Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Melanie Field: the former EGRC expert behind Labour's women's rights policy

131 replies

LetsTalkTwaddle · 29/06/2024 10:18

Word has it that Melanie Field, who was one of those behind an attempt to oust Baroness Kishwar Falkner from her position heading the EHRC, is the woman who is telling Keir Starmer and Angela Rayner what to say when asked about women's rights.

Last year Kishwar Falkner came under attack for alleged bullying and transphobia, which she was later cleared of. Melanie Field left the EHRC thereafter and set up as an independent adviser. It's Field, I'm told, who is behind the 'biological women and other, traumatised and vulnerable women who've been born in the wrong body' line that Keir Starmer et al are trotting out.

Field has also written an article on why the Equality Act is just fine and needs no clarification: she was apparently one of the key people who drafted it.

https://uk.linkedin.com/in/melanie-field-389901148

https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/do-we-need-amend-equality-act-protect-womens-rights-melanie-field-dyewe?trk=publicprofilearticleview

The previous head of the EHRC was David Isaac who also acted as Chair of Stonewall during the time he was in official office. Melanie Field was working in the EHRC during his period in the EHRC.

Elsewhere GC groups have noticed that Stonewall and other trans groups have gone very quiet about the use of the phrase 'biological women', which they would once have protested about, because TWAW. There's speculation that Stonewall and allies have agreed to pipe down in order to enable Labour to pursue the 'Biological and other women' line.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
UtopiaPlanitia · 19/04/2025 18:59

Article by Scott Wortley, legal academic, examining the negative comments made by Field regarding Supreme Court judgement:

https://scott-wortley.medium.com/the-strange-case-of-melanie-field-is-an-individual-civil-servants-views-on-policy-relevant-in-1cd89a9e69ef

"The policy Field had and which forms the basis of her comments was rejected by ministers (the decision makers lest we forget) in relation to the legislation and maternity provisions. The language used there reflected a distinct policy. And given that the broad presumption in relation to legislative interpretation, a point so fundamental it is central to initial lectures on legislative interpretation for new law students, that language is presumed to be used consistently and coherently across legislation this is indicative of the bill clearly not implementing the policy Field wanted but a distinct policy that ministers determined the legislation should have."

The strange case of Melanie Field: is an individual civil servant’s views on policy relevant in…

Today’s Guardian has an article entitled “Court ruling on ‘woman’ at odds with UK Equality Act aim, says ex-civil servant”…

https://scott-wortley.medium.com/the-strange-case-of-melanie-field-is-an-individual-civil-servants-views-on-policy-relevant-in-1cd89a9e69ef

DamsonGoldfinch · 16/11/2025 11:39

Melanie Field has written yet another article on why FWS judgment is wrong. Michael Forman has written a blog post on it: https://knowingius.org/p/what-is-a-womens-service-a-reply

Also her LinkedIn profile is really odd. She seems to have gone from Wycombe high school to executive director at EHRC without any steps in between.

What is a women's service? A reply to Melanie Field

Melanie Field, an independent advisor on equality and human rights who has worked in both the EHRC and the civil service, has written a detailed article on the practical implications of the For Women Scotland ruling.

https://knowingius.org/p/what-is-a-womens-service-a-reply

Ereshkigalangcleg · 16/11/2025 11:49

I read Foran’s piece earlier. Very good. He is forensic, and Field is a fool.

POWNewcastleEastWallsend · 17/11/2025 13:12

Peter Daly weighing in on Melanie Field's latest ramblings:

On Groups: A reply to Melanie Field

Peter Daly
Partner at Doyle Clayton - Workplace law and advisory
November 13, 2025

https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/groups-reply-melanie-field-peter-daly-inpze/

@DamsonGoldfinch her LinkedIn bio is strangely sparse! There is more info here:

"Prior to joining the Commission in 2014, Melanie had a 25-year Civil Service career working in the justice and health sectors and, for the last 15 years, specialising in equality and human rights policy. She led the development of significant advances in equality legislation, including outlawing sexual orientation discrimination in services and public functions and leading the creation and implementation of the Equality Act 2010, for which she was awarded the OBE in 2011. Her final Civil Service role was steering the parliamentary passage and subsequent implementation of the Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Act 2013."

fairnessfoundation.com/deepening-opportunity

Ereshkigalangcleg · 17/11/2025 14:01

That’s a great article from Peter Daly. Contrast the comments under his article on LI with the childish, tumblresque whiny ones under Field’s.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 17/11/2025 15:25

Idly wondering whether any enterprising journalist is investigating just how influential Field is with the government now? Thinking of the "anti trans" allegation email coming from the cabinet office, govt lawyers unexpectedly arguing for men having access to SS spaces "on a case by case basis" along with rumours that no 10 are putting pressure on the new gender clinics to start experimenting on children with the puberty blocker trial? 🤔

New posts on this thread. Refresh page