Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Work

Chat with other users about all things related to working life on our Work forum.

Am I wrong to pay for childcare when mum is offering it for free

27 replies

HelenRosie · 16/12/2009 12:28

I'm expecting my first child next year. My mum is very excited and already talking about how she will look after the baby when I go back to work.

The thing is, I don't actually want her to but don't know if I am being unrealistic/ungrateful. I'd sooner pay for a childminder or nursery.

My mum is lovely and adores kids, but I do sometimes feel that the way she relates to my nephew is a little unhealthy. It feels as though she uses him to fill a void in her own life and doesn't always do what is best for him, e.g he is supposed to go to nursery for a few hours each day but 2 days a week she doesn't let him go as 'she wants him all to herself' (her words) My sister has also told me she has heard her say to him 'if you do that then nanny won't love you' and when she pulled her up on it she didn't appreciate how damaging this could be to a child. I also feel she is far too involved in my nephew's life, more like a replacement mum than a grandmother and I wouldn't want her being like that with my child.

I grew up feeling responsible for my mum's happiness and I really don't want my child to feel like that. I am also aware that as this is my first child and I don't have a partner I may need or want more help when the time comes than I feel I need now.

I just really want some advice on whether I should do what I want and pay for childcare, risking upsetting and alienating my mum, or take the help and risk feeling that she's taking over.

OP posts:
HelenRosie · 16/12/2009 18:34

Oh, that's ok then as she isn't being paid. See what I mean about her being obsessed with babies, she won't even let her friend pay her.

OP posts:
TheHappyCat · 17/12/2009 00:42

Exactly what ChasingSquirrels said.
Although I have total confidence in my mum. Perhaps that has biased my personal view which is that my kids are better off with family... they have one day with a nanny and she is great but I would rather my mum. That said, she is particularly good and like a second mum to them, so it totally depends on the personalities and people involved - you have to do what you feel comfortable with. I find it odd that other posters have rules about how many days are appropriate for grandparents to do - it totally depends on the individuals concerned.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page