Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To be a bit stunned by Lily Allen’s new album

816 replies

AngeloMysterioso · 24/10/2025 11:33

Oooofff. I mean it might as well be called Fuck You David Harbour, You Cheating Bastard. Safe to say she’s set a new bar for diaristic songwriting. I feel so sad for her, I know she’s not everyone’s favourite person but it’s always been clear that all she wanted was to love and be loved and she seemed so happy with him- he popped up on her podcast with Miquita Oliver a few times and seemed so genuine in the way he spoke about her… for it to all collapse in such spectacularly public and hideous fashion must have been awful to endure, so I don’t blame her for working through it by going back to what she does best but still… blimey. I feel like I’ve been spying in their bedroom or something after listening to it!

OP posts:
RaspberryCloud · 25/10/2025 10:17

AngeloMysterioso · 24/10/2025 11:41

It’s… quite something! Cara de la Hoyde has just said in an insta story “if you’re having a bad day today, just remember you’re not David Harbour” 😂 matey has one hell of an awkward press tour coming his way!! Think a lot of Stranger Things/Marvel fans won’t be looking at him the same way ever again…

I certainly will be looking at Hopper differently! 🤨 will need to mentally separate them to still enjoy it 😅

Volpini · 25/10/2025 10:08

VivienneDelacroix · 24/10/2025 14:08

I think the album is great.
I'm a bit on the fence about Lily, but it sounds like she agreed to an open relationship for him and it went very badly.
I can sympathise with this, I (admittedly in my very early 20s, not mid-30s) agreed to a similar agreement because I desperately wanted to be with the charming, charismatic older man - who it turned out was a very damaged, mentally unwell, addict. I'd have bloody loved to have written an album and dragged him through the mud.

I love Lily in all her unfiltered drama.
Despite what people have written to the contrary, she’s so gifted.
i was fully prepared to hate this album but actually, beyond the reason it’s drawing attention, i really like it. It’s hooked me straight away.
I hope she starts her second act without him.
And I hope David Harbour gets flayed in the next season.

Happyjoe · 25/10/2025 09:47

Mangetoutmangetouti · 25/10/2025 09:22

Sadly , I can corroborate this story.
It was a well known event among the Primrose Hill set back in the day.

fortnightly on a Wednesday afternoon, Jude collected his dole money and then straight to the grocers.

he was just going about his daily business but somehow word got out about his routine.

he started being mithered by fawning adoration from fans and harassment from men and women of the press.

he just wanted to get home and start his batch cooking so he devised a cunning plan to keep people beyond arms length and thus the extra bag of onions was born .

most of us locals knew to keep our heads down and treat him like any other stranger in the street - once you’ve been bruised by a flying onion, you soon learn your lesson and give him the space he craves.

but he always bought extra onions to hoy at mitherers just in case.
Tragically he often had cause to use them 🧅🧅🧅

Grins, very funny! :-)

Happyjoe · 25/10/2025 09:45

Firealarm1414 · 25/10/2025 03:01

Sorry, what?! He threw onions at you? 😄I've rarely felt the need to laugh out loud on reading a post. Did this really happen? Obviously more details are required

Lol, yes it really did happen! It was when him and Sadie were getting divorced and was sent down there to their house, well, Sadies house and he was walking back with his shopping. He was so angry about it, he lost it. Fair enough, not exactly the best time in his life I presume.
Luckily don't work in the media now, not for some years so no more onions. I do hope he had to go back to the shop though and get himself some more.. :-)

Cherrytree86 · 25/10/2025 09:44

Toseland · 24/10/2025 12:37

I've not forgiven her for claiming she "didn't know how many abortions she'd had" and laughing about it; not because I'm anti-abortion, but because it shouldn't be used as contraception and she is in an influential position for young women.

