Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want to tell sibling I’m going no contact?

120 replies

Lostwelshlady · 25/06/2024 11:01

Background- I’m one of 3 siblings (middle child) I have never been close to oldest sibling, we’ve had various falling outs over the years but managed to remain civil if visiting our parents at the same time, would send xmas cards etc. I’m very close with my youngest sibling who is getting married in 3 days. They have had a similar relationship with older sibling, civil but not close, but was close with older siblings teenage children who were due to be in the wedding party.

For various reasons, our relationship with older sibling has become more strained due to siblings partner (in our opionion) taking advantage of our parents (lots of cash gifts to older siblings partner to save home from creditors due to business going bust twice) siblings partner making numerous comments about how well off they’ll be once my parents have passed (including talking about hoping to take ownership of family home when one parent was very ill in hospital)

My parents have (for reasons unknown to us) always favoured older sibling and their partner, and will not hear a single bad thing about them. At a recent family wedding older sibling tried to start an argument with youngest sibling because of their refusal to let them babysit their young child and various other non issues. Youngest sibling told them this wasnt the time or the place and to behave. (Parents sided with older sibling and said babysitting youngest siblings child would help them get over a recent early pregnancy loss)

A few days later oldest sibling called unannounced with youngest sibling, and continued the argument. Youngest sibling again told them to leave.

Two weeks ago oldest sibling goes into hospital with migrane/meningitis type symptoms. Parents blame youngest sibling for causing oldest sibling stress.

Wedding rehearsal last night, oldest sibling and family don’t show. Parents call them and are told they are abroad, and won’t be attended wedding. Young sibling is devastated as nieces/nephews were part of the wedding party, and seating plans etc now all incorrect. Parents say youngest sibling and me are to blame for not visiting oldest sibling in hospital etc. Youngest sibling sees this as an end to any type of relation with the older sibling, and I feel that I cannot forgive this either.

I don’t wish to fall out with my parents prior to siblings wedding, but also feel very protective of my youngest sibling and cannot stand them being blamed for older siblings behaviour and so feel I should stand up for them, but probably won’t say anything until after the wedding.I also want to contact older sibling to tell them how angry and disappointed I am that they have behaved this way towards youngest sibling, and sneaking off with days to go with no warning. My husband says not to bother and to just accept the relationship is now over without bothering to tell them I’m going no contact, but part of me feels I need to tell them how disappointed I am just to get some kind of closure. WWYD?

OP posts:
Roseyjane · 25/06/2024 11:42

Merryoldgoat · 25/06/2024 11:34

I don’t understand why people put up with such awful treatment because ‘family’.

Your parents show you over and over they don’t care about you. So why do you care if they’re angry.

I love my children, I want them to love me back. So I treat them in a way that shows that.

That’s a horrible thing to write and I’m sure far from true. That her parents do care for her and love her. Why would you write someone like that?

op. Is there a dynamic here of you and your sibling effectively ganging up on your older sibling and your parents trying to keep the peace? How would your older sibling write about the dynamic?

CracklingLogsGalore · 25/06/2024 11:45

If the relationship is over and you’re certain you don’t want to salvage it I’d just tell them exactly what you think and feel. They might not give a shit but you’ll have got it off your chest.

Cathbrownlow · 25/06/2024 11:45

keep your relationship with your younger sister and detach from older sibling plus parents. Whatever you do or say, it will make no difference, I have been where you are. Enjoy your life, make friends, be happy.

GeminiGiggles · 25/06/2024 11:46

There is nothing wrong with going NC but you have to be prepared that it doesn't equate closure whether you speak to them about it or not.

Even if you do speak to them closure is highly unlikely.

DramaLlamaBangBang · 25/06/2024 11:46

I think the only way you will get closure is if they say they are sorry and beg you not to go non contact. The more likely scenario is that they will blame you/tell you you are being overdramatic/accuse you of something re the money/wedding. This will not give you closure and may be something you cannot come back from. Just don't contact them again. No need to tell them why. To go on holiday at the time of your siblings wedding is horrible behaviour.

Nanny0gg · 25/06/2024 11:48

Just stop talking to them

And distance yourself from your parents

They're central to this

Poolstream · 25/06/2024 11:49

Oldest sibling is obviously the golden dc.

I too think your parents are behaving badly.

Just silently reduce contact, get on with your own life and support your younger sibling.
Your older sibling is nasty.

Member984815 · 25/06/2024 11:52

I'm with your dh , just quietly reduce contact

BooBooButts · 25/06/2024 11:55

Your older sibling wants you to get visibly angry with them. That way they can tell your parents "see what I have to put up with" and garner further sympathy. So don't do it. Listen to your DH on this one and just go no contact without telling them. They'll quickly work it out for themselves, at which point they'll go to your parents and complain, at which point you say that you were just following older siblings' wishes as they clearly have no interest in being in contact with you and your younger sibling. If they did want to be in contact they sure as hell wouldn't be going on holiday instead of attending the wedding.

I hope you enjoy the wedding, but more importantly I hope your younger sibling does!

allthemiddlechildrenoftheworld · 25/06/2024 12:06

@Lostwelshlady been there done that!!! ended up no contact with big sis and parent!! life was so much happier after years of the favouritism being thrown in our faces!! your parents are just as bad as your sister. you will ever be on your parents radar until they need you for help with their care!!! tell them all to get lost!

stilllovebeetroot · 25/06/2024 12:10

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Nanny0gg · 25/06/2024 12:14

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Do you visit people who don't like you?

redskydarknight · 25/06/2024 12:16

If you don't want to stay in touch with your sibling, then don't.

