Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

50 Book Challenge 2018 Part Eight

999 replies

southeastdweller · 17/10/2018 07:21

Welcome to the eighth (and probably final) thread of the 50 Book Challenge for this year.

The challenge is to read fifty books (or more!) in 2018, though reading fifty isn't mandatory. Any type of book can count, it’s not too late to and please try to let us all know your thoughts on what you've read.The lurkers among you are also very welcome to come out of the woodwork and share with us what you've read!

The first thread of the year is here, the second one here, the third one here, the fourth one here, the fifth one here, the sixth one here and the seventh one here.

How have you got on this year?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
TimeforaGandT · 30/10/2018 20:58

Just dropping in to add:

40. Class by Jilly Cooper - I bought this because it was a Kindle daily deal and I have fond memories of Riders, Rivals, Polo etc. It is essentially an analysis of the class system with "humorous" stereotypes for each class/sub-class. It seems very dated - think it was written in the 80s - and quite cringeworthy (is that a word or how you spell it?) in places.

Anyway, next up Anita and Me - Meera Syal

SatsukiKusakabe · 30/10/2018 21:30

46. Melmoth by Sarah Perry

I really enjoyed this. I didn’t love it like I did Essex Serpent, but Perry is a beautiful, beautiful writer and that goes a long way. In Perry’s version, Melmoth is a character of folk myth, who wanders the Earth seeking out despair and darkness, to bear witness to all the worst of humanity, appearing as an embodiment of shame, a guilty whisper of the conscience. This conceit provides the way in to observe different facets of human frailty, cruelty and guilt across time, beginning with Helen Franklin in the present day. She lives a spare, chastened existence, haunted by events from her past, which constitutes the central mystery of the novel; the reader follows her as she comes to possess some documents relating to the history of Melmoth, and here through diary entries, letters and other evidence, she discovers the stories of others in the past that have, through misdeed or mischance, come to be acquainted with, and affected by, the legend. Perry weaves a gothic tale through modern day Prague, and back to past atrocities of war and peacetime, and attempts to explore the complexities of moral culpability and the possibility of redemption, with the emphasis always being on the importance of bearing witness. I don’t think the weaving of the different threads is entirely successful, and though she is very playful with the gothic tropes she employs, nevertheless at times your imagination does need a good stretching in order to go along with her, and I think some of the entertaining smoke and mirrors was a little at the expense of the characters. Whilst I really liked the 19th century treatment she gave to the modern world, the modern day dialogue wasn’t always convincing, as the cadences often felt from another time “you ought not to play such tricks” etc. Also the resolution felt a little rushed and I was a bit disappointed in the slightly hokey ending. However, I did rattle along with it and loved the atmosphere she created, and the historical bits, especially in Prague during the War, were very interesting, and fleshed out my knowledge of that time further. So on the whole, a good read with some quibbles. I think she took a risk with the form because she wanted to say something significant about how to be “good” in a violent, unforgiving and complex world, where signing a piece of paper in an office, or a single act of selfishness can leave you as culpable as any intended act of malice, and how we all have a responsibility to not turn a blind eye to suffering; to witness, if nothing else. I think she is interrogating her own sense of purpose as a writer here also. Overall it was thoughtful and thought-provoking, fun, bleak, hopeful, despairing - so I’ll forgive where it didn’t quite work, and very much look forward to her next one.

PepeLePew · 31/10/2018 06:46

112 Meg by Steve Alten
Giant prehistoric shark terrorises the Pacific while people behave badly. This was entertaining in a terrible way.

113 A Simple Favor by Darcey Bell
Two women share secrets and end up in an entirely unbelievable situation. This wasn't entertaining in any way.

114 Lucky Jim by Kingsley Amis
This was a change of gear after two such lightweight books. I can't believe I've never read it as I had a phase of reading lots of David Lodge who clearly owes Amis a massive debt, and it certainly was much less slapstick comedy than I expected. The humour was dark and the observations fairly caustic. No one really comes out of it well. Nonetheless it was well worth it - I don't feel inclined to seek out any more Amis but am glad to have read this one.

AliasGrape · 31/10/2018 09:04
  1. Hallowe’en Party Agatha Christie Seasonal. Far far from my favourite Poirot though, in fact I didn’t enjoy it much at all. Aside from the fact Poirot would have been about 150 by the time it’s set, I can’t get my head around him coexisting with computers and hippies and such things, and it’s pretty hard to forgive a book that wonders if a 12 year old died because she was ‘sexy’ (it’s ok though, she wasn’t, so there was some other reason to kill her Hmm ) Of its time and better left there really.
whippetwoman · 31/10/2018 11:15

I'm enjoying my spooky seasonal read which is The Coffin Path by Katherine Clements. Supernatural, historical, reasonably scary (for me, I don't do horror) and only 99p on Kindle Smile

toomuchsplother · 31/10/2018 20:31

130. Melmoth - Sarah Perry - this one seems appropriate to finish on Halloween. Satsuki gives a brilliant run down of the story which I won't repeat. I too enjoyed this one. I am a sucker for a good gothic novel and this ticks most of the boxes. I have to say that I agree the strands aren't tied together as neatly as they could be. It does feel a little like Perry was under pressure to get the next book out given the success of The Essex Serpent. However the life lessons of the book are timely worth a read .

