Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

50 Books Challenge 2022 Part Five

1000 replies

Southeastdweller · 06/07/2022 06:53

Welcome to the fifth thread of the 50 Books Challenge for this year.

The challenge is to read fifty books (or more!) in 2022, though reading fifty isn't mandatory. Any type of book can count, it’s not too late to join, and please try to let us all know your thoughts on what you've read.

The first thread of the year is here, the second one here, the third one here and the fourth one here.

What are you reading?

OP posts:
Sadik · 14/09/2022 18:27

Romanmum I just saw Mudlarking in the library today & nearly picked it up - I'll have to borrow it next time I'm in. Mind you, at my current reading rate that might be a while, I have two e-library books on the go, and got 2 extra books today when picking up one reservation. (Inevitably in these circumstances I'm not reading any of the 5 library books, but instead a paper book that I own & could read at any time Grin )

RomanMum · 14/09/2022 18:50

@Sadik this sounds very familiar..!

Definitely worth borrowing.

Terpsichore · 14/09/2022 18:56

@RomanMum I felt exactly the same about the lack of illustrations in Mudlarking and tbh I still don’t understand what the issue was with not including them. However, she has a very good Twitter thread and is on Instagram as london.mudlark where she posts excellent photos of pretty much all of her finds, it’s definitely worth checking out both/either.

MegBusset · 14/09/2022 21:15

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 14/09/2022 12:35

It's narrated by Frances Mcdormand because she played Miss Pettigrew in the film Smile

Oh, that makes more sense! Though given that it's a very English comedy, I might change to "narrated by Frances McDormand, who inexplicably played Miss Pettigrew in the film" 😆

MamaNewtNewt · 14/09/2022 21:20

MegBusset · 14/09/2022 07:45

49 Miss Pettigrew Lives For A Day - Winifred Watson

This was a lot of fun. It's a 1930s kind of screwball comedy in which dowdy governess Miss Pettigrew, who at the ripe age of 40 has nothing to show for her life, answers a help wanted ad and is drawn into the glamorous life of nightclub singer Delicia Lafosse. Inexplicably narrated by Frances McDormand, whose attempts at an English accent are uneven to say the least.

I really enjoyed Miss Pettigrew, once I got used to Frances McDormand, but I didn't realise that she was even attempting an English accent which isn't a good sign!

RomanMum · 14/09/2022 21:53

@Terpsichore thanks, I'll check that out.

RazorstormUnicorn · 14/09/2022 22:54

41. Beartown by Fredrik Blackman
**
Mentioned on here as a great read and I went to look it up thinking it might a second volume of a book from a little while ago but how the bears in New Hampshire are running rampant thanks to the citizens liberal ideals.

I guessed wrong.

I read the blurb and wasn't too bothered until I saw its by the guy who wrote A Man Called Ove which I loved.

Anyway this is actually a book about ice hockey. And the town that is obsessed with ice hockey and how that affects how they bring up their children. Bits of the book are fairly heart wrenching and I was moved to tears on more than one occasion. It was a book that was hard to put down which is exactly what I wanted as an antidote the non fiction I insist on slogging through, though have downloaded more of for my upcoming holiday!

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 15/09/2022 00:07
  1. Fire And Blood by George RR Martin (Audible)

Full disclosure :

I was a mad and seriously overinvested fan of Game Of Thrones. Like, I used to watch the 2am simulcast in case I got spoiled by social media/the media. I was, like many, utterly letdown by the narrative tosh that was the last season, and fuming.

As a reader of The Song And Ice And Fire Series, I was/am also in the "Fucksake George, the excuses wore thin years ago" camp, which he bitches about on his blog, but he can bitch all he wants, to not have released the 6th book of 7 ELEVEN YEARS after the release of the 5th is a massive pisstake on the readership. He enjoys the media limelight more, its just a fact.

So when Fire And Blood came out I was very "Fuck you, George, where's Winds Of Winter and A Dream Of Spring ?

