Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

To Ministers, the NHS, Girl Guides, Top Shop - 'What is a TransWoman?'

76 replies

bigwhitecat · 20/07/2018 13:54

As we know, the reason so few people are outraged by the trans movement is because the issue appears so complex, and is fraught with sensitivities.

People don't understand what the fuss is about as it "affects so few people" or "transwomen suffer so much prejudice" that they deserve our sympathy and support.

People do not understand what 'transwomen' now means.

Trans activists argue that changes to the GRA won't make any difference because its "been this way for 10 years and it's all been fine . . "

What the public don't know is that 10 years ago 'transgender' largely referred to those suffering from Gender Dysphoria. Gender Dysphoria was described by the lead psychiatrist at Charing Cross Gender Identity Clinic as a 'vanishingly rare' condition. In 2011 this same expert stated that the rates of Gender Dysphoria were 'stable and unchanging'

It is no longer so.

I think the only way we can get people to sit up and listen is to force them to think about what we now mean by transwomen.

By the way, I know this is old news and that many have already tried this! I'm in awe of those women who have dedicated so much time and energy to highlighting the terrible unfairness of this ideology. However, often this question isn't posed by GC feminists on TV/ radio interviews, and it's so crucial to our argument. As soon as the public understands who exactly is included under the trans umbrella . . . game over.

Transgender people are not a homogenous group.

Let's present Stonewalls definitions to the ministers, the NHS, Girl Guides, Swim England and ask - in the interests of gatekeeping - who are we now calling a 'transwoman'. If it's all those groups under the Stonewall umbrella, then we are including those who very often don't identify as a women (either at all or part of the time), and derive sexual pleasure from cross dressing.

Is this Ok with them? If not, why not?

So far, this is the only question that made my NHS service sit up and listen. They admitted that we need to be clearer who we mean when we refer to trans people. No answer is forthcoming yet of course. . .

I rarely post, but am a regular (i.e. obsessive) lurker so want to say thanks to all of you who have educated and inspired me over recent months. The events of the past few days have been disheartening, but there are a growing number of us out there now. We're listening. We're trying to do our little bit. Thank you Smile

OP posts:
happydappy2 · 22/07/2018 19:39

tryingtolisten2 you are the first trans woman who has agreed with me that this makes sense, others just insist that they ARE women....which clearly makes natal women feel uncomfortable. I really hope that the more mature trans community can organise themselves and have a clear voice in all this heated debate. Lets face it, trans people have their own medical needs, ie checks for prostate cancer....how can it be in their interests to be labelled 'women'? You are brave for sticking your head above the parapet but I think you will find you have a LOT of support from women.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread