Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Why did my daughter become trans?

4 replies

WarriorN · 29/06/2022 05:55

A heartbreaking article. There were some really key points that stood out.

https://unherd.com/2022/06/why-did-my-daughter-become-trans/

It seems that a trans identity is offered to kids these days as a way out of their confusion and misery. All of us, or at least everyone that I have been close to, can remember our adolescence as difficult years. Feeling unacceptable, substandard, not cool enough. We struggled, were unhappy, but eventually found our way through. In my case it was through academic success, for my sister, sport. A close friend turned to music. What we did not have were people whispering to us in our bedrooms that our gender identity was the problem and changing it the solution.
...

  • But after several months of following influencers and other distressed kids online, a formal statement of a trans identity came in the form of a nicely put-together document sent by email, complete with illustrations. She placed herself somewhere between the middle and the boy end of a continuous line. The language was not hers. It was full of Americanised terminology, and was clearly copied across from materials helpfully provided by someone else.

...

I contacted organisations that profess expertise on the subject. But the trouble is, they nearly all point in one direction. You find Mermaids, the UK trans charity, on the first search. I called them to discuss binders and whether they were safe. That conversation was all about affirming my daughter’s decision and advising that the potential harm of not doing so was much greater than any drawbacks in doing so. They suggested getting on the waiting list for NHS gender services straight away “as there is a long waiting list”

...

The school brings in organisations to talk about trans identities in a positive way, but notably offers no differing points of view.
...
What is particularly baffling is why a mental difficulty that suddenly arises in adolescence is treated as a newly revealed truth, rather than a problem to be worked through and overcome.
...

Many are building their careers on this issue, both in the medical profession and in the burgeoning diversity industry.
...

School-leaders, ask yourselves why you have an annual month of excitement about the sex and gender diversity alphabet and precious little else the rest of the year on other issues like physical and mental disability.
For those making and implementing policy, ask yourselves whether you are being told the full story by the diversity industry, and why the voices of concerned parents and detransitioners are being widely ignored.
For parents with young children, especially girls, do not assume that your child will not be affected.

OP posts:
MrsHandMum · 01/07/2022 15:24

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

WarriorN · 03/07/2022 09:05

Bumping again, no idea why above comment was deleted.

OP posts:
JacquelinePot · 03/07/2022 09:09

It's just so incredibly depressing. Kids are being sold a lie and they don't even know until it's too late. We were lucky growing up, we had music subcultures where they now have "gender identities"

Kennykenkencat · 28/02/2023 22:07

Once saw a discussion with trans identifying teens who seem to have normal problems that everyone goes through during your teenage years.

It was like someone had told them that if you are born female and like having periods then you are a girl and if you don’t like them you are a boy

And if you were born male and like playing with trains you are a boy and if you like dolls then you are a girl.

It was pretty horrifying that no one had said to them that it was perfectly normal for both sexes to feel this way and the path to transitioning would bring with it stuff that cannot be undone and it’s own issues.

No one had told them that despite all the surgery and hormones and clothes and make up and hair cuts that you cannot change your sex.

If you are born male you will still have to have checkups done for prostate cancer.
No matter how much you believe that trans women are women it will not change your male internal organs.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page