Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Work

Chat with other users about all things related to working life on our Work forum.

Question for social science type academics - about bidding for external funding!

2 replies

unpacked · 19/04/2012 16:16

Hello fellow academics! This is probably a very strange place for this type of career advice but I thought I'd give it a go.

I am a relatively junior academic (just past post-doc). An opportunity has come up to bid for some external funding to conduct some research on behalf of an external body. This body would require a detailed report and I would be able to publish from the findings as well. The research is on an area in which I have already done a bit of work and would like to become an expert (by practitioners and other academics)!

My mentor has though suggested that I don't bid for it. He thinks that because I am not specifying the project and do not have total control over it, it would not lead to academic outputs with a sufficiently strong theoretical contribution. His advice is to devise a project of my own (albeit on a similar subject) from which I can publish, because that is the main priority, and not to worry about funding at this stage.

So question one: To bid, or not to bid?? And question two: IF I won the project, where would the money actually go? As I said, I already have a salary and the research itself does not really have a cost, per se, other than my time and basics such as transcriptions. If I won the money, could this be used to pay my way out of some teaching responsibilities? My mentor doesn't have an answer to this.

I would ask others in my dept about this, but am concerned that my mentor would take this as a slight and think that I didn't trust his advice (he's sensitive like that, it can get TERRIBLY political).

Has anyone got any thoughts?

Many thanks!!

OP posts:
DonInKillerHeels · 19/04/2012 18:19

My advice would be not to publish anything at an early career stage that is not a) in a top peer-reviewed journal or b) (in my field) a single-authored book with a top academic press. I would even advise against publishing a chapter in an edited volume unless the editor has a proven track record of publication, it is full of "names", and it is with a top press.

If the principal output of the funding is a report or anything else non-peer-reviewed, or not with a top press, I would not bid for the funding. It would be career suicide, especially with the REF coming up.

Trust your mentor on this one. There will be plenty of other funding opportunities.

(And on the other issues - whether you can use the funding to get teaching buyout, etc - it will entirely depend on the idiosyncracies of your particular department and university. No-one else on MN will be able to help you.)

unpacked · 19/04/2012 19:15

Hi DonInKillerHeels, Thanks for taking the time to read my question and respond, I really appreciate it. You're right. And so is my mentor. I will not bid! Hopefully as you say there will be opportunities in the future. Thanks again!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page