Barracker - do you mind if I paraphrase what you've said? I have a meeting this week with an amazing feminist warrior lady and I think this argument articulates everything that we're currently struggling with!
You go right ahead. I'm 1.5 glasses of red wine down and not getting more articulate.
"If you treasure it, measure it"
We currently have no un-corrupted way of measuring sex inequality, because we stopped capturing sex in 2004, and started assuming women's 'gender' instead.
If it's mutable administratively upon request, and without empirical corroboration?
It's gender, not sex.
No matter what label it wears.
How do you measure inequality between females and males?
You have to have data.
What does the data currently capture?
Not Sex.
Passport? Gender
Driving licence? Gender
Public toilets? Gender
Sports? Gender
BIRTH CERTIFICATES? Can you change them from M2F or F2M upon meeting arbitrary conditions, whilst still remaining the sex you were born?
Yup.
Gender.
What we did, in 2004, is we said, legally, female and male are genders now, not sexes, because you can choose which one you want to be recorded as officially, despite empirical evidence showing you are the other sex. Criteria may apply, blah blah.
And in order to facilitate the lie of the century, we had to ASSUME that 49% of the population had a 'gender' of male (that matched their sex) and 51% of the population had a 'gender' of female (to match their sex) so that less than 1% of the population could claim to have a 'gender' that didn't match their sex, and which was going to supercede their sex, legally and officially.
So yeah.
Even if we think we are capturing sex based data at a population level, we categorically aren't.
We've been capturing 'gender' from that day forward, as if it was a real thing.
Without definitions, everything is smoke and mirrors, and obfuscation and misdirection.
Without recognising reality in law, we are deliberately ignoring reality.
You show me a right that women currently have.
I'll show you how it's no longer a woman's right, and how it can't be effectively enforced.
(I'm now two glasses in, and I told you I wouldn't get more articulate. or concise)
TLDR:
- Recognise it
- Define it
- Measure it
- Fight for it.