Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

A growing threat: the anti-rights movement in the UK says Amnesty who claim over 50% are Gender Critical groups

644 replies

IwantToRetire · 09/07/2026 17:01

Quote:

Anti-rights actors seek a society in which women and men have fixed and distinct roles, based on what they view as ‘natural’ and ‘traditional’. These actors perceive the idea that gender is socially constructed as a threat because it suggests that gender roles can, and do, change across societies and over time. In fact, progress in the rights of women and LGBT+ people has been underpinned by changing understandings of gender and social roles.

Anti-rights actors refer to this perceived threat as ‘gender ideology’, portraying it as an attack on national traditions, family structures, marriage and religious freedom. These narratives often seek to generate fear and uncertainty and rely on misinformation or exaggerated claims.

The term ‘gender ideology’ emerged in the context of debates within international institutions, particularly the United Nations, about gender equality and sexual and reproductive rights.

In 1964, the Holy See became a Permanent Observer at the UN General Assembly, the only religious body with this status. As a permanent observer the Holy See can participate in processes at the General Assembly as well as other UN bodies. It cannot vote but it has the possibility to co-sponsor resolutions if a member state requests a vote. Although it cannot vote, the Holy See can participate in UN discussions and processes and has played an influential role in debates on women's rights and LGBT+ rights.

The term ‘gender ideology’ gained prominence in response to progress on gender equality and Cairo in 1994. These conference were a landmark moment for the global women's rights movement. The Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action is widely regarded as a key international framework for advancing women's rights and gender equality, and states continue to report on its implementation through the Commission on the Status of Women.

While opposition to sexual and reproductive rights predates the Beijing conference, the term ‘gender ideology’ became a particularly important response to the advances achieved there. The phrase was coined to explain the growing influence of gender equality agendas and to mobilise opposition to them.

Although the term originated in debates at the international level, it has since become a broad political narrative used by a wide range of anti-rights actors. Today, it is often used to connect campaigns against gender equality, sexual and reproductive rights, and LGBT+ rights across different countries and contexts.

From intro to report at
https://media.amnesty.org.uk/documents/Report_-_A_growing_threat__the_anti-rights_movement_in_the_UK_July_2026.pdf

See images of the list of 51 groups Amnesty is claiming are right wing.

A growing threat: the anti-rights movement in the UK says Amnesty who claim over 50% are Gender Critical groups
A growing threat: the anti-rights movement in the UK says Amnesty who claim over 50% are Gender Critical groups
OP posts:
Thread gallery
58
Ereshkigalangcleg · Yesterday 11:47

EdithStourton · Yesterday 11:09

If you're an omnicause believer, you don't like the West and capitalism - as @nicepotoftea pointed out.

The most significant anti-Western countries are Russia, Iran and China. It's no surprise if the omnicausers start shilling for them.

How anyone can cast Ukraine as the bad guy in the current situation is completely beyond me.

But a lot of their supporters would have been putting blue and yellow frames around their social media profiles. I absolutely see Ukraine as omnicause but maybe there is a divide.

Ereshkigalangcleg · Yesterday 11:49

Obviously the left have always supported communist uprisings and revolutions etc but that wasn’t what the Ukraine situation was, Ukraine are clearly the victims and Russia the invading aggressors.

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 11:50

Ereshkigalangcleg · Yesterday 11:47

But a lot of their supporters would have been putting blue and yellow frames around their social media profiles. I absolutely see Ukraine as omnicause but maybe there is a divide.

There has always been cross party support for Ukraine. It's one of the few issues that isn't politically divisive in the UK.

Ereshkigalangcleg · Yesterday 11:50

Also don’t some of the same people wang on about Russian bots swaying elections etc?

PrettyDamnCosmic · Yesterday 13:00

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 11:50

There has always been cross party support for Ukraine. It's one of the few issues that isn't politically divisive in the UK.

Edited

Support for Ukraine from the Reform UK Party Ltd has been lukewarm. Farage is a Putin apologist & blamed NATO for the Russian invasion.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 13:03

Haven’t read quite all the way through today’s posts. Has this been shared yet?

https://murrayblackburnmackenzie.org/2026/07/13/amnesty-international-uk-rights-and-wrongs/

About half way through, beginning with the section “Related research and statements by Amnesty” they explain that the recent report was not an accidental one-off by a random person who shouldn’t have posted it, but rather is part of an ongoing Amnesty campaign.

Amnesty International UK: Rights and Wrongs - Murray Blackburn Mackenzie

Introduction This post provides an archive of material associated with Amnesty International UK’s decision to publish defamatory material about a large number of UK groups who do not agree with its position on sex and self-declared gender. Background:...

https://murrayblackburnmackenzie.org/2026/07/13/amnesty-international-uk-rights-and-wrongs/

Emilesgran · Yesterday 13:08

ItsCoolForCats · Yesterday 10:25

I think including Beira's Place in the report will be the undoing of Amnesty UK. I remember there was criticism when the Like a Snowball report came out, but smearing Sex Matters and FWS is par for the course. The outrage doesn't usually extend beyond GC circles.

Since the FWS judgement, TRAs (along with the media) have managed to keep the focus on toilets. They have elicited people's sympathies with stories of poor, vulnerable transwomen being afraid to leave the house because they can't go to the toilet and warning people that big, hairy trans men in the ladies loos will be sending "cis" women running in terror.

They have deliberately kept discussion away from rape crisis centres, shelters etc because they know this will be a much harder argument to win. The Amnesty report has torpedoed this and exposed the unreasonableness and selfishness of TRA demands. Of course TRAs will paint this as JKR using her wealth to silence them. But calling a service that provides specialist support to traumatised victims of sexual violence "anti-rights" is really beyond the pale, and I think it will get a lot of people off the fence. Amnesty have really fucked up.

