Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Work

Chat with other users about all things related to working life on our Work forum.

Employment Solicitor - shall i move to public sector or private?

12 replies

HETZ8 · 31/08/2023 15:50

In a nutshell- I have almost 17 yrs pqe in employment law, trained in a regional/high st firm, moved to a west end firm upon qualification then a year later to a small commercial firm in the City for 6 yrs until I was made redundant (upon the firm closure) whilst on maternity leave. I then joined a new specialist employment practice - again v small firm and went on to have 2 more kids and for 6 years worked part time - 3 days a week only. We lost work and I took voluntary redundancy earlier this year and took a part time role as a lawyer in a local authority. At first I hated it - so much bureaucracy, lack of admin support- total culture shock, most of the work is litigious and colleagues are ok but it feels a bit blah, like i've given up on my career or gone backwards or back in time plus due to ET deadlines etc it can be quite stressful BUT the defined benefit pension is v attractive. My old firm have offered me my old job back as things have picked up but I really don't know what to do. Although I loved my old firm and the ppl I worked with are friends-I didn't have a pay rise in 8 years and have a very very tiny pension - lots of flexibility, school hours, low stress, good holidays (same as in LA) but no bonus or any financial benefits. Overall I'm v disillusioned with the Law in general and quite demotivated. I was offered 3 other roles earlier this year but they weren't right for a number of reasons - although all offered me part time working. My 3 kids are 4, 6 and 10 and DH works from home and does more than his fair share, plus I have support for holidays etc. BUT i'm at a cross roads - do I stay at the LA for the pension (plan would be to stay for 2 yrs to allow the DB pension to vest, put a whole years salary in and buy some more years to get around 5-6k pension per yr for life) and then leave BUT recruiters have said it will be really difficult to move from local gov back to private practice if i stay in LA for more than a year. Salary at both is pretty much the same - if i go back to PP i may have more options in terms of where I move to in future - in house would be great but almost impossible to get due to high competition and v few roles.

Has anyone done anything similar?

What other options might be open for me if I were to stay at the LA and leave in a couple of years workwise?

What would you do in my situation?? Really really confused and stressed - its keeping me up at night - help!

OP posts:
pilates · 31/08/2023 17:34

I would stick with the local authority; pension and stability are the overriding factors. Have you got chance to progress higher in local authority?

SecretShambles · 31/08/2023 21:47

I work in HR and will never, ever work in the public sector again. Far too much bureaucracy, red tape and pandering to unions. Much prefer the pace and relative freedom to act in the private sector, where decisions don't have to go through a million layers of hierarchy. YMMV

RoyKentFanclub · 31/08/2023 21:56

You’re 17 years pqe without a following. Stay put for the pension. In private practice you’re expensive but not bringing clients with you. Law firms are struggling to recruit at the moment but that won’t last and you’ll be first for the chop.

catmg · 31/08/2023 21:59

I would think your time in local authority will make you more attractive to in-house roles as local authority/ public sector more akin to in house act you can draw on that experience at interview.

Recruiter is talking nonsense in my experience. Stay in LA if its working for you. You have excellent private practice experience already, what's the point in going back?

HETZ8 · 31/08/2023 22:40

not sure that I'd want to progress in LA as it seems like it involves more responsibility, meetings etc but with not much more reward, plus the fact that you have v little/no admin support means a lot of time is spent on all that mind numbing stuff and I'm just not enthusiastic /motivated enough for it

OP posts:
HETZ8 · 31/08/2023 22:53

LA life is just depressing me a bit and I fear that I may be closing doors that I may not be ready to close just yet. If I go back to my old firm, I'll be working with a group of good friends, we share banter, laugh and know about whats going on with each of us - the work is varied and I got invited to quite a few interviews due to the variety of work I did whilst there. BUT the money isn't great and minimal pension and that will demotivate me. However, I fear that LA solicitors are stereotyped and i'm not comfortable with that and/or my work/experience will be less valued because its LA work and I'll forever be stuck in LA legal services for the rest of my career - which i don't want. I'm thinking i could go back to my old firm, do a year or 2 then job hunt again and if nothing suitable comes up then perhaps at some point in the future go back into an LA role (mainly for the pension and flexible working)- maybe when i'm in late 40's or 50's (am 43)

OP posts:
HETZ8 · 01/09/2023 18:49

Yes I would but most of these big city firms want lawyers from big well- known city /regional firms :(

OP posts:
alwayslearning789 · 01/09/2023 19:49

"Although I loved my old firm and the ppl I worked with are friends-I didn't have a pay rise in 8 years and have a very very tiny pension"

You've done 17 years with the above.

At 43 you are at prime pension accumulation age - in 17 years you'll be 60.

Your kids are approaching teens when they will really ramp up in terms of requiring extra worknand attention.

Do what's best for you and your family in the long term before you make any final decisions.

HermioneWeasley · 01/09/2023 19:58

Have you considered an in house role with a private company - fast paced and lots of variety.

HETZ8 · 02/09/2023 16:42

That's the problem, I was happier at my old firm but now that I'm in the public sector and thinking about pensions and my lack of pension to date I feel it would be silly and unwise to leave a job that provides a DB pension, even though I don't like it as much :(

I fear that i'd feel demotivated if I went back to my old firm as i know i'd be underpaid and only get minimal pension and have to pay into a private pension which would reduce my part time earnings even more..... wish I could find a job that i enjoyed, with a friendly team earning a decent salary with a decent pension - too much to ask?

OP posts:
HETZ8 · 02/09/2023 16:43

I'd love this type of role in an ideal world but they are hard to come by and highly sought - not sure I'd even get a look in :(

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page