Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

British Girls' fear of failure, Pisa rankings article

8 replies

HandsOffMyRights · 17/12/2019 10:02

Apologies for linking to The Guardian, but it was utterly depressing (not surprising though) to read that British girls have scored so highly for 'fear of failure'.

I have boys and, now that we are entering GCSE years, find myself worrying more about their mental health.

But reading this, along with deeplt worrying statistics about the numbers of teenage girls who are self-harming and struggling with eating disorders (more than three times the rate for boys) makes me so concerned for those girls.

www.theguardian.com/education/2019/dec/17/british-girls-fear-of-failure-pisa-ranking

OP posts:
OP posts:
ItsLikeHeardingCats · 17/12/2019 19:04

This is going to be controversial, but I think it's relevant:

I'm desperatly afraid of failure. I've been desperately afraid of failure for as long as I can think. And, yes, in my teens this meant self-harm and arguably an undiagnosed eating disorder. As an adult it has meant other stuff. I'm possibly the world's best postee child for imposter syndrome.

Here's where the controversial part comes in: my panic of failing is also my biggest asset. It's what motivates me to do better when literally nothinh else will anymore and I'm ready to throw the towel. I wish it weren't this way, but it is. I wish I were just inherently ambitious instead, but I'm not.

And, here comes the possibly horrifying part: it's worked like a charm for me. I've had one hell of a run in my career. I easily outrank people who've been in my line of work for twice as long and more.

This would simply be personal if it were only me - but it isn't. It's something I've come across in successful women over and over again. And in a significant minority of typically not overtly masculine men, too.

When I coach or mentor people, it's something I'm radically honest about (javing had the immense privilege of a mentor - a man in my case - who did the same for me). My advice is never to try and overcome your fear. I'm operating under the assumption that this is not a feasible option for most people affected. My advice is to get a solid grasp on reality, learn to tell the difference between what you think you are and what the rest of the world is likely to see in you, learn not to beat yourself up for having a good sob in the loo ahead of going into a meeting to negotiate the deal of your lifetime and to learn to a) recognise the fear as irrational but part of you and b) harness its power to make you more than you thought you could be out of sheer desperation over the notion you could not be good enough.

The first mentee I've ever given that talk is a senior exec. in her own right at this point and I'm immensely proud. The person who mentored me back in my days is unimaginably successful these days and I'm equally very, very proud.

Told you, this was going to be controversial!

Having said that, I'm not advocating for fear of failure. I'm advocating for radical self-acceptance and for the proposition that this should include acceptance of this fear and recognising its potential as a deiving force.

And, yes, my teens were utter shit!

ItsLikeHeardingCats · 17/12/2019 19:06

ETA: excuse typos. Sausage fingers and tiny mobile keyboard don't mix well ...

ARoombaOfOnesOwn · 17/12/2019 19:39

Interesting Cats. For me fear of failure stops me doing anything in case I don’t succeed/am 100% at it. I self-sabotage all the time - almost to make it ok when I don’t succeed as I didn’t give my all to it anyway so it doesn’t matter.

BolloxtoGender · 17/12/2019 19:52

Ikwym ARoomb about not trying in case you fail.

But I think with public exams which teens are so focused on, the difference is that they don’t have a choice and it the pressure is increased because of the ‘do or die’ narrative around it.

Grafittiqueen · 17/12/2019 20:09

Agree with roomba, my fear of failure in certain types of situations cripples me.

I perform extremely well in situations like exams, but situations where I have to perform in front of someone, even if it was something I could explain well on paper, I totally freeze for fear of saying something wrong or looking stupid. I have the same with driving, I didn't drive for years as so crippled by fear of failure and now though I am mostly over it if I have to drive someone else I am incredibly nervous.

ItsLikeHeardingCats · 17/12/2019 23:55

I self-sabotage all the time - almost to make it ok when I don’t succeed as I didn’t give my all to it anyway so it doesn’t matter.

Story of my entire life up to my early twenties. It quite literally took for me to be faced with the choice between "homeless and starving by next week" and "trying my very best anyway because with a great big deal of luck it might just mean scraping by so long as they're a tad distracted or learning a little bit more about how to fake it fir next time" before I managed to genuinely try despite my tendencies.

(And, yes, I did get lucky as hell: a firm I wouldn't have dreamed of applying to hired me via a recruiting consultant not bothered enough to properly explain where that CV was going precisely. I would have stopped her in her tracks had I realised.)

Siameasy · 18/12/2019 05:17

Perfectionism seems (anecdotally) to be a particularly female affliction. I used to be a sufferer and I used to think it was a good thing but I don’t now. “Perfectionism is the enemy of creativity”
After I had my DD I suffered with post-natal anxiety and the upside of that is that, having come out the other side, I learned to stop caring about 90% of things, I had to.
Women are conditioned to care about absolutely everything and take on everyone else’s burdens. Try acting “like a man” and see the disapproval.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread