Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

'Miracle clinic' baby farms

51 replies

MixedFeelingsNoFeelings · 14/07/2025 10:01

I just heard an interview on the Today programme on R4 (approx 8.40am) between presenter Anna Foster and Harriet Coker, a British-born, British-trained social worker of Nigerian parents, who's visited around 35 African countries to investigate baby farms. It was following on from the news story that a baby brought unlawfully into the country from Nigeria has been adopted.

On the news, the story was presented pretty undramatically, almost as just another angle on immigration. But what lies behind it is a shocking revelation, to me at least.

I had heard of the existence of 'miracle clinics' in Africa, where women can get 'treatment' and emerge with a baby. What I didn't realise is that these places are supported by an organised trade that kidnaps, rapes, impregnates, and discards women, some of them girls as young as 13 or 14 (and as Harriet explained, 'Unfortunately, some of them actually end up dead') - to supply these lucrative babies. Who are then sold on to whoever can afford them, in Africa and around the world.

Although actually, looking at my transcript of the interview, money was never mentioned. It was all about, in the interviewer's words, the 'primal human instincts for babies' and the 'big emotions at play here'. Plus the stigma of adoption in African countries. Which means that people 'maybe choose not to acknowledge it [baby farming], because it would bring an end to their [infertility] journey'.

Wtf? We're talking almost incidentally about women being forced to have babies, sometimes dying or being murdered afterwards - a worse scenario than anything Margaret Atwood dreamed up - and that's the angle? That people should consider adoption before buying an ethically irresponsible baby?

Is it just me or is this mad...

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
LeftieRightsHoarder · 14/07/2025 10:12

This is horrific. I hope it leads to investigations and police action. Realistically though, I’m not greatly optimistic as it’s just one more way in which women are treated as livestock.
Well done Harriet Coker for speaking out.

Helleofabore · 14/07/2025 10:21

I hope all Harriet’s work pays off. This is horrific

ArabellaScott · 14/07/2025 11:34

Jesus H Christ.

MixedFeelingsNoFeelings · 14/07/2025 11:37

Chersfrozenface · 14/07/2025 10:42

The BBC News site has a story on this.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c98jl8jnz92o

That's a difficult read. Appreciate the share.

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 14/07/2025 11:39

You're right, OP, the presenter ignoring the horrific information about girls being raped and forced to give birth, and then whanging on about the 'primal' desire to have a baby is actually repugnant.

ArabellaScott · 14/07/2025 11:40

If you've got the transcript, could you post it here?

MixedFeelingsNoFeelings · 14/07/2025 12:15

ArabellaScott · 14/07/2025 11:40

If you've got the transcript, could you post it here?

Sure, here it is. It was useful to go through it again, because they do briefly mention that people pay for the babies, so I was wrong to say it wasn't mentioned. But obviously that's what drives the trade and somebody's making a lot of money out of it.

Anna Foster (Today presenter): ….It is the second case in three months that the BBC has reported of a baby being unlawfully brought to the UK from Nigeria. The government says falsely claiming to be the parent of a child to facilitate entry to the UK is illegal. Those found doing so will face the full force of the law. Across Africa, women being bullied or exploited into having babies to be sold is an increasing problem, and I've been speaking to Henrietta Coker about it. She is a British born, British trained social worker of Nigerian parents, and she's visited around 35 African countries as part of her work on this topic. She told me first of all about the stark reality of what the term ‘baby farming’ really means.

Harriet Coker (Social worker/investigator): What we're basically talking about is young girls who are either pregnant, have got nowhere to go, so they go into these mother and baby homes; or sometimes we're talking about young girls who aren't pregnant at all, and they just get kidnapped, get locked up in these organizations, they're raped, they're in prison, are forced to give birth, usually over a period about five years, at which point, sometimes they're let go. Unfortunately, some of them actually end up dead.
And what you have is those places being able to continue, being able to function and make money, because people are paying for these babies. So as soon as they close them down, they move. All of a sudden, Ondo State, the last couple of months, that's come up with people bringing children into the UK with documents that they don't have, and they're often not related. I'm not really sure how you stop this to be frank.

