Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband going through bin for cat food

364 replies

mrsgumpy · 02/11/2025 20:25

So I need some perspective on this. And yes I know it is ridiculous to be arguing about cat food.

My husband hates waste. He thinks I don't get all the cat food out of the sachet when I feed the cat. I try to squeeze all the cat food out but I find it disgusting so I am not going to use a teaspoon and scrap every last bit out of the sachet. I prefer to get as much as I can out by squeezing the sachet and then chucking it in the bin. However, every time I feed the cat, DH goes into the rubbish bin, finds the sachet and then scraps the rest of the cat food out. It drove me a bit crazy for a while and then I just decided to let him go for it. This morning it started to irritated me all over again to see DH rummaging in the bin and then trying to scrap out tiny morsels of cat food from the sachet.

I am the first up in the morning, which is why I feed the cat otherwise I would just leave him to it. Whenever he feeds the cat it is such a palaver that the poor cat is almost beside himself with waiting for something to eat. DH also likes to ration the cat's food to avoid waste so he eeks out the cat food in small portions over the course of the day, which means we have a constantly meowing cat around the house. Drives me crazy.

Ok, so what do you think? Am I being unreasonable? Should I just let DH rummage through the bin for cat food and not care about it?

OP posts:
Gilgogirl · 02/11/2025 22:41

mrsgumpy · 02/11/2025 22:29

"It isn't just the cat food, is it? It will be the soap, the toilet roll, the food bill, the lack of nights out, the mean small grudging birthday presents, the careful halving of all expenses, the whole sad misery of the miser's life."

Omg, yes.

I wouldn’t be able to live squeezing out the last dab toothpaste but I’m good at it but you’re being controlled by a miser. Scrooge is it. Ridiculous and don’t put up with it.

mrsgumpy · 02/11/2025 22:40

gillefc82 · 02/11/2025 22:15

I’d add that if you’re genuinely concerned that the cat is being underfed, you’re essentially complicit in the neglect if you just sit back and let it happen. If there is a worry over its weight / health then there needs to be a very serious conversation with your DH about this and the possible consequences for your marriage if he doesn’t change his approach. Don’t be afraid to involve your vet if you think some independent and qualified validation is necessary to ensure your DH takes this seriously and you reach the right outcome.

I don't think the cat is being neglected - he is absolutely beautiful looking with a shiny coat. But I have to be the one to feed him. We do leave biscuits out constantly in an automatic feeder. He just doesn't like them much (they are the bulk by ones from Costco, because of course). So I buy the more expensive ones to give him in addition. The battle is mostly over the wet food.

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 02/11/2025 22:38

mrsgumpy · 02/11/2025 22:33

The problem is that if I leave him to feed the cat, the cat has the single sachet eeked over over the course of the day. If I feed him, I know he is going to get the whole sachet in the morning.

Am currently going through everyone's replies and slowly processing. Will write more soon. I appreciate everyone's insights.

You’re getting a sachet eked out too, aren’t you?

The cat is your spirit animal in all this. Try to be more concerned about yourself because this is no way to live.

Midgetgemsplease · 02/11/2025 22:37

Fml that behaviour would give me the ick. I USED to be married to one like that. Use dry food ( my cat loves applaws) then there's no palaver and no stinky sachets. It's less packaging waste and I believe, better for their little teeth.

CommanderTaggart · 02/11/2025 22:36

He is tightfisted and mean and cares more about the money in his own pocket than the health and happiness of your poor little cat.

I would find it difficult to like let alone live with somebody like this.

helloplease · 02/11/2025 22:34

I'd get rid ! Of the husband but keep the cat - he is unbelievably tight and mean, to leave your cat to go hungry.

EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · 02/11/2025 22:33

I’d put the sachet at the bottom of the outside bin and let him hunt for it every day. Would be rather enjoyable when it rained.

mrsgumpy · 02/11/2025 22:33

gillefc82 · 02/11/2025 22:08

This! If he’s going to be so pedantic about it, let him do it.

The problem is that if I leave him to feed the cat, the cat has the single sachet eeked over over the course of the day. If I feed him, I know he is going to get the whole sachet in the morning.

Am currently going through everyone's replies and slowly processing. Will write more soon. I appreciate everyone's insights.

OP posts:
littlbrowndog · 02/11/2025 22:32

GoldDuster · 02/11/2025 22:19

There doesn't need to be a debate about how much the cat needs feeding, you can work that out, the information for the brand vs your cat's weight and age will be out there.

Work that out, then start to give your cat that amount of food, so if that's two pouches, then feed it two pouches, and let him scrat about in the bin as much as he likes. Not your problem. I really wouldn't join in by leaving the pouches to one side for his inspection and sign off, don't play the game.

Once that's sorted you should have some head space clear to work out if you want to spend the rest of this one short life with a man who underfeeds a cat and fishes used cat food packaging out of the bin so he can scrape them out with a spoon. You're a long time dead OP.

Yep

TalulahJP · 02/11/2025 22:31

How long is the dry food being left uneaten for before it’s tossed?

im going to suggest that bastard is too damn tight so the same dry food is left day in day out. No wonder the cat doesn't eat it. It will have dust and fly eggs on it. You need to throw it out if uneaten.

You need to tell him that this tightness is ridiculous and youre done with it and start feeding the cat properly.

how can you let this continue? The cats crying FFS. You need to sort it. Now. Get him told. 12 sachets cost under a fiver here. Not dear. The cat should have at least two a day.

Id make him his dinner as usual and then split it between the two of you. Say a lasagne or something. So it’s obvious it’s a half portion.

When he says he’s still hungry offer him dry bread. If he says WTF just say now you know what the cat feels like, still hungry or eat bread (or cat biscuits for the cat), oh and btw it’s been lying out all day so the breads a bit crispy but I’m sure it’ll be fine….

See how he likes it. Ridiculous behaviour. I don’t know how you can put up with it tbh.

HelenaWaiting · 02/11/2025 22:31

You should tell him in no uncertain terms that it is two sachets a day plus biscuits, and that if he continues to starve the cat you will report him to the RSPCA.

NamelessNancy · 02/11/2025 22:30

JeminaTheGiantBear · 02/11/2025 22:28

I am worried abour cat! My sachets say 3 or 4 a day. I feed 3 plus various improving snacks (dental, hairball) and cat still wails tragically for a fourth. If your sachets say similar then DH is starving the poor creature!

The cat gets dried food also and as I said above the question as to whether it is eating enough is answered by whether it is a healthy weight/losing/gaining. Not what someone else's cat eats or a packet says.

mrsgumpy · 02/11/2025 22:29

Haffiana · 02/11/2025 21:48

Do you have children, OP? Does he do this with them? Ration their treats, count the pennies?

If you do not - then you need to really think carefully about whether you want your children to have this as their father.

He has a mental illness. It is as intractable and incurable as hoarding. It will never get better and it will never go away. He will never, ever see things any other way than this.

It isn't just the cat food, is it? It will be the soap, the toilet roll, the food bill, the lack of nights out, the mean small grudging birthday presents, the careful halving of all expenses, the whole sad misery of the miser's life.

Eventually you will see the light and be repulsed by him. Then you will hate him. It will be so much easier if you get to that stage sooner rather than later.

"It isn't just the cat food, is it? It will be the soap, the toilet roll, the food bill, the lack of nights out, the mean small grudging birthday presents, the careful halving of all expenses, the whole sad misery of the miser's life."

Omg, yes.

OP posts:
gottakeeponmoving · 02/11/2025 22:29

Definitely look for jelly food. Whiskers Poultry in Jelly slides out whole.

JeminaTheGiantBear · 02/11/2025 22:28

mrsgumpy · 02/11/2025 20:51

I think the cat needs at least 2 pouches/sachets a day plus biscuits. DH gives the cat 1/2 a sachet in the morning and 1/2 in the evening. It is a long-standing dispute. The cat is very active outside (the most athletic member of the family).

I am worried abour cat! My sachets say 3 or 4 a day. I feed 3 plus various improving snacks (dental, hairball) and cat still wails tragically for a fourth. If your sachets say similar then DH is starving the poor creature!

FullOfMomsense · 02/11/2025 22:26

Tbf my cats gets one wet food sachet a day, split in half morn and evening, and dry food available at all times? I think that's pretty standard but if you feel your cat needs more then they need more!

Might be a rogue idea but could you order a bulk load of cat food (amazon maybe) and say you got a good deal on it, so kitty cat doesn't have rationed food?

Are you finances joined? Is there a chance you're in financial difficulty and unaware?

Gilgogirl · 02/11/2025 22:25

mrsgumpy · 02/11/2025 20:51

I think the cat needs at least 2 pouches/sachets a day plus biscuits. DH gives the cat 1/2 a sachet in the morning and 1/2 in the evening. It is a long-standing dispute. The cat is very active outside (the most athletic member of the family).

How cheap can he get, does he like the cat.

mullers1977 · 02/11/2025 22:25

AnOldCynic · 02/11/2025 20:56

Personally I think YABU for not washing out the sachets and recycling them…

They can’t go in normal recycling - do you use terra cycle ?

snackatack · 02/11/2025 22:24

Have you not tried meat in jelly? It come out in one lump - my cats eat the whole lot. so no waste

It is far less icky

NamelessNancy · 02/11/2025 22:23

If the cat is a healthy weight and remaining so it is being fed the right amount.

If the cat is overweight or gaining unhealthily it is being overfed.

If the cat is underweight or losing weight unhealthily it is being underfed.

KellsBells7 · 02/11/2025 22:21

Your husband is a cruel arsehole. I would give him the choice of a properly fed cat or divorce. This thread has made me so sad.

NCembarassed · 02/11/2025 22:20

mrsgumpy · 02/11/2025 20:51

I think the cat needs at least 2 pouches/sachets a day plus biscuits. DH gives the cat 1/2 a sachet in the morning and 1/2 in the evening. It is a long-standing dispute. The cat is very active outside (the most athletic member of the family).

I agree your cat might be underfed. DCat has an annual checkup, which records her weight as well as other stuff. I use that to base her food on, as I'd probably overfeed otherwise. At 4kg (standard sized cat, and pure muscle) she gets 2 pouches per day, plus very occasional snacks of cheese (has to be quality cheddar or won't touch it) or cooked meat from our dinner (little bugger adores my spicy cooking, the more heat, the more she likes).

Her food is 100% meat though, which is filling. Our cat is practically voiceless, so if she cries it means she is very hungry (rare) or unhappy. We get the occasional happy 'eep' in greeting, but it's unusual for her. I know other people have quite 'talkative cats by comparison. I hate the idea your cat might be hungry.

GoldDuster · 02/11/2025 22:19

There doesn't need to be a debate about how much the cat needs feeding, you can work that out, the information for the brand vs your cat's weight and age will be out there.

Work that out, then start to give your cat that amount of food, so if that's two pouches, then feed it two pouches, and let him scrat about in the bin as much as he likes. Not your problem. I really wouldn't join in by leaving the pouches to one side for his inspection and sign off, don't play the game.

Once that's sorted you should have some head space clear to work out if you want to spend the rest of this one short life with a man who underfeeds a cat and fishes used cat food packaging out of the bin so he can scrape them out with a spoon. You're a long time dead OP.

mrsgumpy · 02/11/2025 22:18

MagpiePi · 02/11/2025 21:33

Why don’t you act like a responsible adult and give it the correct amount of food instead of tiptoeing round your dick of a husband?
The poor cat is starving. It is cruel and you should be ashamed of yourself.

Thank you. I do feed him - hence why DH has been going through the rubbish bins to get the sachets. But when I am out (eg: at work) or away then DH is responsible. Tbc, there are always biscuits left out in a feeder. It is just that the cat prefers the wet food.

OP posts:
BadLuckNameChange · 02/11/2025 22:17

mrsgumpy · 02/11/2025 20:42

Yeah, that is another argument we have. He thinks he isn't under-feeding him. I think he is. And so it goes.

Oh love, no.

No “and so it goes.”

NO.

This life is so, so short. The days may seem long but then one day, you’re crossing the street and you’ll never even see the bus that hits you. And up until that moment, THIS will have been your life.

You are not required to put up with anything for any reason. If it’s diagnosed OCD, even that doesn’t make this acceptable - there is nothing that makes “rationing” a cat’s food throughout the day any better. And I suspect he probably does it to you too, in a way, when you mentioned no treats or “extravagances.”

Give yourself the very non-extravagant gift of a lifetime free of this shittery. Regardless of your age, it’s never too late for you and Dcat to start a new life together where you can both have as much of whatever you like to eat at any time.

Please. Think about it before dismissing it as impossible. Maybe you’d have to get your ducks in a row, but freedom is worth it.

Love yourself as much as you love your cat. You don’t want your cat to have to put up with your husband’s shite, and you shouldn’t have to either.