@Toseland

what makes you think we has used abortions as a means of contraception?
it’s her body her choice at the end of the day

WeirdyBeardyMarrowBabyLady · 25/10/2025 09:43

I used to find her very tiresome and I wouldn’t have sought out the new album but for reading the reviews. Having had a listen it’s pretty good I think. It’s certainly entertaining as a massive fuck you.

I know he’s not the father to her daughters but I do wonder about the decision to move them to NYC on a whim when their lives (and presumably their father) are in the UK. I can’t imagine how chaotic their lives have been. Perhaps it’s just part and parcel of being a celeb child and they adapt but still.

The final thing is that I loved Stranger Things when it came out (stopped at season 2 tho so just a fleeting thing) but Hopper was such a great character and I think in my head I’d assumed DH was basically just like Hopper in RL. Clearly not. I’ll never look at him the same way again!

Mangetoutmangetouti · 25/10/2025 09:22

Firealarm1414 · 25/10/2025 03:01

Sorry, what?! He threw onions at you? 😄I've rarely felt the need to laugh out loud on reading a post. Did this really happen? Obviously more details are required

Sadly , I can corroborate this story.
It was a well known event among the Primrose Hill set back in the day.

fortnightly on a Wednesday afternoon, Jude collected his dole money and then straight to the grocers.

he was just going about his daily business but somehow word got out about his routine.

he started being mithered by fawning adoration from fans and harassment from men and women of the press.

he just wanted to get home and start his batch cooking so he devised a cunning plan to keep people beyond arms length and thus the extra bag of onions was born .

most of us locals knew to keep our heads down and treat him like any other stranger in the street - once you’ve been bruised by a flying onion, you soon learn your lesson and give him the space he craves.

but he always bought extra onions to hoy at mitherers just in case.
Tragically he often had cause to use them 🧅🧅🧅

IggysPop · 25/10/2025 09:19

I think this album is outstanding. Not really into her music before - I might be just a bit too old to have caught her earlier stuff.

But - this thread has given me pause for thought and I am not sure why. It has really made me think about how it must feel to be dissected by people who don’t know me, and some of it being quite vitriolic. It is as if she’s not a real human being.

Mangetoutmangetouti · 25/10/2025 09:04

leftorrightnow · 25/10/2025 02:18

Maybe she’s just really fertile. I can only thank my PCO for having had only two abortions I can tell you that. I was ridiculously careless in my twenties. When I think back on it I can’t believe it actually. Except, I do know I was wasted half the time and mentally unstable. I just wasn’t thinking clearly. If you’ve lived your whole life in control you likely have no idea what I’m talking about. Good for you. But don’t judge others whose lives have been much more difficult than yours. She’s joking about the abortions because it’s too painful to be honest about how she feels. Everyone knows dark humor is a trauma response.

Edited

Hundred percent this

Mangetoutmangetouti · 25/10/2025 08:59

leftorrightnow · 25/10/2025 02:13

I like her. She’s honest and raw. Take her over Taylor swift or some other polished Barbie doll any day- it always makes me laugh when people say TS is so honest and open shen she’s so American and polished, yes she shared some bad relationship so tired but everything so sanitized and nothing too shocking.

sad to hear Lily had been treated badly.
She’s a heroine for all those of us who’ve had messy and less than perfect lives and had relationships we regret and abortions and twenties were we probably partied too much. Yep, that’s me and I like it when someone else makes me feel less alone and ashamed.

Yes.
It’s only black and white for some people and unfortunately many of those never learn the nuances, moralising and remain judgmental with little understanding, empathy or compassion for the reality of many.
sadly these black and white thinkers are often in positions of influence or authority over those who are more vulnerable.
the attitudes and disrespect towards those in need of support sadly perpetuate things like poor understanding of how to manage contraception because they alienate those in need of support

Superhansrantowindsor · 25/10/2025 08:15

Looked up her wiki entry after this thread yesterday. She had an affair with a married man too so no sympathy. I have always found her talking style of singing irritating enough to turn the radio off when she’s played.

Charlize43 · 25/10/2025 08:05

SwingTheMonkey · 25/10/2025 03:32

I most stunned that people actually rate LA as a musician. I literally don’t know a single person who has ever viewed her as anything other than a talentless nepo baby.

^This. And given the fact that she has no singing talent or artist credibility whatsoever (give me Celeste, any day).

Would we have even heard of LA if it was for her producer mother and famous father's connections? Most of her career is PR aimed at NPCs who'll think she's 'edgy' because that's the image they've worked so hard to craft for her. I think it was hugely predictable and very cringe that she was going to play out her marital drama in a CD, or book, or endless rounds of interviews.

There are plenty of talentless celebrities, but few so relentlessly annoying and attention seeking.

fortinbra · 25/10/2025 04:26

AngeloMysterioso · 25/10/2025 01:29

Happily the judgement of random strangers on the internet has absolutely fuck all effect on my actual real life so, you do you!

😅

fortinbra · 25/10/2025 04:24

SouthernNights59 · 25/10/2025 01:25

How would she be 'forced' to have unwanted babies? Contraception has been around for quite a long time and while accidents can happen someone would have to be spectacularly stupid to get pregnant multiple times and think that abortion is the only answer.

I judge both her and you.

We will all make a note that you officially judge Lily Allen and the OP

fortinbra · 25/10/2025 04:22

SpidersAreShitheads · 25/10/2025 03:42

I agree with PP - I was pretty appalled by her really irresponsible attitude towards having terminations.

It’s not the fact that she had terminations, that’s her business - but laughing about them and not being able to remember how many you had is pretty shocking.

You don’t need to wear a sack cloth or self-flagellate but acting as if terminations can be treated casually, carried out multiple times on a whim - and with thought for possible consequences - is unbelievably arrogant and irresponsible. Many terminations are straightforward. Some are not. And some women struggle afterwards unexpectedly. There are very good reasons why the medical profession don’t advise that terminations are treated as a regular alternative to proper contraception.

I understand that there are people on this thread who seem determined to defend her at all costs. It seems bizarre to me when she has a long history of pretty vile behaviour, even setting her attitude to terminations aside.

Like most people I dislike, I wouldn’t actively seek out her music but if it came on the radio or TV, I wouldn’t automatically turn it over. I prefer to avoid putting money in the pockets of people who I don’t like; similarly, I would deliberately try to support any artist that I liked who I thought was a decent person.

I think actions matter and I prefer to focus my support towards people who I think make a positive contribution to the world. LA has consistently shown herself to be entirely self-absorbed and rather unpleasant.

I think the moralising about women having abortions is awful and outdated. She is clearly being deliberately defiant because she's tired of lifetime of shit from the tabloids - she knows she's going to be judged so she's developed a defence. I've noticed she will often laugh when discussing serious topics - I actually think it's a mixture of bravado and in the past immaturity. It doesn't mean she didn't have more complicated feelings about the abortions. People are complicated.

SpidersAreShitheads · 25/10/2025 03:42

I agree with PP - I was pretty appalled by her really irresponsible attitude towards having terminations.

It’s not the fact that she had terminations, that’s her business - but laughing about them and not being able to remember how many you had is pretty shocking.

You don’t need to wear a sack cloth or self-flagellate but acting as if terminations can be treated casually, carried out multiple times on a whim - and with thought for possible consequences - is unbelievably arrogant and irresponsible. Many terminations are straightforward. Some are not. And some women struggle afterwards unexpectedly. There are very good reasons why the medical profession don’t advise that terminations are treated as a regular alternative to proper contraception.

I understand that there are people on this thread who seem determined to defend her at all costs. It seems bizarre to me when she has a long history of pretty vile behaviour, even setting her attitude to terminations aside.

Like most people I dislike, I wouldn’t actively seek out her music but if it came on the radio or TV, I wouldn’t automatically turn it over. I prefer to avoid putting money in the pockets of people who I don’t like; similarly, I would deliberately try to support any artist that I liked who I thought was a decent person.

