Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think that most company menopause policies are an absolute joke?

260 replies

JenniferAnistonsHair2023 · 04/10/2023 18:29

I work for a FTSE100 firm, been there a long time. No historical performance issues. Mid 50s, senior role, quite high pressure.

At the start of this year I went down to 4 days in an attempt to slow down a little. I'm menopausal, anxious, permanently tired (insomnia) - you get the picture. On HRT which has helped but doesn't turn you back into the person you were when you were 30.

My last performance review I was pretty much told I'm underperforming. This came as a shock to me as I'm managing a full time workload in 4 days. Was given some areas to focus on which I'm trying my hardest to do, but part of me thinks I'm just not good enough any more.

Decide to contact HR today to discuss what constitutes 'reasonable adjustments' to my role because of menopause symptoms. (We have a policy published on our intranet). HR helpline pretty much just told me that I need to work things out with my manager. Made the point that my manager was the problem and I didn't feel comfortable discussing menopause with a 50 something male with no training on the matter. Still get a 'computer says no' response.

I mean, what's the fucking point of having a policy? I'm losing the will to live. On top of all that I'm asked to do a day of meetings which involves 3 hours of travelling either side next week, with no opportunity to take any of that time back. I refused on the basis that there was a dial-in option and that I wasn't willing to go massively over my 28 hours for the week (there are times when I have to travel when f2f is the only option and that's fine, I suck it up).

AIBU? Has anyone got experience of a workplace where they have a better menopause policy so that I can consider applying?!

OP posts:
SiousieSoo · 05/10/2023 14:07

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 05/10/2023 13:48

If it’s good enough for Prince Phillip in a formal situation then it’s good enough for a MN thread.

What are you talking about? He used the f bomb!

SiousieSoo · 05/10/2023 14:06

Jellycatspyjamas · 05/10/2023 13:58

Dear vs 'sh'' - would you prefer your child said the latter? OK you do you then.

I’d rather my child drank water than wine but it doesn’t mean as an adult I don’t enjoy a drink from time to time. Holding adults to childlike standards of behaviour is infantilising.

Ridiculous comparison given that when referring to your 'child' they can be an adult or adolescent. I would not want any child of mine (adult or not) to use this language. I can hold a different opinion to you. It is allowed.

Jellycatspyjamas · 05/10/2023 14:04

I think you're over-simplifying a bit. I work a 4 day week and I DO get paid less - 20% less, in fact. But I don't have a lighter workload - I have a 100% FTE workload. I would like some acknowledgement that I am doing the same work for less pay, rather than being told I'm underperforming.

I wonder if a discussion around the fact there has been no reduction in workload to reflect your reduced hours and pay might be more productive. That’s about resourcing and capacity which would apply regardless of the personal health circumstance of the person concerned. It’s not even a reasonable adjustment - they agreed the reduction in hours but obviously didn’t consider that would mean a reduction in your availability and your capacity for workload.

honeycombhead · 05/10/2023 14:02

Zebedee55 · 05/10/2023 13:35

No, I have and don't really understand the fuss. I took HRT, took a couple of goes to get the right make, and, yes, some days you do feel a bit weary and stressed.

But, it's a normal process, and life goes on.🙂

Life doesn't always go on.

Looking back, there were a number of women in my childhood who was considered "the mad old bat down the road" type, that turns out was all menopause related and many lost much of their lives. An old boyfriends Grandmother spent 18 months in hospital and had ECT for menopause. Women would be locked away for the rest of their lives.

Just because something wasn't talked about, doesn't mean it wasn't happening. It's incredibly ignorant to think that. Along the lines of "well, women gave birth with no complaint in the good old days". Yes, and look at the maternal death rate.

A bit weary? I can go a week on 2 hours sleep each night to the point I can barely function. About once a fortnight I will literally have had NO sleep. And no rest because of restless legs / arms. On the previous HRT regime I had my breasts got so painful I couldn't even consider wearing a bra. I have days I can't think how to do any of my work.

But you've got through it fine, so obviously everyone is like you.

JenniferAnistonsHair2023 · 05/10/2023 14:00

Hufflepods · 05/10/2023 13:56

You really aren't clear in terms of what you want, you want "reasonable adjustments" but you don't specify. You work a 4 day week and are underperforming, but you don't want to do any more work. It comes across like you want a lighter workload with less responsibility and easier work but for no less money because you also say you can't afford to take another job.

If that is what you want then yeah YABU.

As is moaning that your manager is male. It isn't realistic for everyone to have a manager in the same scenario as yourself. Being uncomfortable because your manager is male is a you issue. People with all sorts of illnesses or pregnancy etc manage to discuss issues with their manager without their manager having direct experience of it.

I think you're over-simplifying a bit. I work a 4 day week and I DO get paid less - 20% less, in fact. But I don't have a lighter workload - I have a 100% FTE workload. I would like some acknowledgement that I am doing the same work for less pay, rather than being told I'm underperforming.

As for your comments about complaining my manager is male - fair comment and I take it on board. I can see from other comments that it's unreasonable of me to be able to talk to another woman about my issues.

OP posts:
Jellycatspyjamas · 05/10/2023 13:58

Dear vs 'sh'' - would you prefer your child said the latter? OK you do you then.

I’d rather my child drank water than wine but it doesn’t mean as an adult I don’t enjoy a drink from time to time. Holding adults to childlike standards of behaviour is infantilising.

kitsuneghost · 05/10/2023 13:58

I too dislike the negative attention given to menopause
I do understand many people struggle but it has reached the point that there is now a stereotype of post menopausal woman, being slow, tired and cognitively impaired.

We need to take away the idea of menopause being this prescribed set of symptoms that apply to all women over 50.

I think we need to get rid of the word menopause and simply say I, as a person am having memory issues just now / insomnia issues just now etc...

Hufflepods · 05/10/2023 13:56

You really aren't clear in terms of what you want, you want "reasonable adjustments" but you don't specify. You work a 4 day week and are underperforming, but you don't want to do any more work. It comes across like you want a lighter workload with less responsibility and easier work but for no less money because you also say you can't afford to take another job.

If that is what you want then yeah YABU.

As is moaning that your manager is male. It isn't realistic for everyone to have a manager in the same scenario as yourself. Being uncomfortable because your manager is male is a you issue. People with all sorts of illnesses or pregnancy etc manage to discuss issues with their manager without their manager having direct experience of it.

easylikeasundaymorn · 05/10/2023 13:55

Tara24 · 04/10/2023 21:15

I hate all this menopause obsession. Why on earth do you need to have a policy to deal with a perfectly normal biological process ? It's a sure fire way to make women even more a target of discrimination in the work place.

I'm 50 and work full time. Sure, tired from insomnia , but no more so than the young parents I work with. Why can't age and experience be seen as a positive thing ? Why can't being in our fifties be seen as when our experience shines through? But instead you want a snowflake policy and to whinge about 'slowing down" like you're 80. Ugh.

If this argument had any rationality then you also wouldn't need maternity, bereavement or sickness policies, all of which are also "perfectly normal biological processes"...you know, all the things our ancestors fought for to try and reduce discrimination?

But then use of the word "snowflake" is a pretty good indicator that everything else said by that ~daily mail reading, GMB watching~ person can be safely disregarded.

OP I agree with the posters who said you need to be more specific about what accommodations you want made for you. And the "don't feel comfortable talking to my male manager" excuse isn't really sufficient- there are lots of things people might not be hugely comfortable talking to their managers about, whether medical or personal but its the role of the manager to manage any discomfort! If you speak to your manager and don't get anywhere then you can refer back to HR/upwards and say they aren't following their policy but as it is it seems like thry are -presumably your policy says discuss any reasonable adjustments you'd like made, HR have said the person to discuss these with is your manager, that's what you have to do.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 05/10/2023 13:48

SiousieSoo · 05/10/2023 13:34

I think when somebody uses such coarse language to describe the pertinent (and supposedly professional) situation at the heart of a dispute, it reveals to me something about their character. And maybe the character traits that I intimated in my post (unpleasant and agressive) are inhibiting their progress in this matter because of the way they come across. Just a thought.... I do not know anyone who would write about their manager in this way. It is a really weird phrase to use when describing a professional encounter.

If it’s good enough for Prince Phillip in a formal situation then it’s good enough for a MN thread.

Prince Philip to photographer: Just take the ****ing picture

Prince Philip tells a photographer "Just take the ****ing picture!" after being made to wait for a photo with Battle of Britain veterans.

https://youtu.be/iDCn0lGhaLg?si=UJrXTaNKKa71hU2a

JenniferAnistonsHair2023 · 05/10/2023 13:47

No I'm ok thanks @SiousieSoo - I don't have an issue with my language, nor do any of the other posters on here with the exception of you.

OP posts:
Olive19741205 · 05/10/2023 13:47

SiousieSoo · 05/10/2023 13:37

It was not 'shit' it was 'sh*t'. Gross and vulgar, but you are another one who thinks it is ok to use this when describing a professional encounter with their manager. OK, up to you. Not appreciating reading this language does not make me fragile at all. If I was fragile, I would not have commented knowing how many people would inevitably put the put in, which has happened.

You do understand the manager doesn't know about this thread right? You absolutely are fragile/sensitive whatever to be so bothered by this.

Olive19741205 · 05/10/2023 13:44

Zebedee55 · 05/10/2023 13:35

No, I have and don't really understand the fuss. I took HRT, took a couple of goes to get the right make, and, yes, some days you do feel a bit weary and stressed.

But, it's a normal process, and life goes on.🙂

Jesus christ. And what about the women who can't take HRT? As long as you were ok eh? "A little weary and stressed"? Lucky you.

SiousieSoo · 05/10/2023 13:41

Olive19741205 · 05/10/2023 13:40

Agreed... and also addressing someone "lovely".

And I'm the one being told to get a life.... You guys are hilarious!

Olive19741205 · 05/10/2023 13:40

Jellycatspyjamas · 05/10/2023 13:24

Your patronising “dear” is infinitely more offensive than explaining that someone shit themselves.

Agreed... and also addressing someone "lovely".

SiousieSoo · 05/10/2023 13:39

JenniferAnistonsHair2023 · 05/10/2023 13:37

@SiousieSoo that's not the question I asked but never mind.

No but it is relevant and perhaps something for you to think about.

JenniferAnistonsHair2023 · 05/10/2023 13:37

@SiousieSoo that's not the question I asked but never mind.

OP posts:
SiousieSoo · 05/10/2023 13:37

Olive19741205 · 05/10/2023 13:33

Omg, get a bloody life. I've seen some petty posts over the years on Mumsnet but this one beats them all. If you're too fragile to read the word "shit" on a forum, then perhaps you should find somewhere else.

It was not 'shit' it was 'sh*t'. Gross and vulgar, but you are another one who thinks it is ok to use this when describing a professional encounter with their manager. OK, up to you. Not appreciating reading this language does not make me fragile at all. If I was fragile, I would not have commented knowing how many people would inevitably put the put in, which has happened.

Zebedee55 · 05/10/2023 13:35

JenniferAnistonsHair2023 · 04/10/2023 21:29

Snowflake menopause obsession? Really? I can only assume you haven't been through it, or you sailed through it.

My fundamental problem is that I don't have a manager who I feel I can approach about this stuff. I'm uncomfortable talking about it with someone who just doesn't get it. I've lost all confidence at work and the accusation of underperformance is only making things worse. I would honestly quit right now and get a low pressure job if I could afford to.

HR BP might be a good call. But the company I work for has made it very difficult to have a conversation with an actual person, not a call centre.

No, I have and don't really understand the fuss. I took HRT, took a couple of goes to get the right make, and, yes, some days you do feel a bit weary and stressed.

But, it's a normal process, and life goes on.🙂

SiousieSoo · 05/10/2023 13:34

JenniferAnistonsHair2023 · 05/10/2023 13:30

@SiousieSoo do you regularly join threads just to tell the OP off for swearing rather than trying to contribute or help with the problem in hand?

I think when somebody uses such coarse language to describe the pertinent (and supposedly professional) situation at the heart of a dispute, it reveals to me something about their character. And maybe the character traits that I intimated in my post (unpleasant and agressive) are inhibiting their progress in this matter because of the way they come across. Just a thought.... I do not know anyone who would write about their manager in this way. It is a really weird phrase to use when describing a professional encounter.

FunnysInLaJardin · 05/10/2023 13:34

some very depressing attitudes on this thread.

I sincerely hope all of those dismissing the OP as a snowflake etc end up having the most awful menopause and have to retire early because of it.

My sister had a hysterectomy in the late 80's aged 38 and at the time not enough was known about HRT etc. It ended her teaching career and so no, it wasn't always peachy in the olden days.

Olive19741205 · 05/10/2023 13:33

SiousieSoo · 05/10/2023 13:12

You said your manager 'sh**' himself.... Absolutely unnecessary to be so coarse and vulgar. I would be mad with any of my children speaking like this but you are a grown woman talking in this way. If you cannot see how vulgar this is then clearly this is on you.

Omg, get a bloody life. I've seen some petty posts over the years on Mumsnet but this one beats them all. If you're too fragile to read the word "shit" on a forum, then perhaps you should find somewhere else.

tigger1001 · 05/10/2023 13:32

MorvernBlack · 05/10/2023 11:39

I think some women are clueless about what menopause can mean for other women. A bit of insomnia and night sweats is the light end of it. I was terrified I had Alzheimers, couldn't think on my feet, couldn't have discussions/meetings because I couldn't remember names or even remember what I was talking about. Couldn't take in new info at all. My joints were so, so painful and I was vomiting with anxiety, then wetting myself when I vomited.

I know too many women who have given up work or had to reduce their hours, women who lost confidence in driving etc.

And as for those scornful ones who think they've sailed through it - menopause can be the gift that keeps on giving, my Mum was one of those, 5yrs later she started with vaginal atrophy, now she can't be examined and even her underwear makes her bleed. She has constant UTIs, panic attacks, can't drive anymore.

I hope the scornful women on this thread are just 4chan scum. I'd hate to think that women I work/live amongst are so unempathetic. Although I know a few who can't comprehend heavy periods or period pain, so it's not a leap to suspect there are.

It's not feminism to succeed whilst crushing other women. It's not feminism to assume we are the same as men. Equity and equality are not the same thing.

100% this!

I can totally relate to the feeling that it was the start of dementia or Alzheimer's. That's exactly how I was feeling. When I described it as such to the nurse, she commented that lots of women have described it that way.

I don't get the hate surrounding the fact menopause is being talked about much more openly. That's a good thing! It helps so many women realise they are not alone. It should never have been treated as a dirty secret or the butt of jokes etc.

Some women do sail through the menopause. And sadly it's these voices which are loudly shouting down others who are not so lucky. It's doing women a huge disservice.

Women's health has always been lacking. And it's good to see that change, albeit it slowly.

Limpba · 05/10/2023 13:31

OuiRagamuffin · 04/10/2023 21:08

Argue it from the position of being paid less in reflection of less responsibility.

As a 53 year old still working 5 days a week, I don't know if these menopause policies will help women. In our 30s we had to face interviewers suspecting we might get pregnant, in our 40s we face interviewers suspecting we might have kids to be home for, and now in our 50s we have to face interviewers suspecting we are "slowing down".

I will not be saying the word menopause at work. Even if I have a hysterectomy (not planned) I'll say I had car trouble.

similar age, SLT and similar thoughts on the matter.

JenniferAnistonsHair2023 · 05/10/2023 13:30

@SiousieSoo do you regularly join threads just to tell the OP off for swearing rather than trying to contribute or help with the problem in hand?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread