Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

NYT shilling for transgender criminal

4 replies

QuietContraryMary · 16/02/2019 23:06

www.nytimes.com/2019/02/15/nyregion/transgender-jail-hormone-therapy.html

See how many ways the NYT tries to avoid assigning agency to this criminal.

Starting with the title

"How a Trans Soldier Took On the Jail That Denied Her Medication, and Won"

Someone in civilian prison for civilian crimes after leaving the military is not a 'soldier'.

"She began her transition during a tour of Iraq. When jail doctors on Long Island "

Spoiler: the transition was with unprescribed internet drugs which caused liver damage.

'When the testosterone started to flow through her system, Jessica Sunderland felt the changes immediately.

“I had to do stuff to deal with the anger,” '

Let's just imply that the lack of hormone suppressants causes uncontrollable animal violence shall we? What is this shit?

"She was an army veteran who had served in Iraq, but at that moment, in the fall of 2012, she was in the Suffolk County Correctional Facility on charges of burglary, kept in a cell 21 hours per day, in a body at war with her conception of who she was."

Again the army status isn't particularly relevant here. If you commit crimes you are likely to end up in jail.

"On a recent afternoon in her lawyer’s office, Ms. Sunderland presented a new phase of her life, including life as a blonde, with long braided hair extensions that she flicked away"

Life as a blonde? Flicked? What is this shit? Some sort of porno fantasy?

"“Transgender folks are criminalized in our society,”

Well no, crime is criminalised.

“I think I’m a pretty fairly decent researcher,” she said. “I can discern stuff. I go online and I would compare 20 people’s regimens and say, all right, these three sound like they know what they’re doing. I kind of made my own regimen.”

Still, she knew she was on shaky ground. “I’m ordering prescription drugs over the internet on a military base in Iraq,”

Orly.

"the complications began after she returned home from Iraq in 2009. She found doctors to prescribe the hormones she had bought off the internet, including those at the Veterans Affairs hospital in Manhattan.

But she developed a growth on her liver that moved her doctors to discontinue the estrogen, maintaining only the testosterone blockers.

“I started going into menopause, having hot flashes,”

Orly2.

"Finally she had the liver growth surgically removed, through an incision running all the way across her abdomen, and her doctors cleared her to resume the estrogen. But the surgery put her out of work, and she started to buy street drugs to manage the pain from the operation, then for recreation. Soon she and an acquaintance were robbing houses to get money for drugs, including heroin and crack cocaine"

Yeah that sounds pretty criminal and pretty standard for Americans after surgery and pain medication.

"For 16 months, until she was finally transferred to a prison upstate, she received neither the estrogen nor the testosterone blockers.

At trial, the doctors testified that they cut off treatment out of concern that the liver growth might return."

Sounds reasonable.

"she has been unable to find work, even after earning a certificate in medical billing and coding at a nearby technical school.

Her classmates in the medical billing program found jobs, she said, but she has not. She was not sure what role bias played."

Are the classmates convicted felons?

"The jury found that the doctors had violated her constitutional right to necessary medical care and awarded her $355,000 in damages, plus a slightly larger sum that went to her lawyers."

Ah yes, a slightly larger sum to the lawyers. The real story here.

OP posts:
FlyingOink · 17/02/2019 08:02

Wow. Good find, OP.

doctors had violated her constitutional right to necessary medical care
Am I missing something? I thought without payment or insurance Americans only got emergency room care? Or is this Veteran's Association entitlement?

Last year, the federal Bureau of Prisons reversed an Obama-era guideline that considered inmates’ gender identity when assigning them to male or female housing.
The decision came one month after a transgender woman in Massachusetts was transferred to a women’s prison after suing under the Americans with Disabilities Act — a potentially landmark case because it applies disability protections to people whose sex at birth clashes with their sense of self.

Wow so going backwards, and now identifying as disabled...and no mention of any impact on female inmates.

the deputy sheriff, confirmed that the jail segregates inmates according to “current anatomical status,” which makes sense, there's a mention that one jail got males to search from waist down and female officers to do from waist up so it looks like a considered attempt was made to balance the rights of the employee and the inmate.

She said she has gotten used to using women’s bathrooms, and that no one had bothered her for it.
No shit, I wouldn't bother that person either without backup!

“I was crying almost every day,” Ms. Giordano said. “They did things for no reason. I didn’t give them a hard time. I never want to go through that again. No one should go through that.” She added: “It haunts me. It haunts me in my sleep. It just haunts me. It’s like I’m screaming but no one hears me...“Transgenders have always been the bottom of the pit. It’s not an easy life. I’m happy with who I am, but to go through what I had to go through, I would never want to have to go through that again...I would tell them that God is going to punish them,” she said of the Suffolk County jail staff. “Because I believe in God, and what you’re doing is wrong, and they knew what they did was wrong. It’s like a restaurant. Nobody ever leaves without paying. Life always has a way of getting a person back.”
This is another person who isn't the main subject of the article. It seems to jump from one story the the other. I googled "Alyssa Giordano" and found Giordano stands 5"11, weighs 190 pounds and was arrested for prostitution, with a further charge of "disorderly conduct".
Seems that Giordano had an armed pimp so I do have sympathy, and Giordano wasn't convinced of a violent offence.

Jessica Sunderland, (charged and legally known as Jeremy Sunderland) however is a burglar and admits to anger issues. Does that make Jessica Sunderland disabled? And imagine you were a burglary victim. Your house and your life have been turned upside down. You suffer with anxiety. And then you hear your burglar has won $355,000!

AnyOldPrion · 17/02/2019 08:12

So a transition started without medical guidance set this entire chain of events in action, costing the state an astonishing amount of money. More collateral from this out of control bandwagon.

FlyingOink · 17/02/2019 08:46

So a transition started without medical guidance set this entire chain of events in action, costing the state an astonishing amount of money. More collateral from this out of control bandwagon.
It is astonishing when you put it like that. However finances aside, I'm the US there's nothing to stop anyone starting transition really. The person could just go doctor shopping, and as I understand it could also sue if not "affirmed".
Interesting that whatever this person was taking had a toxic effect on the liver though.

QuietContraryMary · 17/02/2019 11:22

Perhaps it depends on the question of 'medical treatment'. Clearly if Sunderland had a tumour or something, then treatment would be 'necessary'. However in this case, despite the beliefs of TRAs, Sunderland essentially had decided to start taking hormones at an arbitrary point. The medical indication for gender treatment is essentially 'I want to'.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page