Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think that most company menopause policies are an absolute joke?

260 replies

JenniferAnistonsHair2023 · 04/10/2023 18:29

I work for a FTSE100 firm, been there a long time. No historical performance issues. Mid 50s, senior role, quite high pressure.

At the start of this year I went down to 4 days in an attempt to slow down a little. I'm menopausal, anxious, permanently tired (insomnia) - you get the picture. On HRT which has helped but doesn't turn you back into the person you were when you were 30.

My last performance review I was pretty much told I'm underperforming. This came as a shock to me as I'm managing a full time workload in 4 days. Was given some areas to focus on which I'm trying my hardest to do, but part of me thinks I'm just not good enough any more.

Decide to contact HR today to discuss what constitutes 'reasonable adjustments' to my role because of menopause symptoms. (We have a policy published on our intranet). HR helpline pretty much just told me that I need to work things out with my manager. Made the point that my manager was the problem and I didn't feel comfortable discussing menopause with a 50 something male with no training on the matter. Still get a 'computer says no' response.

I mean, what's the fucking point of having a policy? I'm losing the will to live. On top of all that I'm asked to do a day of meetings which involves 3 hours of travelling either side next week, with no opportunity to take any of that time back. I refused on the basis that there was a dial-in option and that I wasn't willing to go massively over my 28 hours for the week (there are times when I have to travel when f2f is the only option and that's fine, I suck it up).

AIBU? Has anyone got experience of a workplace where they have a better menopause policy so that I can consider applying?!

OP posts:
Flopsythebunny · 05/10/2023 07:27

Tara24 · 04/10/2023 21:15

I hate all this menopause obsession. Why on earth do you need to have a policy to deal with a perfectly normal biological process ? It's a sure fire way to make women even more a target of discrimination in the work place.

I'm 50 and work full time. Sure, tired from insomnia , but no more so than the young parents I work with. Why can't age and experience be seen as a positive thing ? Why can't being in our fifties be seen as when our experience shines through? But instead you want a snowflake policy and to whinge about 'slowing down" like you're 80. Ugh.

For some women, menopause can be debilitating.
Not all women sIl through it or can take HRT

jumperoozles · 05/10/2023 07:24

Some people on here are having a difficult time understanding that equal does not always mean the same. Women are not the same as men and so might need different things to help support them in the workplace. The reason we didn’t have equality in the workplace is because of things like childbearing but there are now policies in place to protect women and help them continue in work. The same is true of the menopause.
I have to admit as a 30 something year old woman I didn’t have much knowledge of the menopause because older women in my workplace and even my own mum didn’t really talk about it. It was like some kind of secret club you had to go through when the time came! I’m glad women are talking more freely about periods etc and I hope the same happens with menopause. I took the time recently to ask specifically what the menopause actually entails and was shocked by the range of experience women go through - some sail through, some really have terrible symptoms. I think having policies around it can only be a good thing for equality to be honest and to help women achieve in the workplace. It’s not about having to struggle through in silence - that doesn’t make you equal to men.

spookehtooth · 05/10/2023 07:23

10% of women, according to one study, quit their job because of menopause. This means more will have considered it.

Acceptable?

Baaaaaa · 05/10/2023 07:19

When my kids were young, I dropped to 4 days. I didn't get a drop in workload and just packed more into 4 days. I noticed an attitude of resentment develop. People perceive you to be slacking, even if you maintain productivity.

Unfortunately it persists even when you go back to full time again.

I moved jobs, full time and I have a reputation for high productivity.

Can guarantee if I dropped to 4 days again, same would happen. I've seen it happen to others.

It's not rational, but we are all just great apes.

Manager might feel the 4 days is reasonable adjustment.

FarEast · 05/10/2023 06:59

No help on this I’m afraid. But at least you have some sort of policy. My workplace talks about menopause and pregnancy without mentioning the word “woman” or “female.”

vodka4mum · 05/10/2023 06:14

My company has a relatively new buy excellent menopause policy... in theory.
In practice I am the only woman with a male manager so we've never had the conversation

Oblomov23 · 05/10/2023 05:25

What reasonable adjustments are you asking for? And how long for? Long term? Permanent?

Will the OP's insomnia or anxiety get better? From an HR point of view, if an employee can't perform their role long term, that is an issue.

A pp, redcess says to OP:

"If it were me I would set out in a really clear email what the issues you are having are, and what adjustments you would like making to your role. "

Many posters have asked if she's already sent her current male manager an email detailing the symptoms and suggesting adjustments. Until she can verbalise it, the manager will claim he hasn't be approached. Which he hasn't.

lljkk · 05/10/2023 05:13

JenniferAnistonsHair2023 · 04/10/2023 21:59

You're completely right. I just wanted to talk to someone other than a male line manager about what I might need. I don't need to articulate here what adjustments I'm expecting. That wasn't the point of my post.

OP has explained her specific need (demand) twice: she doesn't want to speak to a male manager who is untrained. That is the start and possibly the end of what she wants. The first reasonable adjustment OP wants is someone female & trained (or maybe just female, not sure) to talk to.

