how he likes it!! He’s cruel as well as mean!!

JHound · 03/11/2025 15:49

OvernightBloats · 03/11/2025 15:40

Yuck! All those germs from other peoples' drinks - revolting. He must have a very strong stomach and zero shame.

ZERO shame. His tight-fistedness overruled shame.

I was so ashamed I dumped him.

Swipe left for the next trending thread