If you speak to them they will not miraculously say "oh my goodness, you are so right, I've behaved really badly and I will now change and we'll have a wonderful relationship". Nor will they sit quietly and just accept it - they will argue back.

If you want to talk to them to say all the things you've never quite dared to before, then write them down. Do not send it to them.

No contact is not done to give closure - it's done to protect yourself from toxic people. So going back and having "one last conversation" is counter productive.

Lostwelshlady · 25/06/2024 12:17

frightenedmum1 · 25/06/2024 11:13

Out od interest , who paid for siblings wedding?

My advice is be Switzerland, stay on good terms with all of them. Dont burn your bridges for something which is not your battle.

My sibling is paying for everything, no help offered from parents.

OP posts:
KrisAkabusi · 25/06/2024 12:18

Young sibling is devastated as nieces/nephews were part of the wedding party, and seating plans etc now all incorrect.

I mean Jesus! Way to have fucked up priorities. Devastated as seating plan is incorrect. You all sound as dramatic as each other, and in particular, you all seem determined to fight about everything instead of quietly doing anything/nothing. Your husband is right.

Lostwelshlady · 25/06/2024 12:20

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I get where you’re coming from but in our defence we didn’t actually know until they were home that they had even been ill (they were only admitted for two days for tests) I texted and asked if they needed any shopping etc, but younger sibling decided not to because of the way they had (in their opinion) attacked them at the family wedding (which really wasn’t an appropriate in my opinion)

OP posts:
Lostwelshlady · 25/06/2024 12:22

KrisAkabusi · 25/06/2024 12:18

Young sibling is devastated as nieces/nephews were part of the wedding party, and seating plans etc now all incorrect.

I mean Jesus! Way to have fucked up priorities. Devastated as seating plan is incorrect. You all sound as dramatic as each other, and in particular, you all seem determined to fight about everything instead of quietly doing anything/nothing. Your husband is right.

Devastated because nieces nephews aren’t in the wedding party is what I actually wrote. And yes upset as church and reception seating plans as well as order of service is now not correct- weddings are a lot of work and they’ve waited years to be able to have they type they want and siblings disappearance is times for maximum damage imo.

OP posts:
Lostwelshlady · 25/06/2024 12:26

Roseyjane · 25/06/2024 11:42

That’s a horrible thing to write and I’m sure far from true. That her parents do care for her and love her. Why would you write someone like that?

op. Is there a dynamic here of you and your sibling effectively ganging up on your older sibling and your parents trying to keep the peace? How would your older sibling write about the dynamic?

Thank you- I don’t think there is a ganging up dynamic, but so can see why you might suspect that. I think it’s more from
our upbringing- parents always put older sibling in charge when they worked lots when we were children and they still seem to think they are in charge even though we’re all adults. But that’s just my take on it.

OP posts:
CantDecideAUsename · 25/06/2024 12:26

Deciding to go abroad instead of going to your sibling’s wedding is a pretty awful thing to do. Your younger sibling is understandably extremely angry about this but what happens if you announce you’re no contact and then your younger sibling decides she wants to try and make up with your family.
You can support her and also distance yourself but if you want to cut off all contact with the older sister then it may well come at the cost of all your family relationships.

ChateauMargaux · 25/06/2024 12:26

Anything you say will be taken badly and will add to your parents' impression that you and your younger sibling are in the wrong.

Walk away... be civil to your parents... support your younger sibling and prepare yourself for the likelihood that you will not come out well on the will.

TruthorDie · 25/06/2024 12:29

Poolstream · 25/06/2024 11:49

Oldest sibling is obviously the golden dc.

I too think your parents are behaving badly.

Just silently reduce contact, get on with your own life and support your younger sibling.
Your older sibling is nasty.

Oh yeah golden child vibe here is strong re the eldest. Your parents should treat you all equally and shouldn’t have created this dynamic. They are very much part of the problem. NC will oldest sibling sounds the best way forward and low contact with your parents. It’s also a good way to avoid your parents bleating about why you don’t get on and how hard it is for eldest sibling etc etc.

Amused that stress can cause meningitis. Sounds very dramatic to me. I don’t go and visit everyone who is in hospital who is having tests. So does the flouncing out of the country pre-wedding siblings wedding. Who does that?! Well, your oldest sibling l suppose. I would love to hear more of the back story

Lostwelshlady · 25/06/2024 12:29

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

It’s 100% their prerogative, but it’s hard to watch because parents repeatedly have to pay their debt to avoid enforcement action, whilst expressing to me and younger sibling they feel they have no choice as older sibling threatens to go no contact with parents if they don’t (as they have with in-laws) It’s 100% not jealousy, more frustration at bad behaviour being ignored/rewarded whilst we’re held to a different standard.

OP posts:
KTheGrey · 25/06/2024 12:30

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Au contraire, I think they will be delighted. Don't give them the satisfaction.

Write them a letter. Burn it and let the ashes go into the wild blue yonder. Bye bye horrid sibling.

Pour all your energies into making other sibling's day super.

Allie47 · 25/06/2024 12:30

You're not being unreasonable to go NC, but it would be to announce it, it'll just cause more drama which your family seem to enjoy, just fade them out and keep quiet, life has it's own way of just carrying on x

nc14 · 25/06/2024 12:32

I agree with your DH. I would go no contact but there’s no reason to tell them you’re doing it. Take all the emotional charge out of the situation and just let it be, move on and be happy in your life.