Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How do I challenge this unfair, sexist NHS policy?

53 replies

WeeBisom · 22/04/2021 15:31

The NHS has a catch up programme for people who didn't get the HPV (Gardasil) vaccine at school. I missed out, so I was interested in getting vaccinated. The NHS website tells me that the upper age limit for women in the catch up programme is 25. My only option is to get the vaccine privately which is 475 quid.

However, the NHS has recently launched a catch up programme for men who have sex with men. They can get the vaccine up to age 45. Fine. But this catch up program also applies to trans women who have sex with men, and trans men who have sex with men. This means that (to use the NHS terminology) people assigned male at birth with a male identity, people assigned male at birth with a female identity, and people assigned female at birth with a male identity get the vaccine until age 45. People assigned female at birth with a female identity get the vaccine until 25 only. They have to go private.

This, on its face, seems arbitrarily unfair to me. If the activity is the same (having sex with men), then why are only a sub group of female patients excluded but every other patient gets almost 20 more years to get protected for free?

I want to challenge the fairness of this policy, or at least find out why the NHS has this in place. I think that it quite easily satisfies being discrimination on the basis of sex. I don't know if this is discrimination on the basis of 'gender reassignment' because I don't know if 'gender reassignment' is a symmetrical characteristic (ie, can protect people discriminated against for NOT undergoing gender reassignment.)Can anyone give me advice on how to do this? Can I put a complaint in, or submit a freedom of information request? It does seem unfair, right?

OP posts:
Cuntryhouse · 26/04/2021 10:48

I don't think it even matters if it's sexist, I'm more pissed off with the NHS as a medical organisation being captured by non-sensical identity politics. As a trans man, op, you are entitled to this jab should you want it.

sashh · 26/04/2021 10:54

I want to challenge the fairness of this policy, or at least find out why the NHS has this in place. I think that it quite easily satisfies being discrimination on the basis of sex.

It's quite a clear breach of the law but IMHO the EHRC have been stonewalled.

I would ask them why they have a policy that allows anyone with a penis to have the jab but not people who don't. Ask how long you need to 'identify' as a man for? A week? A Day? Maybe just for the appointment?

Then book your appointment and turn up, say you ID as a man, and demand the jab.

Maybe take the press with you.

Cuntryhouse · 26/04/2021 11:19

And when you go in and say you identify as a trans man, make sure you are looking ultra feminine: heels, big hair and make up etc.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page