AF: It is one of the most primal human instincts. People wanting children who can't have them naturally, whatever the reason might be, there are big emotions at play here. That is one of the big challenges that you're facing.

HC: I mean, I think the desire to be parents is really strong. There are a disproportionate number of black children in the UK foster care system, but those children tend not to be babies, and adopters want babies. If you're looking at the African community, I think adoption is only just really beginning to be a thing. There used to be quite a stigma to it. If you attend one of these miracle clinics, or these kind of fake infertility clinics, you know, they can organize paperwork for you. So sometimes they give women injections and herbal remedies that allow this [?stomach swell] and some of the women do actually believe they're pregnant. I'm not sure that all the people buying these babies really understand what these organizations do, you know, how they breed babies. Some of these young girls are kids that can be as young as 13, 14. I don't think they think about those elements of it.

AF: The way you describe it as well, Henrietta, is… particularly the way you describe some of the places that you've seen…. it is unimaginable that a lot of people, a lot of these people, don't know what is going on behind the scenes. Maybe they just choose to not acknowledge it because it would bring an end to their journey. What should the UK Government usefully be doing to try and stop this from happening, to try and make it plain to people, if this is something they try and do and they feed that system, that it won't be allowed?

HC: The first case that I actually dealt with, when the Nigerian police went in there, she had 33 children. The woman had outstanding charges from five other West African countries where she was shipping children through. So I think there needs to be generally raising the awareness, perhaps DNA testing for children coming in, and I think encourage people to adopt in the UK system. I'm not saying that no international adoptions should ever happen. I think they should, but I think there are proper channels in Nigeria or whichever country, because I don't believe that it's just happening- in fact, I know it's definitely happening in other West African countries, and I should imagine it's happening across the global South, because the driving factors for this type of baby farming, it comes down to poverty, lack of women's rights, and in lots of ways. You say, What can the British government do? I'm not really sure, because I think the issues start in the countries where children are born.

AF: Henrietta, thank you so much for your time.

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 14/07/2025 14:43

thanks, OP, super helpful.

'...people are paying for these babies...

... It is one of the most primal human instincts. People wanting children who can't have them naturally, whatever the reason might be, there are big emotions at play here. That is one of the big challenges that you're facing...'

I've tried to reread to understand why, but I still think that's a very, very odd response when the interviewee has just been talking about kidnap, rape, and murder. Lots of people have 'big emotions' about things, it in no way means they are in any way going to go along with rape and murder.

I think it's the sheer self absorbedness of it. As if someone really, really wanting something is in any way a reason for going along with the most horrific crimes.

Anyway. The story itself is bad enough, and I wasn't aware. Those poor girls and women, and poor babies. Thanks for sharing.

Arran2024 · 14/07/2025 15:32

So this isn't surrogacy? That's an ethical nightmare in its own right, with women being trafficked, coerced or tricked into it. Prospective customers change their minds and discard the babies. Eugenics are being used, with men in particular choosing eg supermodel eggs but getting a poor woman to carry the baby. There have been cases of people in their 70s in the UK commissioning babies. The surrogates sign one sided contracts which they often dont understand. The prospective parents set all kinds of rules like banning pain relief in labour.

And yet all we get from our media is puff pieces about how amazing the parents' journey to parenthood has been.

TheSandgroper · 14/07/2025 15:57

Listen and learn. . Women have always been currency to men and even more so now.

And where do these girls forced into motherhood come from?
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chibok_schoolgirls_kidnapping

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ol8krO5SSdc

MixedFeelingsNoFeelings · 14/07/2025 16:02

That's exactly how I felt @ArabellaScott . I listened to it several times and couldn't believe what I was hearing - delivered in such mild, two-sides-to-every-story tones too.

I did wonder whether to bother transcribing the interview so I could post about it accurately on MN. But the BBC's focus seemed so bizarrely misplaced, to the point of being morally repugnant. It made the story more a human interest piece about childlessness and adoption than an expose of a horrific, widespread trade in captivity-bred babies and murdered young mothers.

I'm sure that wasn't the BBC's intention. And I can only applaud Harriet Coker in awe - bringing such profitable atrocities to light, in places where female life really is cheap, takes a courage and persistence I certainly don't possess. But I think her work was ill-served by the BBC in this instance.

OP posts:
CassOle · 14/07/2025 16:07

Bloody hell...

TheSandgroper · 14/07/2025 16:11

@ArabellaScott I read that transcript provided above and my immediate thought was Helen Joyce and the first question she was asked after the FWS Supreme Court win. “But what about the men?”

I believe we are seeing the same dogma at play.

myplace · 14/07/2025 16:31

Those poor girls and women and babies.

I remember several cases- a man bringing a baby in that he claimed was his but was unrelated to him or his wife.
Another of a woman bringing a child in.

Just appalling. And it needs to be spelled out- Miracle clinics are baby farms dealing in the rape of girls and the trafficking of babies.

Imicola · 14/07/2025 16:37

What a horrific story and an appalling reaction to it in the interview. Personally i think I'd be having more than some big emotions if my teenage daughter/ relative/ friend was kidnapped, trapped and forced to give birth in captivity like an animal. It's grotesque but it almost reads as though she is trying to excuse it, or rationalise it.

Toseland · 14/07/2025 17:13

This is where I feared we were going. The removal of the words Mother and maternity, the changing of language to "birthing bodies". The sterilisation of kids and being told you can just have a surrogate give you a baby.
I've said before they'll keep women like cattle if they can get away with it and gotten some odd looks. But here we are, our dystopian future.

IwantToRetire · 14/07/2025 17:42

Sadly this is old news, and despite it being reported at intervals over the past few years, nothing seems to have changed.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-66221990

https://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m0025b02/eye-investigations-nigerias-miracle-baby-scammers

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c78dyryreyxo

And worse the implication that it is because women want to be a "mother" this is what is causing this exploitation and worse to happen.

A baby whose face is not shown is held in the arms of a woman

Nigeria's fertility scam: ‘Pregnant’ for 15 months

Women in Nigeria desperate to conceive are drawn into a disturbing scam involving trafficked babies.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c78dyryreyxo

DuesToTheDirt · 14/07/2025 17:59

Chersfrozenface · 14/07/2025 10:42

The BBC News site has a story on this.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c98jl8jnz92o

I haven't heard the interview, but I read the article. There is a lot in there about the illegality of it, and the baby, but just two sentences about the birth mothers:

Some contained young girls who'd been kidnapped, raped, and forced to give birth repeatedly.
"Sometimes these girls are released," Ms Coker said, "other times they die during childbirth, or are murdered and placed in the grounds of the organisation."

Is it just me that found this by far the worst part of the story? Yes, it's illegal, yes the babies have been taken from their mothers - though on the plus side they are placed in a family that wants them. But the mothers? WTF

pushthebuttonnn · 14/07/2025 18:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

potpourree · 15/07/2025 09:46

I started to write a post on here yesterday but hadn't read the transcript or BBC article. It's horrific, as everyone has said.

MoltenLasagne · 15/07/2025 10:39

I don't know what Anna Foster is like as a presenter but that pivot to "big emotions" made me feel sick. It couldn't be more inappropriate if she tried.

There are young girls being kidnapped, raped and murdered for heavens sake, its no different morally from a black market trade in human organs. I'm sure you could make a valid "big feelings" argument for wanting a new kidney but I certainly wouldn't expect the BBC to be excusing it.

TheSandgroper · 15/07/2025 10:45

@MoltenLasagne well as it’s forcibly trading in uterine space, it is part of the organ trade, isn’t it? It’s just that it affects females and only females.

But I think your opinion in the BBC presenter is entirely correct.