Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

50 Book Challenge 2021 Part One

999 replies

southeastdweller · 01/01/2021 09:10

Welcome to the first thread of the 50 Book Challenge for this year.

The challenge is to read fifty books (or more!) in 2020, though reading fifty isn't mandatory. Any type of book can count, and please try to let us all know your thoughts on what you've read.

Who's in for this year?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
highlandcoo · 07/01/2021 20:46

G&T you have done a lot better with A Place of Greater Safety than me. I love France, I love history and I really enjoyed Wolf Hall so it should have been right up my street. However, after about 80 pages I was still struggling to tell the difference between the three main characters. There was just nothing I could fasten onto to distinguish between them in my head iyswim. And I very rarely DNF. I might have a go at A Tale of Two Cities instead.

highlandcoo what was the survival tip??
Tarahumara it would be a real spoiler if I told you I think, sorry. All I can say it is was revolting. If you like a page-turning adventure story, I recommend it as a really good yarn. You need a strong stomach though.

Pepe I like the sound of your first two choices. They are going on the Wishlist.

FortunaMajor · 07/01/2021 21:40
  1. DUCKS, NEWBURYPORT - LUCY ELLMAN
I'm shouting because it's that good. The inner monologue and musings of a stay at home mother. Her every jumbled thought and innermost feeling. This is about nothing and everything all at the same time. There is no coherent narrative throughout, but as her mind wanders there and back again, she covers life, love, death, motherhood, politics, the environment, modern society, history and everything inbetween. It's witty and whimsical at the same time as being a very astute insight into modern American life. The language is repetitive and cyclic and it takes a little time to get into the rhythm of it, but once you do it's almost poetic. One to go with the flow with and let it carry you away. I did find the style a little jarring and annoying at first, but soon settled in. Although there is no plot and seemingly no point to it, things do start to link in together and there are clever little strands woven through it. There are some subtle in jokes that start to become apparent and amusing little comments that link back to something else. For something that makes little sense page by page the overall work is an astounding piece of writing.

The audio version is beautifully narrated and the woman has a lovely cadence that I found mesmerising. This is one you can tackle in small parts despite the length in either audio or print..

An excerpt so you know what you are letting yourselves in for if you go for it.

“If I die you’ll be sorry,” the fact that I was always thinking that as a kid, always thinking what if I died, and how everybody’d feel about it, how sorry they’d be, and ashamed, and regretful, the fact that I wonder if my kids think that every time anybody’s mean to them, or angry with them, the fact that you angrily think to yourself, they’ll feel bad if you die, but what if they don’t feel too bad about it, and your death will all be for nothing, for no reason, died for nothing, nil by mouth, DNR, the fact that I wish Leo was here more, just to keep me calm, the fact that it’s hard to be calm when ninety-three people get shot dead every day, and there are all these impatient coffee shop clients, and I have a daughter disgusted by my refusal to become vegan, and we got that guy in DC, the fact that I think he plans to just bluff his way through the whole presidency, the fact that he smells so good, Leo, not Trump, dear me, pollution, nuclear war, Nagasaki, sciatica, the fact that there was one poor man who witnessed both Hiroshima and Nagasaki, I mean both bombs, the fact that he was in Hiroshima when the first bomb hit, survived and stayed the night in a bomb shelter, then managed to get home to Nagasaki the next day just in time for the second bomb, and he survived that one too, the fact that, I mean, how awful, vow renewal ceremony, “You’d be sorry if I died,” the fact that there are all these clubs now for people to “prepare” for the end of the world, Doomsday preppers.

FortunaMajor · 07/01/2021 21:45

I also found A Place of Greater Safety bloody hard work for the same reasons. The characters all seemed to roll into one and I struggled to remember which adult belonged to which childhood. I did finish it, but it was a slog.

PepeLePew · 07/01/2021 21:55

Fortuna, isn’t it brilliant?
I haven’t persuaded anyone to read it yet. People look horrified at the idea of hundreds of pages of a single sentence broken up by the story of a mountain lion. And yet it isn’t experimental or literary or difficult or boring. It’s just wonderful, reflective, contemporary, relevant writing. I ended it with such a strong image of her, Leo, Stacy, the house...even the lions!

FortunaMajor · 07/01/2021 22:00

Pepe It was outstanding! I queued this last February and I'm annoyed it took me this long to get round to it. I've read a lot of stream of consciousness novels, but nothing like this. It's a masterpiece. How such nonsense can make so much sense is a miracle!

It's very current in terms of world affairs though and I wonder if it will date as time goes on?

SapatSea · 07/01/2021 22:05

Me too, I also found A Place of Greater Safety a slog. I felt it needed the editor's red pen.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 07/01/2021 22:06

  1. Dishonesty Is The Second Best Policy by David Mitchell (Audible)

A second installment of his columns and I don't think I'd do a third to be honest, having got both of these in the Audible sales.

The problem is not the content, which is still, on occasion, laugh out loud.

It's just organised in a really odd way, by category, not chronology, and though this might make a lot of sense to both author and publisher; for a book that has columns running through to 2019, by close to the end of the run, you are still hearing him making pronouncements about "Prime Minister David Cameron and Home Secretary Theresa May"

Confused Disjointed.

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 07/01/2021 22:29

Ducks sounds very much like it wants to be both Alan Bennet and TS Eliot.

TimeforaGandT · 07/01/2021 22:37

Interesting to hear that others found A Place of Safety such hard work. Maybe I benefited more than I realised from having covered the French Revolution at A level.

eitak22 · 07/01/2021 22:55

My list so far....

  1. Mythos - Stephen Fry. Brilliant book mainly about the Greek Gods and myths surrounding them. It was a reread as got Troy for Christmas.

Currently reading Heroes - Stephen Fry which is the sequel. Definitely easy to follow than Mythos.

Heathercob · 07/01/2021 23:48

I have just finished reading my first book of the year, and have started on the second 😊😊.

  1. "The Secret of Happy Ever After", by Lucy Dillon.
  2. " The Secret of Sunshine", by Phaedra Patrick
SOLINVICTUS · 08/01/2021 06:42

@TimeforaGandT

Interesting to hear that others found A Place of Safety such hard work. Maybe I benefited more than I realised from having covered the French Revolution at A level.
I agree with this because I'm the opposite of most, I did French and German A level, and (somewhat oddly) "did" the French Revolution via German with Dantons Tod. When I read APoGS I too was surprised how much I remembered. And how very interesting and rather sexy I found all three of the main men Confused I bought WH on the back of that really, but have never studied that period (I did History A level but European post 1870) and blimeyheck all those Thomas people. I make myself finish "important" books, which I feel WH is, so that's my resolution for this year, because I got about a third in and realised it was all just words-on-a-page (in true MN style Grin) and abandoned it.

I started Rupture last night. I can see why RJ leaves some people a bit meh, but I think that's what I like, and I can see the Agatha Christie style. After far too many psycho-next-door 99p Kindles, something a bit more Midsomer Murders is welcome. And there's snow! And mountains! And I always find myself saying "imagine waking up every morning and being Icelandic! Wouldn't that be interesting!" Grin

ShakeItOff2000 · 08/01/2021 08:06

3. Piranesi by Susanna Clarke.

Already some chat about this book on here. I thought it was a slow-building, short read with an intriguing story. If you like this genre, I suggest reading this soon before you come across any spoilers.

Now I am reading Say Nothing, non-fiction about The Troubles in Northern Ireland, and listening to Elena Ferrante’s The Lying Life of Adults.

Boiledeggandtoast · 08/01/2021 08:27

@RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie

Ducks sounds very much like it wants to be both Alan Bennet and TS Eliot.
I've seen it compared to James Joyce in a review!

The other brilliant thing about DucksNewburyport is the names and references she drops in lightly (without interrupting the enjoyment and flowing narrative) and are easy to miss, but they are really worth researching as they provide a relevant and fascinating background of US history. American readers may be more familiar with them, but I learned a lot.

RazorstormUnicorn · 08/01/2021 08:38

1 Chasing The Dram by Rachel McCormack

This was described to me as a whisky road trip around Scotland, and I'm a bit disappointed that the actual book is a bit different.

It's a memoir of what whisky is to the Scots and whilst Rachel does visit lots of different parts of Scotland, it's over a period of months so I wouldn't describe it as a road trip.

There's also a lot of history of how whisky is made, which is only relatively interesting.

It's a recipe book too, with some of the recipes appearing quite suddenly and jarringly. I noticed half way through there is also no index of recipes, so to find them again I started turning the corners down (I know I know, I wouldn't usually!).