And then they made House Of The Dragon. And I love Matt Smith and here I am all excited each week, which I really wanted not to be, after being so letdown.

So, I had Audible credits, and this is narrated by Simon Vance, who is widely considered as one of the really "safe pair of hands" audio readers.

I was alternating it with Ducks, Newburyport but it quickly took over because I found it weirdly addictive.

It has been done as a mock history book, not as a fiction, which I think helps. The best part of it being dated before the events of GOT means that I am now confident that House Of The Dragon will have a more rounded and believable ending. These events are mostly covered in between Chapters 12-20 out of 24. After the big events in a war known as The Dance Of Dragons it peters out with the rather boring life of Aegon III. I understand that this was done to emulate the style of real history books but its just very anticlimatical.

There is a court fool in a lot of the later chapters called Mushroom, who disputes official histories with lurid versions of his own. Frankly, I just wanted Mushroom to fuck off.

I think you need to be similarly overinvested to appreciate this in all honesty, it's 27 hours long.

At the end there was an interview between George RR Martin and Dan Snow lasting 50 mins. I fast forwarded to the closing titles. Grin

bettbburg · 15/09/2022 02:40

Just popping in. Nothing much to report but I've read 3 books about a Lejog cycle ride, sailing round the world and an Australian travel journal.

Welshwabbit · 15/09/2022 06:20

52 A Change of Circumstance by Susan Hill

Latest Serrailler. You all know the drill. Quite enjoyed the Cat stuff. Some brutal County Lines storylines, none of which were really the point of the book. No idea why she decided to make Kieron so irritating in this one. The ending (not crime plot related, along with much of the book) was dire.

BestIsWest · 15/09/2022 08:10

I did enjoy that rant Eine. I am surrounded by GOT fans but it has passed me by, I’ve contemplated dipping a toe in and reading the books but fear I will get addicted.

DameHelena · 15/09/2022 11:09

I've been lurking but not posting, and now have a bit of a backlog to report (apologies), which I'm going to split into a few posts over a couple of days to save my typing fingers and so as not to totally take over the thread!

Love is Blind, William Boyd
I'd read Any Human Heart and was looking forward to this one.
The protagonist is a young Edinburgh man, Brodie Moncur, who in the late 19th century goes to work in Paris to escape his tyrannical clergyman father. He works as a piano tuner and meets a famous (and pretty odd) very successful concert pianist, who offers him basically a retainer to be 'his' tuner and travel with him, share the good fortune etc. He falls in love with the pianist's lover and things go a bit Pete Tong.

Without wishing to spoiler people, the book from here on in takes place across various places in Europe inc Paris, St Petersburg, Edinburgh and the South of France, and there are some great evocations of these places in the 19th century. It is basically a romance, with emotional highs and lows.
It's a bit odd in that, treated slightly differently; with the back-and-forth across countries it could have been a 'caper'.
I felt more moved at the end than I'd expected to, as I had felt throughout that I wasn't always all that engaged with the characters and what happened to them. I wasn't disappointed, but I'd say I wasn't overwhelmed either. Having said that, I'd say read it; it is very vivid about time and place and it does have the epic sweep of a good romance.

Sea State, Tabitha Lasley A journalistic account of the men who work on the oilfields in the North Sea, but also an account of how the writer fell for one of the men she interviews and started an affair with him (she left her boyfriend; he is married).
This is fascinating about the life and culture of oilfield workers: the loneliness and the super-macho environment; the pressures, emotional, mental and practical (there is shocking material about how disasters happen and how much they're covered up/minimised).
I found the author herself a bit tiresome though; she seemed a little in love with her image of herself as rather wild and out of control. A bit self-regarding.

Behind the Seams, Esme Young. I love the Sewing Bee and I love Esme, so I snapped this up on an Amazon Kindle deal. She has had an extraordinary life and career, but I wish she was (sorry Esme) a better and more analytical/reflective writer (or had a biographer instead); this is very much in the 'I was born, this was my family, I did this and then this happened' vein of bog-standard autobiog. There are amazing stories and events but she doesn't go into much detail or reflect on them at all and I often almost didn't notice things that had happened and had to go back and reread them to get the impact.
She does though light up when she talks about her 'real work', as she describes her teaching; she clearly adores her students and is inspired by teaching them. And she is clearly (and rightly) proud of the fashion house she and some female friends set up in the 60s; they were hugely successful and influential, plus she obviously finds it important that they were young women of quite modest means, doing it themselves and supporting one another. A frustrating read in some ways but worth it for these gems.

Crow Lake, Mary Lawson Set in very rural Canada, about a family whose parents are suddenly and tragically killed, and the children's lives thereafter. There is conflict between the desire for education and ambition and the need to make money, as well as the family's interactions with their community, some good and some not so. It's a slow burn, but I liked that. I would say the narrative is a little bit like reading an essay at times; the narrator, one of the children but now an adult, has a tendency to pretty much say things like 'Now I'm going to look back at what happened next between me and my brother' (not in so many words but this is the gist). This had the effect of keeping me at a bit of a distance from the emotional world of the novel at times. Overall, though, it's gripping and well written and observed, and very believable about the feelings and actions of the main characters.

More (quite a bit more!) to come when we can all face it...

Stokey · 15/09/2022 13:29

Thanks for the rant Eine. I haven't read Fire and Blood but did read the first five, although would say with diminishing returns particularly in books 4&5. I have been enjoying House of the Dragon but think I'll leave it as a TV show. On principle, I'm not reading anything else by GRRM until he gets his finger out and finishes GOT.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 15/09/2022 13:53

BestIsWest · 15/09/2022 08:10

I did enjoy that rant Eine. I am surrounded by GOT fans but it has passed me by, I’ve contemplated dipping a toe in and reading the books but fear I will get addicted.

Grin my pleasure

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 15/09/2022 13:55

Stokey · 15/09/2022 13:29

Thanks for the rant Eine. I haven't read Fire and Blood but did read the first five, although would say with diminishing returns particularly in books 4&5. I have been enjoying House of the Dragon but think I'll leave it as a TV show. On principle, I'm not reading anything else by GRRM until he gets his finger out and finishes GOT.

I abandoned my principles on the altar of Matt Smith, and would do so again Grin

Palegreenstars · 15/09/2022 17:29

I don’t even want him to finish GOT any more because I’d feel like I have to go back and re-read it all and whilst I enjoyed them I cannot give him another 5k pages of my time.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 15/09/2022 17:38

I really hear that, I don't think I have a reread in me either, there's so much stuff that's completely surplus to requirements as well. I also hate that I don't feel the series deserves the hours required to rewatch it unless you pretend they just never finished it, which is pointless.

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 15/09/2022 19:09

I thought I'd read Beartown but I haven't. DP has though, which is why it was on the Kindle, as we share an Amazon account.

I've just asked what he thought of it - and I quote,
"Terrible. It falls apart like a cheap suit."

Now I also see that it's about ice hockey, I think I'll steer clear!

FortunaMajor · 15/09/2022 19:16

There's someone who works in publishing doing an AMA at the moment.

If you have questions, now is the time!

FortunaMajor · 15/09/2022 20:16

Ive been having a bit of an easy reading session with some new authors.

Close to Home - Cara Hunter
A little girl goes missing from her garden in the middle of a large party. Nobody can figure out how. Local CID work the case.
I can't decide how I feel about this one. The plot twist having a plot twist felt a bit overkill. I'd probably read another but would reserve judgement. Might be a bit too far fetched for me.

The Defense - Steve Cavanagh
Con man turned lawyer gets coerced into representing a mob boss at trial after his daughter is kidnapped.
Someone recommended Fifty-Fifty which was the 5th outing of this character, so I decided to start with the first. This felt like a bit of a poundshop John Grisham. it was entertaining enough, but I don't feel like I would want to read all of them. I'll skip ahead as the plot for the other one sounds intriguing.

A Tidy Ending - Joanna Cannon
A woman dissatisfied with her life and husband gets slightly obsessed with the glossy magazines and brochures addressed to the previous resident that promise a much more glamourous lifestyle. A chance encounter means she sees an opportunity to make her life more interesting. Meanwhile her husband starts to act strangely as a spate of young women go missing in the local area.
Cleverly done. Very discombobulating from the start. You know things aren't quite as they seem and keep second guessing yourself on the inevitable plot twist. I can see this not being everyone's cup of tea, but I think it would suit those who enjoyed Elinor Oliphant.

The Gentle Art of Swedish Death Cleaning - Margareta Magnusson
A self help guide for those downsizing or decluttering with the focus being on the elderly needing to help their children out in advance of their death. She discusses her own experience of clearing out the house of a family member and how this led to her and her husband starting to consider their own home. There are some good points in here, but it is largely blinding obvious and more of a personal memoir that a manual. It would work as a gentle hint for someone as a gift, but isn't really much of a hand to anyone trying to tackle Level 6 Jumanji in their own home.

bibliomania · 15/09/2022 20:22

I've downloaded O Caledonia thanks to Boiledegg 's review. I've a feeling that I've been confusing it with My Antonia due to a similarity in syllables.

Mind you, before I read Watership Down I thought it was about a submarine.

Owlbookend · 15/09/2022 20:49

Enjoyed reading the review of Crow Lake @DameHelena. I read it when it was first published and really enjoyed it. Agree it keeps you gripped and the family dynamics are well drawn. It prompted me to search the author. I wasn't aware of her other novels & might give one of those a go.

  1. The Fell - Sarah Moss
After reading lots of Sarah Moss reviews on these threads I thought I'd give it a go. I was really hoping to read Night Waking, but it wasn't available on borrowbox. The only available Sarah Moss was an audible version of The Fell, so went for that. I haven't listened to an audiobook since borrowing story cassettes from the library as a child & I dont think I'd choose one again. I just didn't enjoy listening as much as I'd enjoy reading. The narration style seemed distracting. For those who havent read the previous reviews, it focuses on a women's decision to leave isolation and take a walk during the pandemic. You hear the thoughts of Kate the protagonist, her son Matt, her neighbour Alice and a member of the mountain rescue team. It took me a while to get into it, but started to enjoy it more as it got going. Alice & Matt's narratives engaged me much more than Kate's. Like one previous reviewer, I could really have done without the crow. I have an aversion to talking animals in books anyway, but this was made worse by the 'crow voice' used on the audible narration. Overall liked it in parts, but think I will enjoy some of the other Sarah Moss novels more.
YolandiFuckinVisser · 15/09/2022 21:54

Mind you, before I read Watership Down I thought it was about a submarine.
🤣

FortunaMajor · 15/09/2022 22:08

Biblio that's brilliant! Makes me feel better about my Moby Dick confusion. There's probably a new thread in there somewhere.

ABookWyrm · 15/09/2022 23:03
  1. Astonishing the Gods by Ben Okri
    A man arrives on an island of invisible people and begins a mysterious mission.
    A short, poetic novel, beautifully written with a meaning that's difficult to grasp. One of my favourite types of book. I loved it.

  2. Coastliners by Joanne Harris
    A young woman returns to her childhood home in an impoverished village on a French island after a ten year absence. She tries to improve the village's chances of prosperity but has to contend with the locals' tribalism and superstition.
    It's okay but I just didn't care enough about the fate of the village to really get into it.

  3. Paradoxical Undressing by Kristin Hersh
    A memoir of a hectic year in the life of the Throwing Muses front woman aged 18 - 19. It's about the band, her precarious living situation, mental health issues and more.
    It's brilliantly written, based on Hersh's diaries from the time. It feels very immediate and vivid, as if you're there with her at every moment.

  4. The Glass House by Eve Chase
    In 1971 young nanny Rita is moving to the country with the troubled family she works for. In the present day forty something Sylvie's life is slowly coming apart.
    It took me a while to get into but is quite an enjoyable read, even if things seemed to come together a little too easily.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread