Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

The week the trans spell was broken

41 replies

IamSarah · 07/04/2022 15:43

Brilliant article by Hadley Freeman. It's been quite a week:

unherd.com/2022/04/the-week-the-trans-spell-was-broken/

OP posts:
Ikeabag · 08/04/2022 00:24

I am so pleased. Geddon, Hadley. I've had her name on my mythical 2nd baby name list for a yonk because I like her a lot. It just got nudged to the top.

Slothtoes · 08/04/2022 08:24

As Tabbycar said:
I think it’s really important to send thanks to the EHRC, Johnson, Truss etc., for their measured, fair comments/guidance, and to copy in your MP

Agreed yes. I’m a Labour voter and agree it is important to encourage this speaking up after we’ve been ignored or actively silenced on this issue for years.

This is a politically significant moment and for now it looks like the prevailing political wind is in our favour. Thank goodness. But these supportive words from the PM haven’t changed anything legally.

In a polite, respectful encouraging way I would suggest thanking MPs, ministers and EHRC while NOT giving any impression that ‘the job here is done’ to Ministers or MPs.

With greatest respect Tabby I’d have held on to my appointment with my MP and said that given the prevailing sentiments expressed by Johnson and Javid this week, by Maya’s Respect my Sex Daily Mail front cover last week, now is the time for the Government to consider repealing GRA so that everyone relies equally on the Equality Act. We need an MP to bring that idea forward.

The government has only kicked GRA reform further down the road. Any future policians could have the opposite feelings and reopen it to extend the GRA to self ID. Future politicians with a less big majority will feel unwilling to touch this issue at all, because TRAs will continue to make toxic.

The GRA needs to be repealed. There’s lots of threads on here about why- but the ubiquitous misinformation around its implementation means that it amounts to self ID and that’s enough of a problem to need to repeal it.

One woman or girl in a hospital ward, prison cell, or public toilets raped or sexually abused, by a man who was justified to be in there because he identified himself as female. should have been enough to create action. It wasn’t though.

Threads like This Never Happens document all of that on here. Repeatedly women and girls have been avoidably hurt and traumatised. It’s because politics of any stripe doesn’t really care about women, the support humans. So we have to speak up.

In the UK, this is a local election period for many of us. Voting is in early May. I will write thank you emails but I will also write Respect My X letters and also ask for GRA repeal.

This is very important to do now because it seems vanishingly unlikely that the Tories are going to be retaining their 80 seat majority in Parliament at the next General Election. So we need actual action from them, and very quickly. Not just sensible words that gender critical women can agree with on here while we have put party politics aside to concentrate on this one issue.

I know I sound like a broken record but this is a campaign. We have a mountain to climb. One Daily Mail cover, one favourable prime ministerial answer, all these are brilliant milestones to energise us, but women can only relax properly once GRA is repealed.

The Tories haven’t done anything to help before and the Conservatives have been in government for the last 12 years. So we need to convince MPs of the urgency of this while we can.

Slothtoes · 08/04/2022 08:36

Apologies TabbyCat for typo

thinkingaboutLangCleg · 08/04/2022 08:37

Very encouraging news. BOOTS52, best of luck in Ireland. I hope once the wall starts crumbling, thousands more of us, around the world, will help to chip it away.

thinkingaboutLangCleg · 08/04/2022 08:43

And MangyInseam too, best of luck in Canada. I know it’s bad there — death threats to women, rat nailed to door of rape crisis centre etc. But many people just haven’t heard about trans activism. The more light is shed on it, the more people wake up and protest.

bellinisurge · 08/04/2022 08:46

@BOOTS52 , Ireland is an excellent example of how hard it will be to overturn SelfID if Labour get into power on the back of some UK voices saying "Let's just get rid of the Tories then sort it out"

The amazing work done by @TheCountessIE on Twitter and other Irish voices is so wonderful. But, Jesus, their struggle for sanity is so much harder than here in the UK.

For those who don't know, SelfID was sneaked into law in Ireland on the back of the historic and laudable law change to allow equal marriage. The "T" muscling in , as it always does, on the back of the hard fought LGB struggle for equal rights. The Mermaids/Stonewall equivalent TENI is finally getting attention as the scam machine it is - it hasn't posted accounts for 3 years and still gets public money. But it's a hard battle. And we should learn from the mistake of letting these scumbags enshrine themselves in law.

myfanwybygaslight · 08/04/2022 08:46

It's great, but the TRAs seem to be upping the lunacy of their threats. Just reported this little charmer for accusing JKR of being a holocaust denier.



BethnalGreenBambinos · 08/04/2022 08:51

IamSarah - what has happened to you is just appalling. The clarifications by the EHRC give me hope for you too. Flowers

Abhannmor · 08/04/2022 11:16

@BOOTS52 yes the Journal.ie seems to be a bit more open to common sense than most Irish social media.The Irish Times and Irish Independent have had some Gender Critical articles too recently. We are behind the curve though. It's still seen as cool and edgy to be unthinkingly pro trans regardless of the downside for gender non conforming children , lesbians etc.Change is coming though !

Oblomov22 · 08/04/2022 11:42

That article is really good.

Turningpurple · 08/04/2022 12:31

What a week. But they’ll redouble their efforts. I’m already seeing lots of ‘scared’ posts on Twitter from trans people who seem to think there’s going to be some violent backlash

That's their tactic though. Talk about unliteral literal violence. Make up loads of fake stats then declare how scared they are.

Except I do believe people are seeing through it

inventinglouise · 08/04/2022 14:04

Boris was the big one - I really feel like now that the PM has stated that biological sex matters we all can.

SwissBall · 08/04/2022 14:25

I’m glad Ruth Hunt was mentioned. I very much her actions will be under greater scrutiny at some point.

Artichokeleaves · 08/04/2022 15:01

@Turningpurple

What a week. But they’ll redouble their efforts. I’m already seeing lots of ‘scared’ posts on Twitter from trans people who seem to think there’s going to be some violent backlash

That's their tactic though. Talk about unliteral literal violence. Make up loads of fake stats then declare how scared they are.

Except I do believe people are seeing through it

Lots and lots of calm repeated reassurance needed that allowing female people to have their needs met too is not too much for anyone to bear. Or something to be scared of.

Females being able to access spaces too really is not the stuff of nightmares.

BastardtheCat · 08/04/2022 16:27

Incredible.

Hold the line.

2Gen · 08/04/2022 16:52

@BOOTS52

Also there was a new woman selected on some Women's counsel in Ireland and guess what a trans-woman.. Why is everything being taken over by trans-women. Are they bullying their way into things. Hopefully now things will change a little for the good of women and our safety and safety for the young women.
I don't follow RTÉ nor any MSM so I didn't know that. I find it scary and it makes me very angry. There's already been harm done to women in Ireland by this ideology ( I'm thinking of the man who'd murdered his mother then said he was a woman and was put into Limerick Women's prison. I think he also had stated he wanted to kill more women and was a sex offender too; frightening!) and now trans ideologues are being put in positions of power, and making of themselves yet another obstacle for women to advance themselves into positions where they could do some good for the rest of us, and worse still, work against the best interests of women. Sex discrimination in disguise! God help us. I'm sick to the back teeth of this whole thing! We do have most of the public on our side and need to keep standing up for ourselves, and encouraging our menfolk to back us up. I think women are much more assertive than they used to be so I am hopeful! I also hope common sense and decency will prevail!
New posts on this thread. Refresh page