Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband going through bin for cat food

364 replies

mrsgumpy · 02/11/2025 20:25

So I need some perspective on this. And yes I know it is ridiculous to be arguing about cat food.

My husband hates waste. He thinks I don't get all the cat food out of the sachet when I feed the cat. I try to squeeze all the cat food out but I find it disgusting so I am not going to use a teaspoon and scrap every last bit out of the sachet. I prefer to get as much as I can out by squeezing the sachet and then chucking it in the bin. However, every time I feed the cat, DH goes into the rubbish bin, finds the sachet and then scraps the rest of the cat food out. It drove me a bit crazy for a while and then I just decided to let him go for it. This morning it started to irritated me all over again to see DH rummaging in the bin and then trying to scrap out tiny morsels of cat food from the sachet.

I am the first up in the morning, which is why I feed the cat otherwise I would just leave him to it. Whenever he feeds the cat it is such a palaver that the poor cat is almost beside himself with waiting for something to eat. DH also likes to ration the cat's food to avoid waste so he eeks out the cat food in small portions over the course of the day, which means we have a constantly meowing cat around the house. Drives me crazy.

Ok, so what do you think? Am I being unreasonable? Should I just let DH rummage through the bin for cat food and not care about it?

OP posts:
BagpussWasRight · 05/11/2025 13:52

I was thinking about your situation this morning when i fed my little tortie.
I have just come home from the vets, where I sat next to a lovely, kind man, probably in his late thirties, who spoke about his old cat, and mine, with such humour and gentleness that it made me tearful, because my husband would never have done or felt this, which is why pets were a no-no for me and our children.
But reading that your husband calls you slovenly and wasteful has made me really angry, I think he resents your cat, I think he secretly hates it, and my gut feeling is that he is seething with contempt.
His obsessive, determined checking of the bins is exactly the same mindset as a man who would go through your phone/purchases/receipts/quiz you about where you have been etc. i.e. a nasty control freak.
If you can do this safely, I would record, or listen outside the door, to see if he has a running commentary when he is picking through the bin, that will tell you who he is when he thinks no one can hear him.😪

ThreePointOneFourOneFiveNine · 05/11/2025 06:47

mrsgumpy · 05/11/2025 06:27

Yes, many times. It always gets framed back at me as that I am wasteful and slovenly.

Please leave him. This is no way to live.

mrsgumpy · 05/11/2025 06:27

ThreePointOneFourOneFiveNine · 04/11/2025 19:48

Have you tried talking to your husband about his strange behaviour?

Yes, many times. It always gets framed back at me as that I am wasteful and slovenly.

OP posts:
mondaytosunday · 04/11/2025 23:05

Poor cat. Your DH is nuts.

Wexone · 04/11/2025 22:54

BlueMum16 · 04/11/2025 21:22

I've not read all the replies.

Sachets used to be 100g each. Most are now 85g. Recommended 2 or 3 per cat PER day.

You are starving your cat.

I buy the jelly sachets rather than gravy. It slides out whole so no waste.

they were sly doing that weren't they. took me a while before I copped the sachets were smaller
op your lucky you not in my house one of my dogs watches the cats closely and if the cat walks away from it food before bowl is empty the dog runs in and wolfs it down - and dog is well fed before anyone jumps on me just loves cat food ( the vet says it's quite common) so I have the begging eyes from the cat when he sees his bowl empty so of course I give him another pouch 🤣

Floatingdownriver · 04/11/2025 21:29

OP, please don’t live like this. You have one life. This is no way to spend it. Please don’t breed with this man. However much you feel sorry for him or believe your love can fix him. It won’t. Take the cat and go love him life. Leave the soap though.

BlueMum16 · 04/11/2025 21:22

mrsgumpy · 02/11/2025 20:51

I think the cat needs at least 2 pouches/sachets a day plus biscuits. DH gives the cat 1/2 a sachet in the morning and 1/2 in the evening. It is a long-standing dispute. The cat is very active outside (the most athletic member of the family).

I've not read all the replies.

Sachets used to be 100g each. Most are now 85g. Recommended 2 or 3 per cat PER day.

You are starving your cat.

I buy the jelly sachets rather than gravy. It slides out whole so no waste.

OhDearMuriel · 04/11/2025 21:16

It’s cruel.
Honestly you shouldn’t have cats.

FatCyclist · 04/11/2025 21:13

mrsgumpy · 04/11/2025 19:47

The responses have really made me reflect on far more examples of this beyond the cat food. Really appreciate everyone's perspectives.

In terms of the cat though, he really is beautifully healthy and people often comment on it. I am giving him one sachet in the morning, one at night, and biscuits at other times. I did notice this morning that shortly after I fed him (whole sachet plus biscuits) that he got up from his sleep in the sun when I came in the room and immediately started meowing for food. He is a pretty vocal cat generally. BUT I am certain that if DH had his way, he would only be getting one sachet a day. I have decided to completely take over the feeding and not put up with DH's miserliness. On occasion the cat had been getting into our food - like bread (in its plastic bag) left on the bench - so surely that is a sign of him being hungry? It is really icky and depressing, as people have said, to see someone eeking out cat food from a sachet in small portions.

I started out thinking you DH sounds a bit odd. After reading all your posts I think you & your poor sweet cat need to have a serious think about whether you really need this man in your life. I suspect that this bizarre cat food thing your DH does has nothing to do with cat food at all: it’s a way of

  • signalling his extreme disapproval of you feeding the cat 2 pouches a day,
  • signalling his disapproval/resentment of the cat (was the decision to get a cat because you wanted one but him not so much? Do you show love/affection toward the cat & he’s jealous?)
  • signalling disapproval of how you do things generally (nothing you do is good enough)

If this was purely an extreme form of parsimony it makes no sense: it is much better for cats, particularly male cats with their very long thin urethras that are easily blocked, to eat wet food rather than dry. Unblocking a cat is a very expensive medical emergency (typical cost £1500-£2000) and if not done the cat dies an agonising death after a few days. So trying to save money by feeding fewer pouches is insane.

I think your husband has some very complex issues that manifest in this very odd way. The good news is that these kinds of conditions respond very well to psychotherapy… IF your DH is able to accept he has a problem and is committed to working with a therapist to address them.

And the bits of soap… EWWWWWWWWWWW!!! There are all sorts of funguses & things that can live on soaps (you never find bars of soaps in clinical settings: only liquid soaps you squeeze from a dispenser. There’s a reason for that.) Forcing you to use ancient bits of soap that other people have used is one of the most disgusting, controlling, & just fucking horrible things I’ve heard.

Please, take your sweet cat and leave this saddo. Or better yet throw him out. Join the ranks of Single Cat Ladies Society.

PermanentDarkMode · 04/11/2025 20:06

Personally I would rinse the sachet in hot water and a little bit of washing up liquid so it was nice and shiny and clean...then bin it for tight arse to find!

ThreePointOneFourOneFiveNine · 04/11/2025 19:48

Have you tried talking to your husband about his strange behaviour?

mrsgumpy · 04/11/2025 19:47

The responses have really made me reflect on far more examples of this beyond the cat food. Really appreciate everyone's perspectives.

In terms of the cat though, he really is beautifully healthy and people often comment on it. I am giving him one sachet in the morning, one at night, and biscuits at other times. I did notice this morning that shortly after I fed him (whole sachet plus biscuits) that he got up from his sleep in the sun when I came in the room and immediately started meowing for food. He is a pretty vocal cat generally. BUT I am certain that if DH had his way, he would only be getting one sachet a day. I have decided to completely take over the feeding and not put up with DH's miserliness. On occasion the cat had been getting into our food - like bread (in its plastic bag) left on the bench - so surely that is a sign of him being hungry? It is really icky and depressing, as people have said, to see someone eeking out cat food from a sachet in small portions.

OP posts:
mrsgumpy · 04/11/2025 19:35

Randomlygeneratedname · 04/11/2025 17:39

Just buy the ones in jelly. I refuse to use the gravy ones as they slop out and you have the squeeze them, the jelly ones drop right out with no leftovers.

We have the jelly ones. Husband still thinks he can scrape out the dregs. I have started rinsing as suggested and tip water into dish and barely anything is coming out.

OP posts:
poetryandwine · 04/11/2025 18:54

This sounds incredibly difficult, OP. I think I would have difficulty feeling physical affection at any level towards someone who treated me this way. I would not be wanting to share a bed

But I don’t think cats need wet food if they can have high quality kibble (the small biscuits) on demand. Our beautiful, shiny female thrived on a diet of dry food, a small bowl of morning milk, plenty of water and the odd treat of a small portion of liver, fish, giblets, etc. She finally had to be PTS age 17

whistlesandbells · 04/11/2025 18:40

Doesnt DH going through the bin to scrape dregs disgust you more than scraping the sachet yourself? Honestly, it’s a close run thing.

Cat sounds like it is underfed and the constant mewing would be unbearable for me. Buy the sachets with jelly so it all slides out. Feed the cat what you want. I would also start removing the sachets from the main bin and disposing of them without him being able to interfere. I’d also refuse to discuss it. Your husband is seriously unreasonable and icky!

LarryIsMyRomanEmpire · 04/11/2025 18:26

That sounds like you're the cat, of so, mine go mad for lick e lix.

Davros · 04/11/2025 18:24

@LarryIsMyRomanEmpire thanks, I didn’t want to miss out on some treat

RoseAlone · 04/11/2025 18:20

I'm a pet sitter and despite my better judgement, I can kind of understand it depending on the cat food. Applaws in sachets are particularly bad, half the food can easily be left in the folds in the bottom of the sachet, there's no option but to dig around the bottom and even then it's torture trying to get it all out.

Switch to a decent brand and avoid the garbage foods like wiskas and Felix, get one that comes in a tin and the problem will be solved.

Pedallleur · 04/11/2025 18:17

Just sounds mad. As a pp said cut the sachets into strips.Or I would just throw the 'empty' sachet in a public waste bin when going to town or work.

LarryIsMyRomanEmpire · 04/11/2025 18:08

@FurForksSake
One of mine adores mushrooms.

outerspacepotato · 04/11/2025 18:06

I think your husband should eat less than half his daily food for a while.

Why would you stay with a guy who's so miserly he abuses your cat by starving it?

He had you showering with his grandmother's soap scraps.

Get the hell out and take the cat. This guy has got a screw loose and you need to do the Freedom Program and get therapy as to why you thought it was remotely ok to live like this.

FurForksSake · 04/11/2025 18:01

My cat likes a custard cream biscuit, but only once it has been dunked.

Randomlygeneratedname · 04/11/2025 17:39

Just buy the ones in jelly. I refuse to use the gravy ones as they slop out and you have the squeeze them, the jelly ones drop right out with no leftovers.

caringcarer · 04/11/2025 17:36

mrsgumpy · 02/11/2025 20:51

I think the cat needs at least 2 pouches/sachets a day plus biscuits. DH gives the cat 1/2 a sachet in the morning and 1/2 in the evening. It is a long-standing dispute. The cat is very active outside (the most athletic member of the family).

Your DH is starving the cat. You are lucky it has not run away and found another home. It needs 2 sachets a day and the kibble. Just feed it more yourself otherwise you are knowingly see the cat underfed.

fan783 · 04/11/2025 17:31

Forget leaving him to feed the cat and just leave him.

Why on earth are you with this miserable little man OP?

Swipe left for the next trending thread