That might all sound like criticism but I have already bought two copies of the book to give to other friends who love whisky, and I am happily tucking into the bottles I have and plotting next purchases, so it's certainly influenced me!

MegBusset · 08/01/2021 08:42
  1. I Wanna Be Yours - John Cooper Clarke

Christmas present from DH and a thoroughly endearing read of the punk poet's life story. Rolls along with a sprightliness entirely missing from the Paphides biog. Would have liked a bit more of the poetry included but that's another book I guess!

Sadik · 08/01/2021 09:03

I think he must not have the rights to his poems Meg - I was very disappointed about that too, especially as I had the audiobook!

PepeLePew · 08/01/2021 09:10

I see why Ducks could be compared to Joyce but as someone who is slogging through Ulysses (at a rate of about a page a day - hard to know whether death or reading will triumph!) I think that is guaranteed to put people off reading Ellman. It's a very different reading experience and much more of a traditional narrative in many ways despite the stream of consciousness.

She has a book of essays coming out this year which I'm looking forward to reading. I saw her talk about Ducks at an event this time last year, and really enjoyed hearing what she had to say.

Boiledeggandtoast · 08/01/2021 10:04

@PepeLePew

I see why Ducks could be compared to Joyce but as someone who is slogging through Ulysses (at a rate of about a page a day - hard to know whether death or reading will triumph!) I think that is guaranteed to put people off reading Ellman. It's a very different reading experience and much more of a traditional narrative in many ways despite the stream of consciousness.

She has a book of essays coming out this year which I'm looking forward to reading. I saw her talk about Ducks at an event this time last year, and really enjoyed hearing what she had to say.

Thanks for the heads-up Pepe, I shall look out for that. And I'm very jealous that you got to hear Lucy Ellman talk about Ducks.

I've never tried Ulysses as it always looks rather daunting, would you recommend it, albeit at a page a day? I did read The Dead a couple of evenings ago which is very fine but not at all like Ducks.

Tarahumara · 08/01/2021 10:35

As someone who read both Ulysses and Ducks in 2020, I can reassure potential Ducks readers that it is far easier going and made a lot more sense to me. They're only similar in the stream of consciousness style.

Tarahumara · 08/01/2021 10:37

Boiledeggandtoast yes I agree with you about learning about things in American history. I often did a bit of googling around the intriguing snippets that she dropped in.

Tarahumara · 08/01/2021 10:40

Boiledeggandtoast I find it hard to recommend Ulysses unreservedly as I did find it really difficult to get through. I got a sense of achievement after finally finishing it though!

PepeLePew · 08/01/2021 10:47

boiledegg, the fact I’m only managing a page a day is probably quite telling! I found the first few sections very absorbing but am currently stalled and can’t restart. I’m letting it wash over me rather than trying to make sense of it all. As near-poetry, it works quite well. As a novel, it’s baffling.

Boiledeggandtoast · 08/01/2021 10:58

Thanks Tara and Pepe. I'll perhaps put it on a WATBR list (With Aspiration/Ambition).

Tanaqui · 08/01/2021 11:26

The best tip for reading Wolf Hall (which I undoubtedly got from here!) Is to remember that everyone she writes a non specific "he", it means Cromwell. Once I got that, it was a much easier read!

  1. The Truants by Kate Weinburg. I read this thanks to the glowing review of it upthread and I will say first that I did enjoy it! However, I had a couple of major problems, and I would love to know if anyone else found the same (possible spoilers): Firstly, the narrative had a couple of jarring words/phrases that I would say are actual mistakes- Jess has "stomach flu" at the beginning, so I was expecting her to be American- I have never come across stomach flu as an English description of a stomach bug. She also refers to airplanes, not aeroplanes; and describes panty liners as as uncomfortably thick as a sandwich- that is a sanitary towel, not a pany liner! Secondly I found the time period unconvincing- there are mobiles and email, but the university seems oddly small for present day UEA, Jess's farm visiting childhood seems more 1970s than 2010s, the 26 yr old journalist attending a first year lecture just did not feel authentic to me- UEA has a big English Literature cohort, I just can't picture it as she describes it. Even when I went to uni in 89 things were not that intimate (and I went to a similar type of place). I would love to know if anyone else feels similarly!