Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Work

Chat with other users about all things related to working life on our Work forum.

help me understand what went on with this interview(long sorry)

5 replies

BestIsWest · 17/03/2012 01:30

About 18 months ago, after being made redundant, I applied for a job with a fairly large IT outsourcing company. Heard nothing but got a job with another company anyway. Anyway, a couple of weeks ago a HR person from the first company rang me up, out of the blue, and persuaded me to go for an interview with them. He said they were desperate for people with my skills in this area (fairly niche IT specialism), sent me a job description, told me the pay would be 7-10,000 more than what I'm on and that I could work from home and generally talked me into going to interview. I was a bit reluctant, took quite a bit of persuading but showed up for the interview anyway.

The interview took almost 2 hours, there were a set of technical questions, several of which I cocked up - but those I messed up were for the 'desirable' criteria not the essential - and having checked up afterwards several of my answers were correct and the interviewers were wrong. According to the 2 interviewers there were 2 vacancies, they were interviewing 2 external candidates and 2 internal - but they weren't keen on the 2 internal candidates as they had 2 people leaving and wanted to keep the full complement of staff.

Suffice to say, I didn't get the job,according to the feedback they had another candidate whose skills were a better match (really?). I am not really too bothered as I quite like my current job despite the commute, but I am angry at a) wasting a mornings leave, b) being taken in by the HR recruiter who was so desperate to get me in to interview. DH thinks it was all set up for me to fail from the start. So what was going on. Was I a victim of internal politics? Was I just ticking the HR recruiters boxes for his bonus or was I a poor candidate? Should I allow this to dent my confidence - which it definitely has?

OP posts:
Tortington · 17/03/2012 01:39

It sounds like you cocked it up and they were being kind in their feedback - push for more detailed feedback if you want more of an answer,.

you shouldn't let this dent your confidence - you have a job anyway - so fuck em

piprabbit · 17/03/2012 01:47

I would suspect that the HR person had been asked to find some extra bodies candidates at short notice and was coming under some pressure to meet a deadline. You were unlucky that your name cropped up.

It is quite possible that the other candidate had the 'desirable' skills, or simply got on better with the interviewer. This doesn't make you a poor candidate, just not the perfect person they were looking for. It is not a reflection on you in anyway. Someone is always going to be disappointed after an interview.

Think of it as useful interview practice, it's a useful skill to be able to test out now and again.

flowery · 17/03/2012 07:24

Why would they want to "set you up to fail"?

Sounds as though they wanted to widen the pool a bit to give them a few more options, so called you as being someone who might be good, but on the day you weren't successful.

mrsflower · 17/03/2012 09:25

Put it behind you. You are obviously not destined to work for this company.

Interviews are a mixed bag IMO. Some are awful and can dent your confidence. Others are great and make you feel like the best thing since sliced bread. It's just the way it goes. You're not going to be a great fit for every role/organisation.

BestIsWest · 17/03/2012 17:55

Thanks all, I just found it all a bit odd and it's been niggling me. I shall put it behind me and move on.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page