Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Fascinating article about the failure and complicity of the BBC regarding transactivism

86 replies

lcakethereforeIam · 16/05/2026 09:10

In Unherd

https://archive.ph/hxJFg

https://unherd.com/2026/05/inside-the-capture-of-the-bbc/?edition=us

Long but worth a read.

Inside the capture of the BBC

https://unherd.com/2026/05/inside-the-capture-of-the-bbc/?edition=us

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · Today 09:27

OpheliaWitchoftheWoods · 16/05/2026 10:46

Only half way through but well worth a read, thank you.

a blind commitment to diversity and inclusion schemes, and a culture of intolerance

In fact, a blind commitment to severely LIMITING and restricting diversity and inclusion by controlling and manipulating the words and concepts to the advantage of small, powerful political and fantastically intolerant groups. This was about making 'diversity and inclusion' work to achieve the exact opposite.

Davie’s failure to grasp the journalistic implications of this is best exemplified by his use, as late as 2024, of the lazy mantra: “We have to be kind and caring in this and listen to people, and be nice!”

Which was, in actual reality rather than identified reality, enable and indulge certain politically identified groups unconditionally with extreme priviledge, while being extremely unkind and uncaring and erasing other people with different views. It was not being nice. It was a comfortable lie to avoid taking responsibility for very bad actions, and to participate in an elite group belief that enforcing these things on unwilling plebs - punishing dissenters, harming and overwhelming and actively hiding evidence of harms and the victims of these actions - was for some greater good.

In the opinion of this special elite group, who believed themselves superior to people Not Like Them.

This is one hell of a lot more serious on multiple levels than 'failure'. DEI was a concept intended to prevent this kind of control and abuse by the privileged and powerful. The privileged and powerful immediately took over and made it work for them, to gain greater control and dominance, while avoiding responsibility.

My university lecturer also presented many of the same lectures I did to BBC staff as part of BBC training.

One of these lectures covered the topic of the ethics of censorship.

His key point was this, and it's one of those things that's stuck in my head to this day.

He looked around the room and said, "you may all think I'm a chain smoking right winger and you may all think you are really progressive lefties in wanting to ban the daily mail, but one day you might really need it".

He then talked about censorship and who controlled the power of censors and how people with other views balanced things and both held each other to account.

His key point was that censors rarely had any accountability at all and there was very little transparency. He talked about how censorship in the right hands might be finding but you couldn't trust that to always be the case.

He was very perceptive about a lot of things that have since come to pass. He taught me to recognise them - that basically what I've tried to pass on here over the years. I wasn't a good student then but I think I've done good in the end.

Fwiw I don't think he was a right winger. I think he was a liberal who understood liberalism and the history of liberal democracy.

There are plenty of people who probably still work at the BBC who sat through a lecture where he said very similar. This is what is the most depressing thing of all to me.

NoFineBalance · Today 12:18

An interview with the author from the OP article, Rob Burley, on The Free Speech Union YouTube:

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ros0so0UW58

lcakethereforeIam · Today 18:13

It was a good article. I don't know how widely read it would have been on Unherd alone. I'm glad the Telegraph and now the Times have picked it up. Hopefully that will see it more widely disseminated.

OP posts:
KnottyAuty · Today 20:37

Very glad to hear that the Times and Telegraph have picked this up

RedToothBrush · Today 22:48

KnottyAuty · Today 20:37

Very glad to hear that the Times and Telegraph have picked this up

Likewise.

All those people in journalism - particularly those with beef at the BBC (and outside journalism but studied it like me) are starting to speak up properly. Not just in hushed whispers.

I do believe this is a force to be reckoned with.

Those of us who believed in journalism all along, and believe in it being impartial believe it stands before all else as it's the very thing that protects us all no matter what our individual politics.

I do not have to agree with you. I just have to believe that telling the truth as best as we can without compromise.

Transwomen can't be women and thats sad but it's the truth. And telling the truth is important to people who don't even want to admit it. For their sake as much as anyone else's.

I have said that the light of truth would always win through one way or another.

moto748e · Today 22:52

KnottyAuty · Today 20:37

Very glad to hear that the Times and Telegraph have picked this up

How long do we have to wait for the Guardian, and others? Serious stories, of major public interest, and they are choosing not to report them.

RedToothBrush · Today 22:55

moto748e · Today 22:52

How long do we have to wait for the Guardian, and others? Serious stories, of major public interest, and they are choosing not to report them.

These organisations are proving themselves not to be serious journalists, but instead are just opinion columnists.

mrshoho · Today 23:08

Grantham sex offender jailed for contacting young girls - BBC News https://share.google/pJtuxIVcivda8LJTl

Wow bbc reporter managed to type the entire article using no pronouns. It's still strange to read but way better than she/her.

Yet again another crime that never happens

moto748e · Today 23:09

RedToothBrush · Today 22:55

These organisations are proving themselves not to be serious journalists, but instead are just opinion columnists.

I think there are still some good journalists at the Guardian, women and men, but the editorial tone is deplorable. As I've said before, it seems to me nothing much changes whilst Viner is still in charge.

Paddingtonsmarmaladesandwich2 · Today 23:24

BendoftheBeginning · 16/05/2026 10:25

Oh God, have you ever seen what passes for news in other parts of the world? The US has become an absolute joke, despite all the posturing about free speech they were doing a couple of years ago.

I want the Beeb to take responsibility for the trans debacle, but you really are throwing the baby out with the bathwater. I prefer the Beeb as a U.K. public-funded counterpoint to all the billionaire-backed “news” channels and social media networks and their kowtowing to the new American kleptocracy. Give me journalism by pointy elbowed middle class British strivers over billionaire’s minions any day, at least we can plausibly argue the former should be responsible to us!

I agree, I can’t see how this is some ground breaking article

absolutely people need to think carefully about what they wish for - it’s like the get rid of monarchy..do you really want Farage or similar in Buckingham palace -

the main criticism I have of the Beeb is the insane bloody promoting misogynistic drag acts - really shouldn’t be doing it as a publicly funded body

of course the beeb want to be impartial
and talk in a balanced way about immigration and trans people instead of taking a GC view

New posts on this thread. Refresh page