Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

50 Books Challenge 2022 Part Five

1000 replies

Southeastdweller · 06/07/2022 06:53

Welcome to the fifth thread of the 50 Books Challenge for this year.

The challenge is to read fifty books (or more!) in 2022, though reading fifty isn't mandatory. Any type of book can count, it’s not too late to join, and please try to let us all know your thoughts on what you've read.

The first thread of the year is here, the second one here, the third one here and the fourth one here.

What are you reading?

OP posts:
FortunaMajor · 20/08/2022 22:30

I have been without internet for the best part of the week due to mast maintenance locally that gives occasional patchy and weak signal. I have got some serious reading done, but have had to store these up in my notes app to dump all at once.

All the Booker Prize talk has inspired me to hit up the longlist, an ongoing project, plus a few that got away in the past few years.

A Passage North - Anuk Arudpragasam
A young man in Sri Lanka is devastated to hear of the death of his grandmother's close friend in the north of the country that is still scarred from 30 years of civil war. He travels to her funeral contemplating the impact of the war on different people and figuring out his own failed relationship.

One of the most beautiful opening passages I have ever read. It contains a lot of navel gazing and alludes to the history, but the reader needs to put some work in on this. It's not a country I really knew anything about. It's very slow and meandering, so requires a bit of patience to get through.

I am about 1/4 into The Seven Moons Of Maali Almeida - Shehan Karunatilaka
This is also set in Sri Lanka, but is a completely different feel and provides a whistle stop tour of the main historical events through the lens of a murdered photojournalist who is caught in the "inbetween" in a short admin period which will determine his progression one way or the other in the afterlife.

Each book is too far one way, one gently hints at the history and the other bombards you with it. Had I know I'd have read them the other way round.

Trust - Hernan Diaz
This is a bit meta. A book within a book. Four incomplete manuscripts that together tell the rise and fall of a NY stock exchange tycoon and his wife who were a bit of an enigma to those around them.
I'm quite sure the finer points of this and its cleverness passed right over my head, but it's interesting to see events told by alternative voices with a different perspective on events.

Who They Was - Gabriel Krauze
Semi-autobiographical novel of a white Polish immigrant teen living a double life as a studious English lit undergrad by day and a violent Yardie gang member by night.

This is such a unique voice that grabs your attention straight away and doesn't let you go until you've been dragged through the underbelly of London criminal culture. It's very vividly written and it feels like you've experienced something visceral by the end.

Maps of Our Spectacular Bodies - Maddie Mortimer
I've pinched the blurb for this one.
This lyrical debut novel is at once a passionate coming-of-age story, a meditation on illness and death, and a kaleidoscopic journey through one woman’s life—told in part by the malevolent voice of her disease.

A mother finds out she has cancer for the second time while she navigates parenting a teenager. The book is told from a variety of different perspectives, including by her cancer cells as the narrative moves backwards and forwards through her life.

This does get a bit surreal in places, and doesn't always quite work, but overall is a wonderful and experimental piece of writing. I would be very surprised if it doesn't also appear on next year's Women's Prize List. It feels like a very prize worthy book.

The Colony - Audrey Magee
Two men descend on an isolated island off the West Coast of Ireland, one a British painter and the other a French Algerian linguist, who clash with each other and the locals about culture and the effect of outside influence. Both have experienced very different sides of Imperialism and this guides their feelings on what it is right to add or take away from somewhere that is not your own. The mounting tensions on the island are set against the escalating violence of the Provisional IRA on the mainland.
This is one of my standout reads of the year. Wonderfully drawn characters who stubbornly hold onto ideals while the ones who learn anything are the ones paying the price. I could see this being adapted very successfully for the stage.

Treacle Water - Alan Garner
Small boy meets a rag and bone man who helps him as she slips in and out of reality to deal with the mysterious bog-man who appears on the local marsh. He slips back and forth between his real life and scenes in his favourite comic.
If you figure out what the hell this was about, you're doing much better than me. Thank goodness it was short.

It had all the right words, but not necessarily written in the right order.

These have been interspersed with some lighter less taxing books, mostly to go with the book club theme of beach/holiday read.

The Dance Tree - Kiran Millwood Hargrave
1518 Strasbourg (based on real events) during a heatwave a lone woman develops a dancing sickness in which she cannot stop dancing in public, this soon affects many more local women and soon hundreds are dancing in the streets until their feet bleed. Local authorities are called in to resolve this and it affects one particular family with serious implications for the women involved.
I felt like this had a very different feel to The Mercies and while the plot wasn't as good, I think I liked it more.

Golden Girl - Elin Hilderbrand
Famous Nantucket author gets killed in a hit and run. On ascending to heaven she is allowed a short period of time to watch events unfold as her 3 young adult children come to terms with her death as the police investigate the accident. She is allowed 3 "nudges" where she can influence events below.
Not really my sort of thing and very cheesy, but it rattles along and is very immersive. The plot twist was easy to guess quite early on.

Beach Read - Emily Henry
Two authors who hate each other find themselves living in neighbouring cabins for the summer, each dealing with a breakup and writers block. They challenge each other to switch genres. The angsty lit fic male needs to come up with a romance, while the chic lit author is set upon writing the Great American Novel.
Entertaining enough RomCom, but again not really my thing. OK for a one off. I was told to find a beach read and took the brief very literally and read the first Google result.

Ghost Wall - Sarah Moss
Historical reenactment experience goes too far. A self professed expert brings his reluctant family to an Ancient Britain encampment being used to teach students about experiential archaeology. Tempers flare as some are taking the experience more seriously than others.
I've only ever read her more recent work so this felt very different. It didn't disappoint and she builds tension throughout. Although some earlier fans haven't really enjoyed her more recent style, I quite like it.

Wisdom of the Ancients: Life Lessons From Our Distant Past - Neil Oliver
He looks at various ancient cultures and civilisations to see what we can learn from them in modern society. Generally good, but a bit of a stretch at times in trying to tie it in to today's societal issues.

The Arrangements - Chimanda Ngozi Adichie
Short NYT story that retells Mrs Dalloway with Melania Trump as the lead. A window into the Trump family in the lead up to the 2016 election.
Quirky and fun.

Real Life Organizing: Clean and Clutter Free in 15 minutes a day - Cassandre Aarssen
Canadian decluttering guru sets out 4 personality types and gives different methods to sort out your house depending on how you work.
A bit cutesy and patronising in places, but by the end of the audiobook I was inspired to attack the junk drawer with gusto rather than trepidation. A few bits I've been toying with getting rid of were unceremoniously and unrepentantly dumped in the bin. I need to go to war with my house right now and this may be the key to motivating me.

Hopefully I have enough signal to both post and catch up on the thread. I may be some time.

FortunaMajor · 20/08/2022 22:38

I forgot one!

The House With the Golden Door - Elodie Harper
Middle installment of The Wolf Den trilogy, aka Pretty Woman rip off set in Ancient Pompeii. If you liked the first, you'll like this.

merryhouse · 20/08/2022 22:44

16 The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time by Mark Haddon

Another one I should have read when it first came out (when almost-2nd-year student S2 was a baby): I had too many expectations to appreciate it properly.

I'm not entirely convinced, though aware of the vast range of neurodiversity and that my own and family experiences are mostly undiagnosed. However it was an interesting way of looking at and presenting the story.

The ending felt a bit rushed.

Got another big popular book on economics next (then maybe I can reward myself with some time-travelling historians)

FortunaMajor · 20/08/2022 23:24

Piggy I am not sure how I feel about your accomplishment. Is it that you've physically run out of books, or have you been extremely picky about what makes the list? My magpie mind is struggling to keep up with mine. I wish you great joy in choosing what fills it again. A very exciting prospect.

MaryasBible if the book in a series is not too complex or full of detail that I will have to remember, then I will tend to leave a decent gap as binge reading can often cause disappointment. You often get bored or start to notice certain words/phrases that the author overuses. Some I think you have to read close together, or you risk needing to reread to refresh your memory.

DuPain the Alps LP book sounds fantastic. I spent 6 years in the Alps, 5 in France and I love the area in general. I was mostly based in the Tarentaise, but was fortunate to explore.

ChessieFL · 21/08/2022 05:58

I will never clear my TBR list because I cannot stop buying new books even though I have well over a hundred to read on my kindle alone, let alone all the actual books waiting to be read.

I don’t even think I would want to clear my TBR list. I find it comforting knowing that I have loads of new things to read even if something happens to stop me buying new books.

Piggywaspushed · 21/08/2022 07:19

I have physically run out of books. I have been trying to be restrained about buying new ones for a while now, so this is the pile I have had without adding much to it for about 2 years and religiously using my random number generator to get through it. Added to this is that not much published recently has appealed to me so I haven't felt huge urges to add anything.

I have just bought a few new books today so the pile will rise once more!

ChessieFL · 21/08/2022 07:27

It’s a good excuse to go book shopping Piggy!

CornishLizard · 21/08/2022 09:10

Have semi name-changed - still Cornish and blue..

The Summer Book by Tove Jansson tr. Thomas Teal A little girl named Sophia and her grandmother spend the summer on a tiny Scandinavian island.
The grandmother is gifted at entertaining Sophia - they build a miniature Venice, and the child’s sorrow over the accidental death of an angleworm is directed into a shared writing project. The child’s father is also on the island, but is very much a background presence.

The book, published in 1972, is described as a novel, but it is written in standalone chapters which make it read almost like short stories. It also feels autobiographical - I wondered if the author might have been the child, but from the introduction it seems that the grandmother is closer to the author’s mother and the child on the author’s niece, who is also named Sophia. The book’s island is recognisably the family’s actual summer island and photos of it feature on the beautiful cover. At first I assumed the book was about a single summer, but came to realise it is perhaps about many, a kind of distillation of summertime when it never gets dark spent on the island with a girl and her grandmother and the lovely relationship between them. Although I found the short-story-like experience of having to get back into the book every few pages not to my taste early on, I liked it more and more as I went along and the atmosphere built cumulatively, and I liked the way the book was brought to a close. I think the spirit of it will stay with me and I might return to it in winter for a dose of summer.

More Than a Woman by Caitlin Moran I listened to the audiobook, read by Moran herself, and it worked brilliantly in that format even for the concentration-span-challenged - though it is emphatically not suitable for listening to without headphones with children in the house. I’d previously tried one of her earlier books (possibly a collection of columns?) and quickly given up because I found it very know-it-all, but this book addresses the know-it-all earlier self hilariously in the first chapter and I was on her side from there on in. About life as a middle-aged woman coping with supporting both children and elderly parents and having to be ‘more than’ humanly possible. There’s discussion of various feminist topics from botox to social media pile-ons as well as a very moving account of living with her daughter’s eating disorder. Overall, the book is chatty, warm and funny and just the sort of thing that works for me as an audiobook.

IsFuzzyBeagMise · 21/08/2022 09:11

Exactly! I'm nearly at the end of mine with a few books left :)

CornishLizard · 21/08/2022 09:36

Just gone back through the thread. Congratulations piggy on clearing your tbr and managing not to acquire more over the last couple of years. I thought your random number method was interesting - did you ever cheat or turn up books that gave you a sinking feeling that made you realise you didn’t in fact want to sit down and read them? I have quite a few worthy books in that category.

Piggywaspushed · 21/08/2022 09:40

Never cheated! But, yes sometimes it made me realise I wasn't desperate to read a few lurkers.

satelliteheart · 21/08/2022 10:02

@MaryasBible I like to read a series all in one go so I can really immerse myself in the world of that series without distractions from other types of book. But with the Gregory series I am struggling a bit to stick to it

Are you reading it in published order or Gregory's recommended chronological order?

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 21/08/2022 11:03

I'm too frequently at the end of my 'to read' pile, especially in terms of fiction. I've generally got a non-fiction book on the go (and they often take a long time to read) but I struggle to find fiction and, when I do, it's usually read within a few days if I like it.

Boiledeggandtoast · 21/08/2022 11:58

Piggy I'm torn between huge admiration and the thought of a rising sense of panic that would sweep over me if I were ever to clear my TBR pile.

Return to Paris by Colette Rossant Disappointing sequel to Apricots on the Nile. One of the things I enjoyed about Apricots was the sense of time and place but this felt more formulaic and, critically, more solipsistic.

Moon Tiger by Penelope Lively A re-read after a recent recommendation on this thread - I'm sorry I can't remember who it was but very many thanks. I had read this when it first came out in the late 1980s but I think I must have been too young to appreciate its brilliance. Terrific.

I'm currently reading The Real and the Romantic by Frances Spalding - subtitled English Art between Two World Wars. This was a present and is a beautifully produced hardback with excellent reproductions. So far really interesting (if you like this sort of thing).

Boiledeggandtoast · 21/08/2022 12:01

Which I do!

cassandre · 21/08/2022 13:27

I can kinda sorta envision the possibility of getting through my fiction TBR pile, but the non-fiction one, no! I have a mountain of non-fic I want to read, but reading fiction is so much more effortless, it can't compare, especially when I'm tired at the end of the day.

Fortuna, lovely review of The Colony. Maps of Our Spectacular Bodies is one I've requested from the library.

Cornish, I loved The Summer Book when I read it some years ago.

cassandre · 21/08/2022 14:00

Btw I've just started to read The Canterbury Tales, inspired by DC1 who is doing The Merchant's Tale for his English A-level. I originally thought of reading them in the original Middle English, but have kind of given up on this idea as it's such slow going. And I have perfectionist tendencies, so if I read the whole thing conscientiously in Middle English, it will take up more of my summer reading time than I want it to. So I'm using David Wright's prose translation as well as his verse translation. I want notes, but I also don't want to get bogged down in notes. (Is it obvious that I'm a person who overthinks everything?) My day job involves reading medieval French, but I know nothing about medieval English, and I just want to read Chaucer for the joy of it.

Anyway, if anyone else has read The Canterbury Tales and has a translation or an edition to recommend, that would be great.

MaryasBible · 21/08/2022 14:04

satelliteheart · 21/08/2022 10:02

@MaryasBible I like to read a series all in one go so I can really immerse myself in the world of that series without distractions from other types of book. But with the Gregory series I am struggling a bit to stick to it

Are you reading it in published order or Gregory's recommended chronological order?

@satelliteheart I’m reading it in the order she recommends so started with The Lady of the Rivers. I got that for 99p on kindle. I’ve picked up the others second hand. The White Princess was also 99p on kindle. I don’t have The Constant Princess yet, but have a second hand copy of The King’s Curse ready for when I need it.

What order have you read them in?

Terpsichore · 21/08/2022 16:26

Nevill Coghill's rhyming translation in modern English was the version of The Canterbury Tales we had for O-levels, @cassandre (showing my age there!). His is the classic - the 1950s, so it's an oldie but still a goodie, I think. I hadn’t encountered the David Wright version but it looks interesting. We did the Prologue and the Franklin's Tale, about which I remember very little….!

(wasn’t the chapter on Chaucer in Meetings With Remarkable Manuscripts great, btw? 😊)

Sadik · 21/08/2022 16:30

I'm the opposite to many of you in that I hate having an 'enforced' tbr pile of actual books and if I don't read a book within quite a short time of acquiring it then I will most likely never read it. I think it's something about the fact that they sit there and look at me reprovingly from either shelf or kindle app. Books I've been given are the worst for this, I feel morally obliged to at least try them, but it can take me years to bring myself to it unless I start really quickly.

I do have a long wish-list of books to buy though, and I enjoy looking through it and choosing what I want to purchase next. I'm also a serial re-reader, so if I don't have a new book I'll happily re-visit an old one.

Unlike you Cassandre I find fiction much harder, and I generally have to stop every few pages to do something else or switch onto non-fiction for a bit (all that peril and emotional tension!).

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 21/08/2022 17:18

I am quite similar Sadik in that after I receive or buy - they are read quickly or sit there for years.

minsmum · 21/08/2022 18:15

Thank you for whoever recommended War Doctor, I have just finished it and thought it was brilliant, such a brave man.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 21/08/2022 18:29

16.Small Things Like These by Clare Keegan (Audible)

Local collier Bill Furlong begins to wonder about the treatment of young women at the convent. Like Foster this was very short, atmospheric and engaging. I can see why it was longlisted.

  1. Taft by Ann Patchett

John Nickel is a lonely and bored bartender. When siblings Fay and Carl Taft enter his life, trouble undoubtedly follows.

This was really well written and a total page turner, Ann Patchett is such a good writer. Sadly I didn't really believe that someone as perceptive and worldly wise as Nickel would leave himself so wide open to the risks these vulnerable teens obviously posed.

DuPainDuVinDuFromage · 21/08/2022 20:08

@FortunaMajor you’ll know a lot more than me about the region after 6 years there! I’m close to Grenoble but also travel to DH’s parents in the southern alps quite often so am starting to get to know my way around!

51 Winter Holiday - Arthur Ransome (read to the DCs). This is one of the sequels to Swallows and Amazons, set in the winter holidays this time (obviously!), again in the Lake District. The characters and the story are great, and I could really imagine myself in a snowy Lake District despite reading the book over the course of a boiling hot summer hundreds of miles away. This is possibly my favourite Ransome book (although I’m about to start The Picts and the Martyrs with the DCs, which I also love!) and I definitely prefer it to Swallows and Amazons. The kids loved it too which makes me happy 😊

MamaNewtNewt · 21/08/2022 20:59

58. The Premonitions Bureau: A True Story by Sam Knight

In the aftermath of the Aberfan tragedy in the 60s, a psychiatrist investigates instances of people from the village, as well as further afield, who seem to have had premonitions of the disaster. This leads him to speculate whether the tragedy could have been prevented if the premonitions had been collated and centralised. Working with a journalist for the Evening Standard he sets up the 'Premonitions Bureau' (in reality the Dr, the journalist and his assistant) to track premonitions received from members of the public.

This was an odd book, it jumped around the timeline and from character to character, with little rhyme or reason. The 'Premonitions Bureau' was actually a pretty small part of the story, and I don’t think that there was enough material to warrant a book, hence the padding. The sections detailing the approach to mental health at the time were interesting, but didn’t really fit with the alleged subject of the book. The premonitions weren’t subject to a rigorous scientific scrutiny, that being said there were definitely a couple of examples that did seem to have potential but there just wasn’t enough detail. I think this might have made an interesting long essay, but no more.

59. The Silence of the Girls by Pat Barker

Much reviewed on the thread, I have had this on my TBR pile for a while (unlike some 50 bookers I can confidently say I don’t think I’ll ever get through mine 🙂) I finally got round to reading it as it was chosen for my book club. I loved it, and can’t wait to discuss it when my book club meets.

60. Behind Closed Doors by Susan Lewis

A run of the mill detective story story centred around the disappearance of a 14 year old girl. Although I didn’t guess the ending I think that’s partly because I just didn’t care. I won’t be continuing with this series.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.