Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Excellent article on Twitter-banned FTM campaigner Scott Newgent

6 replies

SocialConnection · 03/10/2021 12:44

Worth a read - Scott Newgent underwent serious complications from 'experimental' FTM surgery and is now actively campaigning from experience.

This has led to a Twitter ban.

thepostmillennial.com/transman-twitter-banned-for-speaking-against-gender-transition-of-children-fights-back?s=04

OP posts:
Masdintle · 03/10/2021 13:02

But Graham Linehan is Irish, not English. Scott Newgent is brave to highlight the potential problems of gender-affirming surgery.

Cailleach1 · 03/10/2021 14:10

That is obviously just a mistake. Probably due to IT crowd and Motherland. Of course, Linehan could be a dual citizen of the UK now anyway. The biggest thing to take away from that article is not that.

Three things are going around in my mind from that article.

1). Is it ethical to carry out surgery like this when it is so experimental. If there was an obligation on those carrying out the surgery to state all the things that could go wrong, could the person choosing the surgery complain about it subsequently. There is no standard of care, is there?

2). If deemed ok for adults to consent (knowing diagnosis may be a result of other issues, and not a cause). Then should health insurance pay out when others will inevitable be subsidising it, and all the complications involved. Remember it was elective and it was performed on an initially healthy body. Not all treatments for ill people are covered by insurance. So, maybe if the person choosing this cosmetic surgery had to pay themselves, at least they haven't done it at the expense of someone else.

3). Can someone really do any of these cosmetic surgeries to a child? Can a guardian really consent to this for a minor?

So, I wonder if SN was informed about the experimental nature of this surgery and how it could all go wrong. Also, were they told that there was no standard of care? How is someone's mental health and state of mind assessed before they seek this type of surgery?

There are so many questions. The main ones are how this passes any medical ethics standard; is there an obligation to make a patient fully informed of the problems that may occur, and is there any safeguarding of people who may not be in a state of mind to consent.

CreepingDeath · 03/10/2021 16:02

Interesting also that Twitter and Facebook were far more likely to take down post that contain alleged transphobia than antisemitism.

They really are terrified of anyone not following the party line, and aren't even pretending to be unbiased anymore. It's difficult because we like to see Twitter etc. as public spaces where discourse is possible. But of course they are privately owned companies, and can manipulate the narrative, which they are doing.

Well done Scott for speaking out. Hopefully it will helps others in that situation.

Jaysmith71 · 03/10/2021 16:05

Graham Linehan may be British by nationality, but he is not and can never be English.

ChristmasPlanning · 03/10/2021 16:08

What a horrific experience.

Cailleach1 · 03/10/2021 16:20

@Jaysmith71

Graham Linehan may be British by nationality, but he is not and can never be English.
Yes, indeed. Is this detail important to the subject matter of the article, though? British / English are used interchangeably by many non British people. It is written by someone from Quebec not libre .
New posts on this thread. Refresh page