Totally agree, except for all the other times I’ve thought “This will get people off the fence”. There’s an effect for sure, but my god it’s slow and painful.

Arran2024 · Yesterday 13:45

EdithStourton · Yesterday 11:09

If you're an omnicause believer, you don't like the West and capitalism - as @nicepotoftea pointed out.

The most significant anti-Western countries are Russia, Iran and China. It's no surprise if the omnicausers start shilling for them.

How anyone can cast Ukraine as the bad guy in the current situation is completely beyond me.

Ukraine was seen by many on the left as a bastion of far right wingers. There were a lot of people glad when Russia moved in.

JellySaurus · Yesterday 14:02

Arran2024 · Yesterday 13:45

Ukraine was seen by many on the left as a bastion of far right wingers. There were a lot of people glad when Russia moved in.

And Putin isn’t?

Do ‘the left’ still think Russia=USSR?

Ereshkigalangcleg · Yesterday 14:09

Exactly, definitely a split as the more moderate left and centrists definitely would have sided with Ukraine and bemoan Russian influence in politics. As pp said, it’s like these people think it’s the Cold War still.

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 14:15

JellySaurus · Yesterday 14:02

And Putin isn’t?

Do ‘the left’ still think Russia=USSR?

I think it's only a particular section of 'the left' - we still have some sensible politicians on the left and the right.

However, for e.g. Corbyn

America + Western Europe = baddies

Everyone else = goodies. If sometimes they act like baddies it is important to remember that it is not their fault, but the fault of the western imperialists.

Then there is Farage who I think is more motivated by money than anything else and a gang of ideological right wingers in America who believe that Putin has every right to invade whoever he wants.

So you can be pro-Russia for both anti-imperialist and pro-imperialist reasons.

Arran2024 · Yesterday 14:18

JellySaurus · Yesterday 14:02

And Putin isn’t?

Do ‘the left’ still think Russia=USSR?

There was a lot of propaganda back then that Ukraine was full of right wing Nazis. There were some very visible right wing groups and a lot of people over stated their importance. Putin said he was invading to rid the county of these right wingers. And for some Westerners, that sounded reasonable.

moto748e · Yesterday 16:16

It's not just the Left, though, is it? Seems to me a lot of the Spectator/Unherd/Medium people have always been unenthusiastic about Ukraine, and seem to believe that we should have done what they wanted us to do with Covid: do fuck all, and let it all happen.

Emilesgran · Yesterday 17:14

moto748e · Yesterday 16:16

It's not just the Left, though, is it? Seems to me a lot of the Spectator/Unherd/Medium people have always been unenthusiastic about Ukraine, and seem to believe that we should have done what they wanted us to do with Covid: do fuck all, and let it all happen.

Boris Johnson was enthusiastically pro Ukraine, more so than a significant part of the left.

As for Covid, as someone who strongly supported the original 3 week lockdown, and indeed the initial prolongations, I remember reading just before it all kicked off, in a Spectator type article, a warning that it would be a lot easier to declare a lockdown than to lift it, and that the damage done was not being considered - I remember it because it seemed like rubbish to me at the time. But in fact it was true.

So I think that’s not a very accurate description, or perhaps it just wasn’t as clear a right/left divide as in the US.

moto748e · Yesterday 17:44

Well, once again, we are not talking about the US.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Yesterday 19:47

ItsCoolForCats · Yesterday 10:25

I think including Beira's Place in the report will be the undoing of Amnesty UK. I remember there was criticism when the Like a Snowball report came out, but smearing Sex Matters and FWS is par for the course. The outrage doesn't usually extend beyond GC circles.

Since the FWS judgement, TRAs (along with the media) have managed to keep the focus on toilets. They have elicited people's sympathies with stories of poor, vulnerable transwomen being afraid to leave the house because they can't go to the toilet and warning people that big, hairy trans men in the ladies loos will be sending "cis" women running in terror.

They have deliberately kept discussion away from rape crisis centres, shelters etc because they know this will be a much harder argument to win. The Amnesty report has torpedoed this and exposed the unreasonableness and selfishness of TRA demands. Of course TRAs will paint this as JKR using her wealth to silence them. But calling a service that provides specialist support to traumatised victims of sexual violence "anti-rights" is really beyond the pale, and I think it will get a lot of people off the fence. Amnesty have really fucked up.

I think it is important to point out, as often as it might be relevant, that Beira's Place is NOT "anti-trans"; its pro-woman stance includes trans men who need it. Just not men who are trans, and seem to have access to all the other rape crisis centres and therefore don't need one that is for women and trans men only.

moto748e · Yesterday 23:20

Well, it's all about making it all about JKR (clickbait), isn't it? But it won't end well for them.

TempestTost · Today 00:21

moto748e · Yesterday 16:16

It's not just the Left, though, is it? Seems to me a lot of the Spectator/Unherd/Medium people have always been unenthusiastic about Ukraine, and seem to believe that we should have done what they wanted us to do with Covid: do fuck all, and let it all happen.

Most people I have seen who take this approach seem to be doing so for pragmatic reasons rather than ideological ones. They don't think Ukraine can prevail, and that if they keep trying with the support of the West, both will end up compromised.

moto748e · Today 00:31

TempestTost · Today 00:21

Most people I have seen who take this approach seem to be doing so for pragmatic reasons rather than ideological ones. They don't think Ukraine can prevail, and that if they keep trying with the support of the West, both will end up compromised.

I don't disagree with that. It's a poker game, isn't it and the West blinked first, and Putin won. So I guess the cynics who thought so were proved right.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread