Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Work

Chat with other users about all things related to working life on our Work forum.

Which job would you choose?

7 replies

ChristmasJumpers · 31/10/2022 16:53

DH applied for a new job after working in his current role for 12 months. He was approached by the new company and has been successful at interview. He currently earns £24.5k in a graduate position after doing a masters.

The new employer asked him for his salary requirements, he asked for £30k and has been offered this. Working hours slightly longer (by 2 hours per week) but working pattern much the same with hybrid office/home working and shorter Fridays.

His current employer has now countered to £31k in a bid to keep him! He doesn't know what to do, we've never worked in industries that can do this before.

If it helps, I'm pregnant and neither company offers full paternity pay, just statutory. He will not qualify for statutory paternity pay in the new job as he won't have been there long enough so we'll be 2 weeks salary down.

The new role promises regular pay reviews and good progression routes but don't all companies say this at interview stage? He does feel a little stagnant in his current role but they are now offering more money (and he'll get his statutory paternity pay).

I say better the devil you know. He tends to romanticise new jobs and the promises that come with them. What do we doooo? We are making the decision together but really they're both so similar we're stuck!

OP posts:
KurriKawari · 31/10/2022 21:31

That's a huge jump for his current employer, means they think he's worth it and we're underpaying him before. Is he happy at the company? I move jobs regularly and do see the attraction of new place, new faces etc, depends how much he wants that.

KurriKawari · 31/10/2022 21:32

Just realised his current employer is only offering £1k more than new role, divide by 12 months and deduct tax, it isn't much at all than new job. I'd go for new job.

NotRainingToday · 31/10/2022 21:36

I'd go for the new job. If they start at £30k, they may well be happy to go to £33 in a year, then £35 etc. etc. He will never be limited by having started on £24.5k

The paternity leave seems like a big deal now, but it's quite small in the broad scheme of things.

Move22 · 31/10/2022 21:41

The new job.
also ask them re paternity. It won’t be SPP but if they’re keen to get him they may agree to pay \ match the paternity pay.

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 31/10/2022 21:43

The new job sounds like a real step up in terms of development and opportunities so I’d go with that.

WorkCleanRepeat · 31/10/2022 22:31

The new one. The old job is likely to try and leave him on 30K forever!

ChristmasJumpers · 01/11/2022 11:09

Thanks all, I forgot to say in my OP that DH was a bit cheeky in telling his current employer that £31k is the offer from his new job. That's why they've also offered £31k.

My only other concern is that the new role was advertised for 3 months prior to him being approached to apply and we got the impression that he was the only person interviewing at that time (they worked completely to DH's schedule and never had to interview anyone after him before making a decision). It gives me a weird feeling that they struggled to fill the role!

They also told him that he'd get SPP and I did my own research to see that he wouldn't.

Oh and holidays are 20 days plus bank Holidays (he's currently on 25 days + BH). When he asked the new employer to match his current holidays they told him they're pretty sure it's being changed to 25 from January anyway but wouldn't put this in writing.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page