Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Work

Chat with other users about all things related to working life on our Work forum.

Feedback after interview

10 replies

pluiedeprintemps · 16/09/2020 22:18

Hi,

Im looking for opinions and want to know if the situation below is normal/common/plain strange. Thank you.

( I am not in the UK but in mainland Europe )

I currently have a job but am signed up with a recruitment as looking to change. I trust the recruiter 100% - they seem reactive, honest, organized.

A few weeks ago recruiter sends me a job description and the name of the company and asks if they can put my CV forward, company is pretty much household name and currently expanding fast.

I say go for, it let’s see. All good. Company wants to do a video interview. I agree to a day and time. Meeting all set up. I then get a call from recruiter who seems rather embarrassed and tells me they want to change day and time and do the call the next day. I shuffle round my diary and make it happen.

I read up on company, prep interview etc etc.

3 minutes before call Im all set up. I send email to interviewer to say I’m ready when you are.

I join call, she joins 5/6 minutes late, I don’t mention it ( of course ) she briefly introduces herself as talent acquisition and tells me a little about what she does and then starts asking lots of questions none of which are exactly relevant to my position. Seems quite junior. I answer the best I can. Call goes on for 1h40 minutes, she asks a lot of questions, tells me a lot about how company director works but in all honesty really didn’t seem to actually understand what my position entails ( corporate financial analyst). She asks for my salary expectations, I reply saying I would accept the number on their offer.
She then tells me that they actually already have a candidate and that they will probably sign with them but wanted to interview me just in case. I thank her for her time ( whilst fuming inside that they’ve wasted mine).

I then call recruiter who says they should have let me know that they already had someone in mind and cancelled interview. Recruiter is apologetic.

Next day talent acquisition sends email to recruiter that just says position has been filled and that she’s off on holiday ...

No other feedback. Two weeks later still no feedback. Fine but slightly peeved that my time was wasted ( prep + interview).

Found out through grapevine today that friend of friend of friend got the position. I reach out and congratulate them - we chat, I find out that 1) he wasn’t interviewed by talent acquisition lady I had my call with but by CFO 2) that he signed the day before I did video interview.

Are CV are pretty similar with this guy - same double degree - same professional certification - same experience, same previous position ( think him 7 at say KPMG and me at EY) - same double nationality.

Im happy for the guy who got the job and honestly the interview put me off so much that I wouldn’t have taken it if offered.

But I’m still pissed off about the process - is this how some companies work ? Do I just need to grow thicker skin ?

Thank you for taking the time to read long post!

OP posts:
NotSuchASmugMarriedNow1 · 16/09/2020 22:21

I always ask whether any internal applicants are applying for the position before I agree to go for an interview.

If there are internal applicants then it's a done deal that they will get the job - you're just interviewed to make up the numbers and for them to pretend that they recruited fairly.

pluiedeprintemps · 16/09/2020 22:21

Lot of spelling mistakes sorry - *OUR resumes are pretty similar

OP posts:
pluiedeprintemps · 16/09/2020 22:22

I could understand if he was internal , but he wasn’t ...

OP posts:
NotSuchASmugMarriedNow1 · 16/09/2020 22:23

Ah sorry I see that he wasn't an internal applicant - sorry i misread that.

Regardless, you were just interviewed so that they could pretend that their recruitment process was fair. It sucks.

waterandlemonjuice · 16/09/2020 22:25

Bloody rude of them and unprofessional but you’re going to have to chalk it up to experience

pluiedeprintemps · 16/09/2020 22:26

It does suck! Thank you. So going forward any how I can avoid having my time wasted in the future?

OP posts:
ALLIS0N · 16/09/2020 22:33

Ah. He wasn’t internal but he was a man. And I’m guessing you are a woman.

NotSuchASmugMarriedNow1 · 16/09/2020 22:36

So going forward any how I can avoid having my time wasted in the future?

You can't. You can ask if they have any internal applicants applying for the job but they don't have to tell you. I'd never bother going for an interview if an internal candidate was going.

pluiedeprintemps · 16/09/2020 22:46

@ALLIS0N

Ah. He wasn’t internal but he was a man. And I’m guessing you are a woman.
True - but honestly - given that he signed before I even interviewed - and that he started interviewing before they even had my CV - I’m not sure that played much.

I don’t feel discriminated against in any way - I just feel like I had my time wasted and spent over an hour and a half answering half baked irrelevant questions asked by a woman who had no idea what my job actually entails ...
I get that sometimes for numbers you have to interview candidates you’re not going to hire. But FFS - she kept me in the call for over an hour and half. If she knew it was just a numbers game surely 15 minutes and thank you very much would have been sufficient !

OP posts:
pluiedeprintemps · 16/09/2020 22:53

@NotSuchASmugMarriedNow1

So going forward any how I can avoid having my time wasted in the future?

You can't. You can ask if they have any internal applicants applying for the job but they don't have to tell you. I'd never bother going for an interview if an internal candidate was going.

Bon beh, c’est la vie alors !

That said I’m probably actually lucky because it’s the first time not had some sort of positive outcome from an interview. Of course I haven’t gotten all the jobs I’ve applied for in the past. But on the jobs I didn’t get, I’ve had some great interviewers and some great feedback/suggestions of what sort of position they thought would work for me. I actually got my current job following a recommendation from a company I had interviewed with and who didn’t take me ( they took an internal candidate). But at least when they interviewed me they were polite and relevant and gave me good coffee ...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page