Is he a manager or not? does he need training in every employee need in order to accommodate them? Is it reasonable to expect or demand that training for each condition, or is it just a menopause requirement?

What if OP gets someone trained & female to talk to and arrange additional adjustments with, does anyone have to explain to her actual male line manager why OP had those adjustments (& maybe to OP's colleagues, too)? Would it be the duty of the female trained staff member to explain to the colleagues & line manager why OP had those adjustments (which presumably aren't necessarily available to anyone else?)

I'm not sure that what OP wants is best or reasonable.

HoneyBadgerMom · 05/10/2023 02:41

Vikina · 04/10/2023 22:11

I agree with this. Menopause is not an illness in the same way that puberty isn't either. I've fought so hard to be treated as an equal in a man's world. We can't have it all ways.

I'm self employed so just have to get on with it. And that's as is should be.

I agree with this. I have to concede I haven't gone through it yet (I'm so ready, I'm 51, I'm so tired of periods!). Menopause, pregnancy, puberty, these are not illnesses. It's LIFE. You get through it. Some women have extreme symptoms, and those women should be treated with respect and dignity, as everyone should be, but I do get the sense that there are a lot of women just looking for an excuse to be coddled. "Snowflake" is an apt description. It's kind of insulting to the women who DO have extremely debilitating symptoms.

And HEAR, HEAR for wanting to be treated as an equal. Equality means being equal all the time. If you're constantly asking for concessions and coddling because you're a woman, then you're not equal. It makes it harder for the rest of us when women are constantly whining "it's not fair" while asking for time off and special accommodations for every little thing.

Hellaweirdhuh · 05/10/2023 02:40

cushioncovers · 04/10/2023 22:28

Yes the nhs are very keen to acknowledge the male menopause.

That's a 'story' highly misrepresented by the media and posters here. Men aren't being offered a year off for 'male menopause' in the NHS.

HoneyBadgerMom · 05/10/2023 02:33

I've never heard of menopause policies. I can't imagine asking off work because of menopause, but I haven't actually started it yet, so I reserve the right to change my attitude about it when I get there.

spookehtooth · 05/10/2023 02:03

I don't know how to assess the effectiveness of the policy where I work, which is virgin money but this is what they do. It's been driven by a woman in a fairly senior level management position:

  • HR policy exists
  • Training provided to number of staff across the business who volunteered, so called menopause champions. There's a page on the intranet with a bio of each and way to contact them. The training is provided by an external provider called hen pecked, who seem to be really good. I volunteered and have ended up being token man as no others did. They didn't specify gender, and I thought "why not" & it turned out I was wanted.
  • There's a teams group related to equality, a channel exists there for women to talk menopause with each other. A separate one exists for the so-called champions to discuss stuff too
  • There's also online coffee chats organised for people to join
  • There's a desire to get people leaders training and more clued up about menopause so they can provide better support, but I don't think it's happened yet

I don't know how helpful it is compared to what's necessary, but it definitely helps some

Relying on GPs alone seems to not be the best idea. I forget the exact figure but they get hardly any training, and there's lots of bad experiences reported by women. My friend's was useless for health issues that frightened her, it's almost certainly peri-menopause and he totally dismissed it, like not even doing either of the two different ways to diagnose. There's worse stories out there.

There's some shocking stats on the number of women who consider quitting work, and those who actually do, because of menopause. Any preventable resignation is unacceptable, surely?

EBearhug · 05/10/2023 00:42

The TUC website has some info about menopause policies. Some unions do, too. You may be able to read some info without being a member, I don't know.

I think it would be worth joining a union. Most unions won't assist with an existing dispute/grievance with new members, nor will they help with a new one within 3 or 6 months of joining (length of time can vary between unions.) But it's unlikely you'll be though menopause and symptom free that quickly.

stealtheatingtunnocks · 04/10/2023 23:38

Im going to be a man and get a year off.
May as well, they won’t take me seriously as a woman do I may as well say I’m a special man menopause

Olive19741205 · 04/10/2023 23:28

direbollockal · 04/10/2023 23:04

I would also add that I have found the menopause a blessed relief from periods and the sickness and diarrhoea and javelin arse that I had to endure for 2-3 days per month for 35-odd years. Period pain was absolutely horrendous (for me) and there certainly wasn't any "support" with that one.

So? You have found it a relief...so what? I had horrendous periods every month and horrendous menopause symptoms. We're not all the same. 2-3 days a month is nothing compared to menopause symptoms every single day.

PennywisePoundFoolish · 04/10/2023 23:05

I was able to get my manager to do an occupational health referral, under the vaguest of terms- that I had ongoing long term health issues. I Explained in detail to Occupational Health who then wrote to my manager with recommendations ehich included advice on setting achievable targets. I'm aware the company I work for genuinely try and support staff, and we can access a a few things (e.g . Physio, counselling etc).

If thar makes me a snowflake then so be it.

Im on HRT and anxiety medication and still struggling. Also hypothyroid. I hope you can get some support and start to feel a bit better soon.

direbollockal · 04/10/2023 23:04

I would also add that I have found the menopause a blessed relief from periods and the sickness and diarrhoea and javelin arse that I had to endure for 2-3 days per month for 35-odd years. Period pain was absolutely horrendous (for me) and there certainly wasn't any "support" with that one.

direbollockal · 04/10/2023 23:00

Tara24 · 04/10/2023 21:15

I hate all this menopause obsession. Why on earth do you need to have a policy to deal with a perfectly normal biological process ? It's a sure fire way to make women even more a target of discrimination in the work place.

I'm 50 and work full time. Sure, tired from insomnia , but no more so than the young parents I work with. Why can't age and experience be seen as a positive thing ? Why can't being in our fifties be seen as when our experience shines through? But instead you want a snowflake policy and to whinge about 'slowing down" like you're 80. Ugh.

I'm afraid I agree with every word of this.

DivingForLove · 04/10/2023 23:00

@SisterMichaelsHabit you are the third person this week I’ve seen recommend to a poster that they should join a Union to sort out an existing issue. As a lifelong union member I’m fucking sick of people thinking that they only need to pay their dues when there’s something in it for them. You can’t do that and quite rightly the union will do nothing for you. Pay your dues every month like the rest of us and they might be interested 🙄. FFS.

Tinkerbyebye · 04/10/2023 22:58

What do you want your company to do? And why should someone not be challenged on performance?

woman want equality, but play the pregnant, menopause, childcare card at any opportunity

lots of woman at my work had menopause symptoms of varying degrees, from sailing through to the most horrendous systems, but all accepted it as part of woman’s life, took sick leave when it got really bad, but cracked on with work in the main

so tell work what you want and see if they agree

herbetta · 04/10/2023 22:52

Wow, there's some comments on here, WTAF?!
I had no idea of what women were going through until I experienced it myself - I have hardly ever had any sick leave & none in last 15 years, still haven't. I think the difference isn't being 'ill' as such but appearing to underperfom etc, without even being able to pinpoint why exactly.

OP, up your HRT. It's what worked for me, gradually increase it and also consider adding in Testosterone - both gamechangers for me. Also, then consider changing jobs.

Blingstar · 04/10/2023 22:48

@JenniferAnistonsHair2023 There's some good info on this link: www.fom.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/Guidance-on-menopause-and-the-workplace-v6.pdf

It might be a good idea to follow the advice from someone further up about emailing your line manager and explaining you have some health issues and that you'd like a referral to an OT.

I'd also listen to some of the Louise Newson podcasts and go back to your GP and ask for a change to your HRT because it's not working. Check out the Human Being Diet (HBD) which is specifically targeted at this age. It's transformed my life in terms of sleep, energy levels and all round health. It's worth buying the books - very insightful.

Good luck. I hope you can get this sorted out.

Iwasafool · 04/10/2023 22:48

Remagirl · 04/10/2023 22:36

This is really rude and belittling of women who are suffering with much more debilitating symptoms. I believe it's a step in the right direction to make allowances and adjustments for women who genuinely need some support at a period in their lives that can be very difficult. I appreciate it isn't the same for everybody but I have empathy for those of us who need time and patience to get the right combo of support to see them through.

People need help/adjustments for various things in life. I think what some people don't like is the idea that we are all the same. I didn't need any adjustments for the menopause I needed for a couple of days every month for the previous 30 odd years. So I'd like to see help and support offered when needed regardless of the reason it is needed. So some women might need it for periods, some might need it for pregnancy, some might need it for menopause, some might need it for rheumatism or cancer or any number of other things. They should all get it.

FusionChefGeoff · 04/10/2023 22:47

For everyone telling OP she needs to articulate what she needs, don't just expect special treatment yadda yadda:

She is here asking for help in articulating what she needs!!!

So I'm peri but don't have a workplace as I work for myself. However, my main issues are brain fog, fatigue, overwhelm and anxiety.

Things I do / would ask an employer to do:

Flexi working so when I hit "done" for the day, I can sign off then pick up again earlier the next day. I risk making huge mistakes and I'm very inefficient if I keep working beyond that point.

Help or systems for Task management / prioritising - when I'm bad I find it incredibly hard to prioritise and flutter about doing very little apart from winding myself up. Do you have task management software or training you could do? My stuff is now ruthlessly systemised so I don't have to rely on my brain on bad days, the system just tells me what my tasks are.

Regular breaks. Help me to stave off overwhelm.

Let's hope others can start to give you some other ideas that you can take to your manager Flowers

Iwasafool · 04/10/2023 22:41

OuiRagamuffin · 04/10/2023 21:19

Exactly @Tara24 I completely agree. I've been lucky perhaps but I wouldn't want to contribute to a stereotype that 50 something women lose their confidence. If I need time of I'll get a doctor to send a certified sick note to the absence management team.

That's the thing isn't it, it isn't the menopause people need time off for it is the symptoms and if it's tiredness/anxiety or whatever people might need adjustments but not just because of menopause. Personally I found menopause liberating, no more crippling migraines that I used to get every month, so I certainly didn't want anyone viewing me as some special case needing adjustments, I needed them every month for years.