I think actions matter and I prefer to focus my support towards people who I think make a positive contribution to the world. LA has consistently shown herself to be entirely self-absorbed and rather unpleasant.

SwingTheMonkey · 25/10/2025 03:32

I most stunned that people actually rate LA as a musician. I literally don’t know a single person who has ever viewed her as anything other than a talentless nepo baby.

Firealarm1414 · 25/10/2025 03:01

Happyjoe · 25/10/2025 00:00

Threw onions at me, full on rage. Must be pushing 20 years ago now. The onions came out of his shopping bag that he had with him. Funny now I look back but at the time it was a bit surreal and a bit startling. I worked in the media at the time so more than likely deserved it, but I still avoid seeing his face where I can!

Edited

Sorry, what?! He threw onions at you? 😄I've rarely felt the need to laugh out loud on reading a post. Did this really happen? Obviously more details are required

Bigneonsign · 25/10/2025 02:22

They're not actually divorced yet, are they? Wonder if this might impact the financial order...

It's a great album. Gut punch lyrics and spikey stories with beautiful string arrangements and melodies, and then bopping beats. It's very good and very clever.
Have been reading about it - written and recorded in just over two weeks (some of the greatest ever pop songs were written in minutes) and then fully produced (with the strings etc added) over six weeks.

leftorrightnow · 25/10/2025 02:18

AngeloMysterioso · 25/10/2025 01:29

Happily the judgement of random strangers on the internet has absolutely fuck all effect on my actual real life so, you do you!

Maybe she’s just really fertile. I can only thank my PCO for having had only two abortions I can tell you that. I was ridiculously careless in my twenties. When I think back on it I can’t believe it actually. Except, I do know I was wasted half the time and mentally unstable. I just wasn’t thinking clearly. If you’ve lived your whole life in control you likely have no idea what I’m talking about. Good for you. But don’t judge others whose lives have been much more difficult than yours. She’s joking about the abortions because it’s too painful to be honest about how she feels. Everyone knows dark humor is a trauma response.

leftorrightnow · 25/10/2025 02:13

I like her. She’s honest and raw. Take her over Taylor swift or some other polished Barbie doll any day- it always makes me laugh when people say TS is so honest and open shen she’s so American and polished, yes she shared some bad relationship so tired but everything so sanitized and nothing too shocking.

sad to hear Lily had been treated badly.
She’s a heroine for all those of us who’ve had messy and less than perfect lives and had relationships we regret and abortions and twenties were we probably partied too much. Yep, that’s me and I like it when someone else makes me feel less alone and ashamed.

Gemstonebeach · 25/10/2025 01:59

I feel very sorry for her when she finally seemed happy after a troubled life. I saw her at a festival many years ago before she had children and she was so intoxicated she couldn’t even perform.

Gilgogirl · 25/10/2025 01:38

Wow, I’ve got to listen to this now. Thanks for the heads up

AngeloMysterioso · 25/10/2025 01:29

SouthernNights59 · 25/10/2025 01:25

How would she be 'forced' to have unwanted babies? Contraception has been around for quite a long time and while accidents can happen someone would have to be spectacularly stupid to get pregnant multiple times and think that abortion is the only answer.

I judge both her and you.

Happily the judgement of random strangers on the internet has absolutely fuck all effect on my actual real life so, you do you!

OP posts:
SouthernNights59 · 25/10/2025 01:25

AngeloMysterioso · 24/10/2025 13:17

Absolutely. Because the alternative is women being forced to have unwanted babies. We don’t know the circumstances around those pregnancies, so I’m not going to judge her for having multiple abortions or for being unashamed of them.

How would she be 'forced' to have unwanted babies? Contraception has been around for quite a long time and while accidents can happen someone would have to be spectacularly stupid to get pregnant multiple times and think that abortion is the only answer.

I judge both her and you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread