Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Work

Chat with other users about all things related to working life on our Work forum.

Have just had my yearly appraisal and it wasn't good...

10 replies

midlandsmother · 24/02/2012 14:11

Have been in my current job as a healthcare assistant for a year and last week had my first appraisal. The feedback I got was a very mixed bag. On the one hand apparently I have "excellent rapport" with patients, especially the "difficult ones", and good IT and admin skills, but on the other I "lack awareness", "seem in a world of my own", "start every shift looking like I've just arrived from Mars" and need to "co-ordinate my workload better". The senior member of staff who carried out my appraisal said she thinks I'd make an excellent administrator and she'd write me a glowing reference if I were to apply for an admin role within the NHS.

I actually came away feeling quite positive but now the things she said have sunk in and I'm wondering if she was subtlely encouraging me to look for another job. I wasn't planning on staying in this job forever, in fact I'd considered switching across to admin, aware it's more in line with my strengths, but I want another baby (am going to start trying imminently) and thought I'd stay in it for the duration of my pregnancy and maternity leave at least, and maybe even go back to it afterwards (it's part-time).

In our NHS Trust people do seem to be able to continue in their jobs even if they're not good at them - on our ward we are all aware of a healthcare assistant on a neighbouring ward whose numeracy is so poor she can't do basic things like add up fluid intake and she has been working there for 10 years! I'm not comparing myself to her, because I'm at least competent at my job, but I hate the thought of people talking about me behind my back like they do about her. I already felt kind of a klutz at work, very self-conscious, and have often sensed people getting impatient with me. Now I think I'm going to feel even less welcome. Do I stay or do I go?

OP posts:
hopenglory · 24/02/2012 14:17

Stay - but ask for tangible examples of what they mean by 'lack of awareness' 'in a world of my own' - the mars comment for example, exactly what did they mean by that? Also, if you need help to co-ordinate your workload better, then it should be provided.

If you agree that you have short-comings in some areas (and everybody does) then they have a responsibility to help you overcome them to do your job better.

SuePurblybilt · 24/02/2012 14:24

I agree, ask for more helpful feedback. It seems odd that they'd want to encourage someone with such good people skills into a (presumably) mostly back-office job. Maybe ask for progression suggestions that fit your skills a little better? Are there jobs that concentrate more on liaising with patients or outreach work or something? .

midlandsmother · 24/02/2012 14:41

Sorry, I forgot to say: they have come up with a personal development plan for me, which is for me to shadow a more experienced HCA. My progress is going to be reviewed in 3 months. I feel like I know what they mean by in a world of my own - during the appraisal I actually thought 'Oh my gosh, she is saying all the same things my teachers used to say when I was at school'. I'm just not very practical. I daydream. For example, the other day me and a nurse were about to give a patient a bed bath when she got called away. The patient was hooked up to various drips and things I wasn't familiar with and I wasn't really confident starting to wash him on my own so I just waited for her to come back and let my mind drift...then she came back and was annoyed with me for not starting. That kind of thing. My appraisor also said I don't use my initiative (ironic considering I used to successfully run the local branch of a national charity) and my heart doesn't seem to be in the job. Well, like I said, this isn't my dream career or anything, but then lots of people work jobs they don't exactly love and seem to do ok.

OP posts:
SuePurblybilt · 24/02/2012 14:45

OK. Well perhaps they have a point then, if you think it was a fair appraisal.
Could you look at an admin role? If you're not that fussed about the job? Or is it vastly different in terms of money/hours/benefits?

midlandsmother · 25/02/2012 11:25

Fair...yes, I suppose it was fair. I would think about looking for an admin role but I'm not sure I should when I hope to be going on maternity leave relatively soon. Also it would be more hours for less money (I work antisocial hours and get extra pay accordingly), though I think in the long term that's a price worth paying to feel more comfortable at work. Life's too short and all that.

OP posts:
midlandsmother · 25/02/2012 11:27

Basically it has been my plan for some time to look for an admin job but I was going to wait until after maternity leave. Now I don't know what to do.

OP posts:
hopenglory · 27/02/2012 18:15

so by the sounds of it, they don't want you out. They have identified that you have shortcomings. You agree with them. They have put a plan in place to help you. You have to decide whether you can improve - or I guess at your review in 3 months time they'll be having a different conversation.

With regards to the maternity leave issue - what if you don't end up pregnant immediately? You either need to decide to make a go of this job or actively seek something else. You're just treading water at the moment, daydreaming away, and that's not going to benefit anybody

BelaLug0si · 27/02/2012 23:03

Has any of this been fed back to you before your appraisal? Appraisals are supposed to be "no surprises".

Llareggub · 27/02/2012 23:14

When you say you just let your mind drift while you waited for your colleague to come back, I have visions of you just standing there. Having spent quite a few days on a busy hospital ward, I can't imagine it going down well with your colleagues to see you just kind of hanging around. There is always something to do in any job, and you need to get the hang of looking for things to do. If you aren't familiar with the assigned task, and need to wait, then look for something you know how to do.

Santa70 · 27/02/2012 23:18

"lack awareness", "seem in a world of my own", "start every shift looking like I've just arrived from Mars"

Totally wooly statements. No wonder you are left thinking what on earth she meant.

To put it in a nutshell your boss sounds crap at appraisals. These are not things you tell employees. You implement plans to develop their confidence and address the issues.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread