Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Nadhim Zahawi answers on definition of a woman

29 replies

ChristinaXYZ · 01/04/2022 21:41

Education secretary Nadhim Zahawi interviewed in the Telegraph

"Mr Zahawi ... asked for the definition of a woman - an issue which has stumped Labour politicians - he said: “A woman is an adult human female. My favourite subject at school was human biology. It’s a straightforward answer.”"

OP posts:
Signalbox · 02/04/2022 18:16

Excellent. Perfect answer. What I want now from Zahawi and Javid (who also answered factually) is for them to start applying it in their policies. Single sex toilets, single sex wards, sensible sex ed policies that are age appropriate and factual etc.

This.

They should start with prisons rather than defending the indefensible in court. If you recognise what a woman is and still think it’s fine to lock them up with rapists then we are no better off than with Labour and self ID.

ResisterRex · 02/04/2022 18:40

I'm not a typist but have listened and done my best...CH = Christopher Hope (interviewer) NZ = Nadhim Zahawi

Q&A as reported

CH: it's a question of biology
NZ: Absolutely right

CH: does it matter? I mean, we shouldn't be talking about genetalia should we? At 10amm_ in a pub. It's dogging our political life isn't it?
NZ: and it really shouldn't and I'll tell you for why:

  1. We have to make sure we protect those who feel that, actually, their gender is male or female. It's right to protect them. We are a civilised society and a sign of a civilised society is how it protects its minorities. And, you kow, I would asbolutely make sure that happens either in our education system or in the rest of society. But you don't protect them by in some way, being ambiguous, being - you know - unable to answer simple questions around sex. And I think that's important.
The thing that slightly concerns me is, you know, we are a hugely tolerant society and my family had the beneficiaries of this incredible country this tolerant society, is, we don't want this debate to become intolerant, to become nasty. It's not us, it's not how we...

CH: Trans people don't want to be part of a culture war, they just wanna live their lives
NZ: Exactly right. Exactly right. And I don't - I'm not comfortable with this nastiness - you know, I, I, just think we shouldn't be living in a world where - you know - people who say exactly what I just said are then set upon, are attacked.
CH: And young people aren't having this debate, they're completely relaxed about it. Completely. It's a generational thing.
NZ: And that's the beautiful thing about it, right? The great thing about our, our values is we are an incredibly tolerant society. Of course, there are - you know - there are outliers. There are people who behave badly but we have a justice system that deals with that.

[end of gender/sex segment]

[there was no point 2 but point 1 was long and then the interviewer cut in]

ChristinaXYZ · 02/04/2022 20:19

@Purpletomato

Excellent. Perfect answer. What I want now from Zahawi and Javid (who also answered factually) is for them to start applying it in their policies. Single sex toilets, single sex wards, sensible sex ed policies that are age appropriate and factual etc.
Absolutely! Also, properly monitored sex of patients and staff too - with clear markers on everyone's records. So no-one 'accidentally' gets put into a ward that differs from his or her biological sex, and so when same sex staff for intimate care is requested the patient gets what he or she has bargained for.
OP posts:
DomesticatedZombie · 02/04/2022 20:56

Yes. This is the starting point, a clear definition. Now all the bullshit legislation and policy and conventions built on bullshit TWAW assertions need to be fixed.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread