Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

just watched Pride and Prejudice... i love the film (Keira Knightly version) is the book hard going?

55 replies

juicychops · 11/07/2009 21:58

im dying to read it when i get a chance and a break from my studying

OP posts:
janeite · 12/07/2009 10:54

Well this one does it for me. Had never heard of MM before and have never heard of him since but I really liked him as Darcy.

boogiewoogie · 12/07/2009 21:00

Absolutely read the book OP! It's not difficult to read at all.

We have both versions on DVD and dh and I have just finished watching the BBC version which I would highly recommend as well. It's much truer to the book and I prefer nearly all the characters in this version than the KK one. KK smirks and giggles a bit too much, Judi Dench a bit too aggressive and overall, I didn't think that 2 hours did the book justice. See what you think.

elkiedee · 13/09/2009 23:34

P&P is the most readable of JA's books, I think, and if you like it Emma and Northanger Abbey are also pretty good reads. Mansfield Park is very readable but suffers from a deliberately boring heroine although it has some very funny moments.

I love the Emma Thompson version of Sense and Sensibility, but find the book quite dry. While I've read Persuasion, I don't remember it very well, that was probably me rather than the book as I have a terribly bad memory and at one stage used to read everything very fast and not remember any of it very well.

MarsLady · 13/09/2009 23:43

It's a lovely book. The KK version of the film leaves out so much and the American ending is crap!

It's such a lovely book. Read it. I've just re-read it for the umpteenth time. It's my favourite novel. It could have been written yesterday. It remains current.

choosyfloosy · 13/09/2009 23:47

To the OP - P&P is wonderful and Jane Austen is one of the few 'classic' authors who you can still read anytime, anywhere. However, beware - if you become too fond of the books, you end up posting stuff like this:

Colin Firth as Mr Darcy does the bit where he's really unappealing extremely well, but not the rest of it. And I even fancy Colin Firth in other things (he was in an ancient J B Priestly miniseries when we were all 20 years younger and was fabbo).

The Jennifer Ehle/CF version already looks extremely old and dated. Odd. The KK version is just too quick - P&P doesn't work as a single film IMO, and it's pretty annoying with so little time to spend aeons looking at Lizzie Bennett staring soulfully into mirrors - of all the things Lizzie Bennett would do, this is NOT one of them. I will watch Donald Sutherland in anything and he was OK as Mr B but I would have liked him to dive into a pond

Can I just say that the most recent Andrew Davies Sense and Sensibility adaptation was historically awful. In what universe do you decide to cut Jane Austen to time by - erm - removing all the dialogue?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page