Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

“I’m transfer” teen at higher ed open day

27 replies

SallyDraperGetInHere · 22/09/2025 01:24

I was manning a stand at a careers day this week. A teen came up to chat, and the first thing they said was ‘hi, I’m trans, and I just want to know, is this a sector where I’d be treated respectfully, or?’

First thing, before they even opened their mouth, it was clear to me that this was someone with something to say. They just stood out by their need to be heard.

Clearly a boy, 16-17, 5’10-11, wearing a uniform, stubbly, wearing a cap, bloke-y looking. A bit quirky.

My heart sank. He was on his own. Everyone else was in a group of 3-4. Clearly a kid without a friend.

I introduced myself; he told me his name was Melanie.

The fact that his very first question was about his trans acceptance-ness - not about whether he was interested in x sector to work in - made me feel ‘Jesus, this is what you’ve defined yourself by’: I’m trans, not ‘I’m interested in mechanics/ engineering/ history/ being a chef.’

The colleague I was with swiftly moved to reassure him, with anecdotes of trans people she knows who work in this field.

I was just left with this feeling - you’ve latched onto this thing to create a new person for yourself. You’re not a girl; you’re just a lost boy. I can’t help you be a girl. Please don’t think this is your key to happiness.

Poor kid. Poor boy. Thinking that reinventing himself as Melanie was going to gift him acceptance.

OP posts:
SallyDraperGetInHere · 25/09/2025 08:24

NumberTheory · 25/09/2025 03:03

I completely understand your assumptions about his having decided to be trans to distance himself from the friendless boy who struggles that he thought he was. You only saw him for a very short time so it is an assumption, but I get why you made it. My dc have several trans friends and it seems blindingly obvious with the two TIMs that this is what being trans does for them. They use it as a claim to cover up their lack of social skills and give themselves a story that seems like it has a happy ending - if only people would accept them as women. But they haven’t clicked that it isn’t gender that puts most people off them.

If that’s how it came across, I didn’t intend it - I don’t know that the trans identity was a choice based on his being friendless: just that he seemed lonely and a bit of a misfit, AND was saying he was trans; not one resulting from the other. (Edited) but reading back my OP, yes, I revealed a subconscious assumption.

OP posts:
TheCatsTongue · 25/09/2025 09:27

The concern with teenagers is that they are focussing on their trans identity at the expense of their qualifications etc. They will be unemployable because their trans needs got in the way of their education. They want to be (or been made to believe) the opposite sex, they don't want to be a mechanic, plumber, builder etc.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread