Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

50 Books Challenge Part Three

1000 replies

Southeastdweller · 24/02/2024 13:46

Welcome to the third thread of the 50 Book Challenge for this year.

The challenge is to read fifty books (or more!) in 2024, though reading fifty isn't mandatory. Any type of book can count, and please try to let us all know your thoughts on what you've read.

If possible, please can you embolden your titles and maybe authors as well of books you've read or going to read? It makes it much easier to keep track, especially when the threads move quickly at this time of the year.

The first thread is here and the second one here.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
25
EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 20/03/2024 18:38
  1. Unorthodox by Deborah Feldman

One woman's memoir of her journey from being a member of the Satmar Hasidic Jewish community in New York to breaking free on her own. It was the inspiration for the Netflix adaptation of the book of the same name and I'm sorry to say I did prefer the TV version. The book is well worth reading but I was riveted by the series and at just 266 pages, I did feel bogged down by the book and that it dragged.
I know a lot of people on here read this a few years ago to very positive reviews so if you want to and haven't it's currently 99p

TattiePants · 20/03/2024 19:24

@EineReiseDurchDieZeit I started Unorthodox this week and finding it interesting so far. I haven't watched the series so want to read the book first. I have a habit of buying books then finding it for 99p on kindle the following week.

I loved Any Human Heart so would highly recommend buying it for 99p.

@BestIsWest thanks for the Miep Gies recommendation. I watched A Small Light last week which was excellent.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 20/03/2024 19:27

The series was absolutely superb make sure you catch it

DuPainDuVinDuFromage · 20/03/2024 19:34

12 Politics on the Edge - Rory Stewart I like Rory on his podcast with Alastair Campbell, and remember feeling vague support for him as a sensible alternative to Boris Johnson in the conservative leadership campaign (not that I would ever have had a say in that!). I was slightly apprehensive about reading this after some mixed reviews on here ( I think in particular his reading voice on the Audible version is generally held to be incredibly irritating, especially accents/impressions!) but luckily I read this rather than listened to it 😂 I really enjoyed it and didn’t feel he came across as vain or supercilious - I think he is refreshingly aware of his own shortcomings, and also a genuinely good, clever and rational person - not something which is very common in politics (and, of course, he has now left politics - or at least parliament). Overall this is a bold for me, but I especially liked the parts where he talked about his constituency and his ministerial roles - the central leadership stuff was more familiar to me and also slightly less interesting.

MorriganManor · 20/03/2024 20:35

24 I Have Some Questions For You by Rebecca Makkai
Incredibly tedious. Made me physically twitch with boredom, like being trapped by someone in a corner who won’t shut up about people you don’t know and couldn’t give a shit about.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 20/03/2024 20:37

Wow! @MorriganManor sorry to hear that. The main character is intense though

MorriganManor · 20/03/2024 20:48

She was the problem @EineReiseDurchDieZeit . Forever blathering on, inserting herself into a tragedy while fakily berating herself for doing so. I can’t remember the last time a character bored me so much. Then there’d be a brief flash of interest, but very derivative of other books such as Penance or The Secret History or The Ninth House, before swinging back to Boring Bodie.
Technically it wasn’t a DNF but I wouldn’t win Mastermind with it as my Specialist Subject, put it that way.

LadybirdDaphne · 21/03/2024 09:41

17 Why is This a Question? - Paul Anthony Jones
Exploration of linguistic concepts, I would say for the lay reader who’s got quite a committed interest (much more in depth than a Susie Dent facts-about-quirky-words book, although I like those too!). It’s focused on the technical aspects of how language works, which it outlines very clearly, but doesn’t go into much depth about more ‘philosophical’ issues eg how far does language shape culture/is language uniquely human?

18 Nursery Earth: the wondrous lives of baby animals and the extraordinary ways they shape our world - Danna Staaf
I chose this on the basis of its very lovely cover, but didn’t realise it would be so squid-heavy. I learned a lot about larva and plankton, even if I didn’t particularly want to.

19 Writing for Busy Readers - Todd Rogers and Jessica Lasky- Fink
Quick primer on effective practical/business writing. It wouldn’t want a longer review.

50 Books Challenge Part Three
Stowickthevast · 21/03/2024 10:47

@MorriganManor I'm nearly halfway through but have read another book in between - never a good sign. Not sure whether I'll persevere, I'm struggling to care.

  1. The Candy House - Jennifer Egan. This is kind of a sequel to the Goon Squad and brings the characters and their kids into present and beyond. It's playing with the concepts of AI and social media, and where that's going. One of the characters has invented a product called Own Your Consciousness which allows all your memories to be uploaded, and then shared collectively. I thought the concepts throughout the book were interesting and strong, and liked the characters. It is written as interconnected chapters so you only follow one person for a chapter which can be frustrating but on the whole I really enjoyed it. I think it is better to read the Goon Squad first to better know the characters.
bibliomania · 21/03/2024 11:12

I learned a lot about larva and plankton, even if I didn't particularly want to.

This made me laugh, Ladybird.

MegBusset · 21/03/2024 13:58

18 Sandman: Fables and Reflections - Neil Gaiman

Another fine collection of Sandman stories- all standalone but on the theme of stories and storytelling.

ÚlldemoShúl · 21/03/2024 21:38

44 The Maiden by Kate Foster
The story of Christien, a woman sentenced to death for the murder of the man who was both her uncle and her lover. It is also narrated by Violet, a prostitute kept by the victim in his home. This is on the Women’s Prize longlist and I’m at a loss to see how it ended up there. It’s nothing new in terms of historical fiction and the writing is distinctly average. Meh.
(I DNFed The Blue Beautiful World by Karen Lord before this. It was nonsensical and irritating.)
I’m losing faith in this longlist. So far I’ve read 6- loved one, liked one a lot and everything else has been underwhelming so far.
On the other hand I’m enjoying the non-fiction list. I’ve read 4- loved one and really enjoyed two including my latest read.
45 A Flat Place by Noreen Masud
This book combines nature writing about flat places in England (and Pakistan) and the author’s struggles with complex PTSD and her family relationships. The family part was fascinating. The nature writing was beautiful but only tangentially connected to the other theme- it felt a little forced together. That said, I’m glad I read it.

Next up Young Queens and In Defence of the Act. I’m quite enjoying combining the two types together.

HenryTilneyBestBoy · 21/03/2024 23:23

Latest reads, both nonfiction turning on a key event in 1984, both recommended:

36 Killing Thatcher - Rory Carroll
Meticulous, balanced and gripping account of the 1984 Brighton bombing, which came within minutes and inches of achieving the feat in the title. I was only aware of the bare outlines of this event (taking place a few years before I was born) and was engrossed and shocked by many of this book's revelelations. While maintaining tight focus on a single explosion, Carroll also manages to give a broad sweep of its complex causes and consequences, including details of the IRA's jury-rigged development of long delay timers and tenuous supply chains involving Dutch anarchists, Boston mobsters, and Muammar Gaddafi, how interpersonal quirks shaped Thatcherite policy, the mutual mistrust between various UK police/security forces, how surveillance and fingerprint analysis were conducted before widespread CCTV and digitisation.... all without losing momentum, or a baseline of empathy for the people involved on every side, as human beings.

Slightly annoyingly, some sentences/paragraphs were repeated multiple times almost verbatim and several bits made me think this was primarily aimed at a general (American) audience (e.g. explaining what 'own goal' means?), so I'm not sure if it would be as impressive to someone who lived through these events or had more knowledge of them. I enjoyed the vivid, snappy writing style, but phrases like "History pirouetted on a twist of geometry" might not appeal to everyone.

37 A Bookshop of One's Own - Jane Cholmeley
Also in 1984, Jane Cholmeley opened the Silver Moon Women's Bookshop on Charing Cross Road in London with her partner Sue Butterworth and their friends (and dog Biff). It had become the largest women's bookshop in Europe by its closure in 2001. This is a memoir of those years, though nothing so structured as that makes it sound - more of a rummage through a rag-bag of reminiscences, including old diary entries, news clippings, minutes of staff meetings and snippets from letters and interviews with customers, staff, and writers. It includes plenty of the defiant, heartwarming and hilarious moments you'd expect of a plucky underdog tale but also darker, sadder fare: not just the obscene phone calls, homophobic and misogynistic abuse and violence faced by a radical feminist/lesbian bookshop but also failed relationships and the slow death of the business after the end of the Net Book Agreement (price control) and advent of Amazon.

Jane Cholmeley comes across as a chatty whirlwind of energy and the book jumps slightly dizzyingly from topic to topic. Consequently there wasn't enough about books for me (JC frankly admits to being more of a numbers person - the other staff would take the piss out of her catchphrase 'I've read the reviews!') and I wanted more insider publishing gossip and eccentric customer requests, but OTOH she would end the cute dog anecdotes / skirmishes with council bureaucracy / celeb authors gush just before I was tempted to start skimming. She's fair and open about her own mistakes and regrets, and the chapter about Silver Moon's closure is titled, movingly, "A Changing World". It made me wish I'd been able to visit the original shop, and feel the lack of a space like the one they created in the current world - ok, maybe without the idealistic voluntary staff toilet-cleaning rota, but definitely with the 80p Black Forest gateau slices.

satelliteheart · 21/03/2024 23:57
  1. Manhattan State of Mind by Rosa Lucas Crappy romance as I've had a houseful of sick kids and no ability to concentrate on anything "real". Second in the series. Lucy wakes up in the hospital following a severe head trauma. She quickly realises she has no memories from the previous year. Whilst attempting to retrieve her memories it turns out she had a serious relationship with her boss and he's trying to keep the reason for their break up a secret from her. Didn't love this but it passed the time and required limited brain power
GrannieMainland · 22/03/2024 06:27

I have 3 books to collect at the library today, and won't be able to read them all before I go on holiday after Easter, so minded to hand The Maiden straight back based on the consensus here!

  1. The Coiled Serpent by Camilla Grudova. Short stories by the author of Children of Paradise from last years Women's Prize list which divided opinion here - I was very much in the no camp, but I read this as it was a present. As you'd expect, very dark, surreal, grotesque stories. They're not linked exactly but repeated motifs throughout from the colour green, painted crockery and empty coffee jars, to poison and cannibalism. She's undoubtedly a very talented writer and is particularly good at creating eerie, uncanny settings which feel a bit like the Britain we recognise. The stories have a lot to say about work, food insecurity, violence against women. But, and I don't think I'm particularly prudish, why must they be SO disgusting?! Worth a read if you enjoyed her novel. Trigger warnings for absolutely everything.
Kinsters · 22/03/2024 06:35

I'm struggling through listening to Eve - Cat Bohanon I really wanted to enjoy this but, as another poster said upthread, it's painfully not gender critical. I don't think it even needs to be gender critical but please don't shoe horn transwomen into discussions where they don't belong. I'll keep going with it but it may end up being a DNF. At least it was a free credit with an audible trial..

I'm really enjoying The Assassin's Quest - Robin Hobb. Why did they make a TV show of Game of Thrones and not this?!

FortunaMajor · 22/03/2024 07:44

Grannie I've finished The Maiden this morning and you won't be missing out if you don't read it. It does not belong on that prize list.

Sadik · 22/03/2024 08:35

Very impressed with all your progress through the longlists. I'm still reading Shadows at Noon, currently about half way through. It's not the best written book I've ever read, but full of interesting content, & I'm feeling much better informed about the transition to independence & partition in particular.

Separately, I'm definitely not gender critical & move in circles with plenty of trans & non-binary people but I still wasn't inspired to read Eve - sounded very dubious to me even from the description. I think the next longlist book I'll look for is probably All That She Carried - I don't know if anyone else has read / is reading that one?

SapatSea · 22/03/2024 10:18

@FortunaMajor I agree The Maiden was a DNF for me

CluelessMama · 22/03/2024 11:52

Well done to those that are reading through various award lists - I'm finding the reviews really interesting and feel that you are saving the rest of us from the duds!

10. One Life: The True Story of Sir Nicholas Winton by Barbara Winton
This is a film tie in rerelease of the biography previously titled If It's Not Impossible: The Life of Sir Nicholas Winton. In 1938-39, Winton was involved with a group of Brits and Czech nationals who organised the transportation of hundreds of children out of Prague to live with foster families in the UK before the outbreak of WWII. His story came to prominence in two episodes of That's Life, shown on TV in the late 1980s. It was from seeing the footage from these programmes a few years ago that I came to hear of Winton and I was keen to see the recent film and read this book to find out more. Where the film very much flashes between the 1930s and the late 1980s, this biography is written by Winton's daughter who really set out share his whole life story and create an impression of who he was a person - strengths and flaws, achievements and failures. As such, I kept expecting it to flag and get bogged down in domestic life and Rotary meetings, but it actually held my attention and my interest all the way through. He led quite an extraordinary life but was also very adamant that he shouldn't be seen as a hero - he wanted others to feel that they could have a positive influence on events too. To me, the book succeeded in it's aim of exploring his life, who he was as a person and how he saw the world.

11. The Secret Garden by Frances Hodgson Burnett
Listened on audio to support DS who was struggling to get into reading this for homework. The beginning put him off - described by him as "I can't remember what the book is called, but it's set in India and everyone has died"!! The language also took a bit of getting into for him as some parts are written in the language of the time and there's also a lot written in Yorkshire dialect that he couldn't wrap his head around at first. It was a really nice experience to go through it together, chat about parts of it and hear his thoughts as the story developed.

12. The Moon Sister by Lucinda Riley
Book 5 in The Seven Sisters series, this time we are in modern day Highland Scotland and tracing ancestors back to Spanish gypsies, the caves of Sacromonte, flamenco dancing and fortune telling.
Long. Easy reading. Annoying in places (though less so than the previous book). Enjoyed it but didn't love it, and it didn't send me down the historical research rabbit holes that some of the other books have. Could see the ending coming a mile off. Made me want to go travelling which is a side effect I've noticed from the other books too. On to the next in the series next month.
(Slight aside - because these are so very long, I usually get them from the library in print and also listen to the Borrowbox audio. The Scottish accents in the audio of this one drove me up the wall!)

ASighMadeOfStone · 22/03/2024 14:15

Scuttling in quickly to do a couple of reviews

15 Unlawful Killing by Wendy Joseph.

I enjoyed this immensely and learned a lot about the beauty, and at times, utter frustration, of the jury/adversarial system in the law. The author is a QC (maybe KC now) and takes loosely based on cases she has judged stories to illustrate various facets of justice. It's beautifully written, the calm quiet prose I think is what makes it so very good- as befits someone from a world where every word is measured, and every word counts.

The only thing stopping me bolding it at the moment is that each chapter begins with a fictionalised background of how the killer ended up in the dock and I found that a bit forced. I did like her opinion piece about the case, and society in general, at the end of each chapter

16 The Girl Who Died by Ragnar Jonasson

A Ragnar standalone, and alone we shall leave it. It was shite.

PepeLePew · 22/03/2024 14:47

I didn't feel as if I'd done much reading recently but was well behind on reviews since the last thread so perhaps it's just the last week or so when I've been struggling to concentrate.

Real Tigers by Mick Herron
Dead Lions by Mick Herron
More from the Slough House crew – I read these in tandem with the Slow Horses TV show which is AMAZING. And liked them more as a result – I find the storytelling in these books occasionally bewildering (I probably am guilty of not paying enough attention and find the long complicated descriptions of action and fighting hard to follow) – so it’s helpful to have it brought to life on screen even though the plot diverges in places. I’ve got book 4 lined up from the library for this weekend, so will have to see how I get on without it. Whether or not I follow the plot in all its complexity, I’m there for Jackson Lamb who is the anti-hero for all time, smelly, rude and unrepentant in his awfulness.

