The logic of non-binary/ gender-fluid

[TrashyTerf]

I am honestly not saying this to be goady. I am genuinely trying to understand this issue further. I tried asking on a transgender sub on Reddit, but I was instantly banned. If it is too offensive to be discussed here, then I do apologize and will ask for it to be removed.

My question is this:

How can non-binary and gender-fluid exist alongside transgender?

From what I understand, transgender people believe that they have the wrong brain for their body. This error happens in the womb. Fine.

Non-binary people believe that they have no gender. But then, does this mean that their brain is genderless? Is this also an error in the womb?

Gender-fluid people believe that their gender changes daily. Does this mean that their brain changes daily too?

For me, the logic falls apart when comparing these three things. I don't think they can logically exist together.

Can someone talk me through it?

What I find frustrating about these people is that they can't see past the end of their own noses. Binary gender is harmful - but only for them because they're special and complex

Reminds me of the video the dear Magdalen did about Ash Hardell organizing an exemption just for themselves wrt work uniform so they didn't have to wear the required uniform for women. She included footage about the woman from the UK who fought the rules for all women to wear heels. The comparison was stark.

There is no logic. I think about gender / gender identity / stereotype like a jail. Transwoman is someone who was in a man's jail but chose to go into a woman's jail instead. Transmen grew up in a woman's jail but chooses to go into a man's jail instead. Neither are happy as they are still in a jail. Gender fluid people change their minds on which jail they want to be in today. Nonbinary people reject both jails yet don't accept they are a "sex" at all. Gender critical people say "I am this sex. I am not going to jail for you or anybody!*"

• had to add the Wayne's world reference

I think it’s all bs, I think non binary/gender neutral just means they claim to be whatever gender suits their agenda at any given point, eg they can pick and choose to their advantage.

I concur.

And yeah I am sure it's not a great analogy but it helps me try and get some logic of the absurdity of gender.

Best non binary article ever:

www.refinery29.com/en-us/2017/11/175870/gender-neutral-relationship-terms-lgbt

"Words so adorable we should all be using them..."

"Words so adorable we should all be using them..."

Navels so adorable we should all be gazing at them.

It was great to see my pibling, piblingspouse, nibling and niblingspouse the other day,

Actually hang on my nibling doesn't have a spouse, I meant my cousin.

And cousinspouse.

I like the analogy MrsJamin

It was great double plus good to see my pibling, piblingspouse, nibling and niblingspouse the other day,

Fixed your post for you, Ereshkigal

Double double plusgood suggestion there, HerFemaleness!

It's a peculiar modern condition to pathologise normal variations of behaviour.
The world's got smaller. We 'know' so many people and it's a challenge to find the thing that makes you important.

Thanks for explaining Stadt.

But what do clothes have to do with biology? Or our brains?

Additionally, what is the point of segregating people through the subjective notion of gender rather than sex? If gender is just about clothing then isn't that like separating people via music type?