The Rose Field - come over here once you’ve finished !

[CalmConfident]

Hi all, a place for us to discuss once we’ve finished reading the book!

I will never acknowledge this trilogy as ‘true’ or canon or whatever the word is.

It’s such a disappointment that one of the most wonderful storytellers alive today delivered something full of very essential issues with the story.

As someone who works in children’s publishing, clearly everyone is too scared to edit him properly now and it shows.

The thing I can’t get over is the fact that there are still open windows between our world and Lyra’s despite the fact that they were all closed at the end of Amber Spyglass. It is this that makes the ending of AS so complete and moving. I like La Belle Sauvage which works as a prequel. The other two sequels I will not revisit.