Lilith by Nikki Marmery
Now that all the Greek myths have been retold from the female perspective (hard stare at Natalie Haynes and Pat Barker), it was inevitable that the Bible would be the next source of fiction of that type. Lilith is an interesting character in the Bible but who has a place in Jewish folklore as Adam’s first wife and has ended up with arguably an even worse reputation than Eve. This book leans heavily into the alternative view of Lilith as a source of female power, and tracks her through the centuries after she is cast out of Eden. Plot wise it’s a bit of a mess with some weird nonsensical stuff I couldn’t really be bothered to untangle, but I quite liked the anti-patriarchal vibe.

The Cancelling of the American Mind by Greg Lukiannoff and Riki Schlott
Somewhat tedious and smug discussion of why cancel culture has taken hold in the US and in particular in universities. I know they spent a lot of time trying to be balanced and show it’s a problem on both the left and the right and I’m sure there’s a good book waiting to be written about this issue, but this wasn’t it.

Airhead by Emily Maitlis
Entertaining romp through a variety of extraordinary interviews and encounters, from a pre-Presidential Donald Trump to Simon Cowell and Alan Partridge, as well as stories about big news events and how they are covered. This would be a great introduction to anyone interested in broadcast journalism. Maitlis is honest towards the end about her experiences with the stalker who has dogged her for years and the impact this has had, but doesn’t dwell on it elsewhere. She comes across as thoroughly likeable and good company. This suffers somewhat – through no fault of Emily’s – from the fact it doesn’t include details of the only Maitlis interview anyone really wants to know about which is the infamous Prince Andrew discussion.

The Stone Angel by Margaret Laurence
If this doesn’t make it onto my top five fiction books of the year then it will have been a really epic reading year. This is – though I had never heard of it – a Canadian classic, and apparently still widely read and studied in Canada. I mentioned it to a Canadian friend who was really surprised I’d never heard of it. Hagar is old, ill and dependent on her son and his wife. She’s irascible, difficult and absolutely bloody mindedly awesome in her refusal to let ageing get the better of her. As she fights against her family’s attempt to send her to a home, she looks back on her life, the people she loved and lost, and her experiences and regrets. This is funny and bitter and absolutely devastating. Hagar is a heroine for the ages, even though she’s an absolute pain in the ass and clearly has made a lot of her own troubles for her. I think that this is not a book for the young, though Laurence was only in her thirties when she wrote it, which is incredible. It’s insightful and compassionate and so well observed.
If I’d read this when I was younger, I’d have a very different view of this book, I think. I’m far from old, but have a lot more sympathy with ageing experience than would have been the case a couple of decades ago.

Rizzio by Denise Mina
So many of you read and recommended this, and thank you because I’d never have found it otherwise. Taut and tense account of the murder of Mary, Queen of Scot’s friend and adviser. Really good.

Fire Weather by John Vaillant
I think someone else reviewed this recently, and I agree that the strongest sections were those dealing with the huge fire that destroyed the Canadian town of Fort McMurray. I don’t know who the climate change sections were aimed at (though I did think perhaps the people running and working on the Alberta tar sands may have been the target for that - come for a well told tale of your recent trauma and stay for the sections where you learn how your job is literally causing the planet to burn!). The only "new" bit for me there was just how close the oil and gas industry came in the 1960s to alerting the world to climate change and its risks. How different things could be now if they'd chosen a different path.

Poor Things by Alistair Gray
Bella Baxter is a small child in the body of a young woman. Her mentor and creator lets her loose in the world to find her path, while she leaves a train of devastated men in her wake. This was a Frankenstein/Pygmalion mash up (DD’s words) with a healthy dose of Victorian grotesque thrown in. Really entertaining and thought provoking; it is very good on female agency, so much so that I had to keep reminding myself it was written by a man. I’ve not seen the film, which I believe only takes half the narrative. And dials up the sex which is only really alluded to here.

Tarahumara · 22/03/2024 15:43

@CluelessMama I hated the first chapter of The Secret Garden as a child. It was a favourite book of mine and I re-read it many times, but always skipped the first chapter after it gave me nightmares the first time!

Piggywaspushed · 22/03/2024 16:43

I know lots of you have loved it but I just cannot cannot get on with Demon Copperhead....

FuzzyCaoraDhubh · 22/03/2024 16:45

Which part are you on Piggy?
I thought it was very good without saying I loved it. * *

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.