Please or to access all these features

Work

Chat with other users about all things related to working life on our Work forum.

How do I raise concerns about an unfair internal promotion?

34 replies

southern82 · 26/09/2026 19:00

I work for my local town council, and recently a colleague whom I started with has been given a different job with a much higher pay grade.
He hasn't applied for the job, nor interviewed.
He told me they said to not tell anyone he's getting more money. He's also got no experience either in this role. He has gone to work in health and safety and has no clue what he's doing.
I was given serving the committee members tea and coffee and he was given a new job with more money.
This feels completely unfair, how do I broach the subject with management?

OP posts:
TallSturdyGirls · 03/10/2026 23:31

topcat2014 · 03/10/2026 18:52

It's this urge to go running somewhere and "report" stuff that I always seem to see on MN.

Why mark yourself out as a problem?

Or maybe you will be seen as someone with the gumption to call out bullshit.

Gwenna · 04/10/2026 08:27

Elieza · 27/09/2026 10:10

A secondment can be for years. i did ten years on secondment. so it’s not like temporary promotion.

the fact they have hired new starts to replace him proves that this is not just til christmas or something.

i too would be asking the union to anonymously investigate. meanwhile id be asking my line manager how i should progress my career. and referencing your colleague doing so well for himself and you want to do that too. i might even go as far as saying is there a post for me, as you hired two new guys and colleague got promoted so is the other guy to replace me if i get promoted?

have you been there over two years? you have more job security is you have. so you can say things in due course if you need to.

if not it’s easier to fire you and you need to be careful what you say or imply or they couod imagine some slight and put you out. maybe that’s why they hired the other guy…… oh no……

yeah you need to be careful while challenging this jobs for the boys shite.

This is great advice @southern82

LasVegass · 04/10/2026 08:38

I’m surprised there are still committee meetings in person and they get served tea & coffee!

I think you’re right to be annoyed. You could ask at your appraisal for opportunities for secondments or promotions like your colleague. This might be less confrontational.

Whatisthat1 · 04/10/2026 08:43

This thread should be used as a case study to show why the public sector is such poor value to those who fund it.

I’m just thankful I work in the private sector. I couldn’t be bothered with crap like this. It’s pathetic.

ApricotTulip · 04/10/2026 08:43

TallSturdyGirls · 26/09/2026 23:23

Yes let's not challenge any poor practice because "life is unfair".
Do you just let bad things happen and not do anything to inprove the world?

Yes "life is unfair" is a rubbish excuse for acting in an unfair way. Women wouldn't have the vote if everyone had just accepted "life is unfair."

Luckydog7 · 04/10/2026 08:45

People on here don't seem to understand that this is a local council and there are strict rules about hiring that are there to ensure that public spending has sufficient oversight and the best salaries aren't just handed over to someone's mate.

I interviewed 5 times for various council roles and I didn't get a single one because I didn't get enough points compared to the external candidates. I worked there as a contractor for years, applying for the roles I was actively covering at the time, but because I was only in my 20s I lacked the experience of older candidates and lost our to them dispute my managers liking me and being very contrite about offering the job elsewhere.

Pp is right though. Don't raise it in your review, that will make you look bad. Do raise it with the union.

LateNightOne · 04/10/2026 08:48

You won't get far. Fair or not.

Leopardspota · 04/10/2026 08:48

southern82 · 27/09/2026 02:56

It's been told to us by management that he's on secondment and they didn't mention that he's been regraded.
I only know because he told me, and they specifically said "don't tell anyone'
We both started on the same day 6 months ago, the job he is doing requires specialist knowledge as it's health and safety related. He has zero experience in this field. I was told he was doing this for 3 days a week, and it turns out it's now 5 days a week. And they have replaced him with two new starters.
I have a 6 month appraisal next week on which I was going to mention this.
I've been given more work to do for people several pay bands higher than myself and no mention of a regrade for myself.
Basically the health and safety manager got sacked because he hadn't been doing the job correctly and they've appointed my colleague as a Buildings Officer to inspect council owned buildings, he was doing admin beforehand.
If this is allowed to happen, why was he told not to tell anyone he's had a regrade? And why not advertise internally?

Edited

Are you interested in the job? You need to go from a point of ‘I would like to be considered’ or even regraded in your own role etc, you can’t just say you’re unhappy he was chosen.

OldGothsFadeToGrey · 04/10/2026 08:51

Whenisitsummer · 26/09/2026 19:14

I don't think there is a legal requirement for employers to advertise jobs.
What does the recruitment policy say for your employer though, have they gone against that?
I suspect expressing concerns to management won't get you anywhere, they obviously wanted to give him the job ( for whatever reason).

There isn’t but there is. Civil service policies pretty much mandate that jobs have to be advertised. Legislation like the Local Government and Housing Act says that local authority appointments should be strictly on merit. While it doesn’t ban direct appointment, it does strongly recommend that this is done via open competition so the best candidate is appointed. VFM for the tax payer etc. In my department we have to go through a painful approval process, and sometimes get ministerial sign off for appointments outside recruitment. Secondments can get around it but as public sector HR I might take it seriously that a woman has been given the role of making tea while a man with (allegedly) no one experience has been given a more senior role without fair process.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page