Terpsichore · 31/10/2018 23:10

72: No Name - Wilkie Collins

At long last, I've finished this stonking Victorian classic. It was first published (in serial form) in 1862 and draws on Collins's legal background - as well, perhaps, as his more personal experiences of living with a woman he never married.

Anyway, the starting-point of the novel is that sisters Norah and Magdalen Vanstone live an idyllic, comfortable life with their loving parents and their old governess, Miss Garth. Until fate strikes, both parents die...and the sisters discover (shock! horror!) that they're illegitimate. Not only that, their wicked uncle is due to inherit the entire family fortune, and there's nothing they can do about it.

Magdalen, beautiful, spirited and clever, vows to get back what is rightfully theirs. Collins plunges into a tale of impersonation, deceit, plotting, confidence-trickery, secret wills and sudden deaths, with some splendidly memorable conniving characters - notably Captain Wragge and Madame Lecount, whose attempts to outmanoeuvre each other are described with tremendous relish. And Magdalen is a bold and resourceful heroine, astonishingly so for a mid-19thc novel - you can feel Collins rather losing interest at the end when she reverts to a more typical womanly stereotype, but if you're looking for a good chunky read this is a corker. It would make a great TV adaptation too.

Annandale · 01/11/2018 00:06

32. Thinner by Stephen King
Cor! I haven't read any Stephen King for a while, and the last one I read was 23.11.63 or whatever that one was about the Kennedy assassination. Thinner is very much 'classic Stephen King' in that it's a schlocky horror yarn, and quite 80s in that it includes a lot of brand names. I enjoyed reading it but it made everything look very dark and unpleasant, I could do with something more uplifting now.

SatsukiKusakabe · 01/11/2018 10:22

I looked in Kindle Monthly deals but the few I was interested in still seemed quite expensive - 3/4 quid Confused Not a lot there.

SatsukiKusakabe · 01/11/2018 10:24

toomuch good point about publishing pressure re Melmoth - I felt I wished she could have taken her time with it a bit more, and didn’t think it could be down to that. She was quite poorly while writing it apparently, recovering from surgery on her back so perhaps that played a part in constricting her.

nowanearlyNicemum · 01/11/2018 13:11

The Snow Child is 99p in the Kindle Monthly Deal if you haven't read it - I would certainly recommend.

Otherwise, soooooo many cook books (I'm a cookbook fiend) - not sure I want cookbooks on my kindle though. Prefer to have a hard copy.
Am hesitating over the Joanne Harris - pocketful of crows. Any one read it?

KeithLeMonde · 01/11/2018 17:07

Lots of the cookbooks in the monthly sale look interesting TBF but am very disappointed in the lack of actual books to read. I see Into Thin Air is in there for anyone who hasn't read it. I bought The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks which I am looking forward to reading.

Thanks Satsuki for a couple of cracking reviews upthread. Which version of How to Be Both do you have? Mine started in the Renaissance which really worked for me and I loved the book - reviews that I have seen tend to agree that this way round works better than the one that starts in the present day.

89. The Sparsholt Affair, Alan Hollinghurst

This opens at in 1940s Oxford, where a group of arty, literary students notice a handsome newcomer to the college. This is David Sparsholt, and this section deals wonderfully with the atmosphere of the black-outed, wintery University town and the unspoken, unrequited love and lust bubbling away between the characters.

The rest of the sections are set later, focussing more on David's son, Johnny, from his own frustrated adolescent passions to a gently funny scene of him and a friend as the two oldest men in a trendy gay bar. I found these later chapters much less satisfying - Johnny is a bit of a nothing as a character, most of the important events happen off-stage, and for me the storytelling never matches up to the deliciousness of that first section. An interesting and subtle way, though, to reflect on how life - both public and private - changed for gay men during the 20th century.

90. Homegoing, Yaa Gyasi

A similarly bitty book which jumps forward across time. The first chapters tell the stories of two half-sisters (unknown to one another) in C18th colonial west Africa - what is now Ghana. One sister, Effia, is sold by her parents as a bride to an British slave trader living in the colonial fort. The other sister, Esi, is captured by local African slavers and sold to the British - held in the dungeons in the same fort awaiting transportation. The novel then diverges to tell the story of their descendants, generation by generation, with Esi's family moving through American history and Effia's through Ghanian.

The stories are unflinching and harrowing. There is love and pride but very little joy. Terrible things happen to these people both in Africa and America. Slavery is horrific but freedom is not much better. Many of the chapters are too short and too punchy to work properly on their own but the overall effect is thought-provoking and moving. You can't read the later chapters about the more modern generations without a real consciousness of what came before, and that is what makes this book impactful and clever.

91. Everything I Never Told You, Celeste Ng

I seem to have been reading a lot of multi-layered books about the past and identity over half term! This one has been reviewed a number of times above. I didn't like it as much as Little Fires but it was similarly readable and touches on race, gender, class and family relationships with a similarly deft touch.

92. After the Bloom, Leslie Shimotakahara

Rita's elderly mother Lily has gone missing. Lily, who is Japanese-American, has always been fragile - prone to strange moods, temper and loss of memory. She refuses to talk about her past much, and when she does the story is confused. Trying to find where Lily may have gone, Rita has to dig into her mother's past, to find out about her time in a wartime internment camp, and her strange relationship with Rita's long-dead father. This was OK - I enjoyed the writing about Japanese culture and the sections about the camps are obviously well-researched and interesting. The story, not so much - too sentimental, too over-dramatic, and too much emphasis on Rita who isn't a very interesting character in herself.

I'm quite pleased to have moved onto something very different now - my copy of The Secret Barrister arrived in the library on Tuesday and I'm glued to it with fascination and growing horror.

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 01/11/2018 17:20

The Kindle sales have been really disappointing recently.

Perry was apparently on a cocktail of painkillers when writing Melmoth, which might explain some of the disjointedness.

CoteDAzur · 01/11/2018 17:39

I'm popping back here to let you all know that City of Mirrors (#3 in The Passage trilogy) is 99p on the Kindle today.

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 01/11/2018 17:41

City of Mirrors is really poor, unfortunately. Such a shame - I really liked the other two (which are also in the sale).

SatsukiKusakabe · 01/11/2018 18:10

Yes I heard an interview with Perry about that. It was still a good read of the kind of happily be reading now!

Those last 2 posts are a classic cote - remus one-two Grin

SatsukiKusakabe · 01/11/2018 18:28

scribbly mine starts that way too; I need to give it another try. The style just kept sliding off my brain Grin

CoteDAzur · 01/11/2018 18:48

Remus - I know you said it's poor but I'm going to read it anyway because I just can't stop on #2 of a series I enjoy, although I did wait until its 99p to buy it because you were so critical of it (not sure why - it's not as if we agree on many fiction books Grin

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 01/11/2018 19:04
Grin

I'll be interested to see what you think of it. Yes - you definitely need to read it, to see the series to the end. I just can't understand why it was so much worse than the other two - suspect he just rushed it out to meet demands from the publisher.

CoteDAzur · 01/11/2018 19:16

I'm struggling with Iron Gold atm. It's a bit less shit now at ~40% but it took me a long time to get here. I remember you were quite critical of this book, too.

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 01/11/2018 19:23

I was really disappointed with Iron Gold. It just all felt a bit pointless and disjointed.

Sadik · 01/11/2018 20:31

78 Too Like the Lightning by Ada Palmer

Set in 2454, ultra fast transport has made geography all but irrelevant. Nation states have withered and died, and been replaced by seven Hives, each with their own code of law. At some point in their late teens, people take an Adult Competency examination, after which they choose which Hive to join. The world is effectively a technocratic semi-utopia ruled more or less co-operatively by the leaders of these Hives.

In practice, most of this is just background that emerges slowly from the story. The novel is deliberately written in a kind of bastard 18th century style, with lots of sex, murder, & intrigue interspersed with philosophy, political theory and religion. I enjoyed it enormously, probably more than any other book I've read this year. Despite that, I"d be very wary of recommending it without a whole lot of caveats.

Amazon reviews are spread right from 1-5 (though tbf around two thirds 4/5). One of my favourite comments from the reviews: 'I cannot decide whether or not I wish she exhibited more self-restraint' and I think that sums up the book for me. Half way through I was describing it to dd (who gave it me as a birthday present) & said that it felt rather like a fruit cake with far too much fruit, or a very over-stuffed cushion.

At least one reviewer compares the novel to Le Guin, and she is the obvious point of reference (all that philosophy & politics) - yet really it's the most extreme opposite to her simple uncluttered stories that you can possibly imagine.

But then the author really does manage to bring everything together and by the end it absolutely did come together and work as a whole. I'll take a break first, but then I definitely will read book 2 in the series (one for the Christmas list...)

Cedar03 · 02/11/2018 08:45
  1. Pompeii by Mary Beard Fascinating read about Pompeii, what the archaeology tells us about the people who lived there. Very well written - she explains things simply and clearly. It took me a little while to read because there was so much to learn, I had to keep stopping so that I could digest what I'd read. Really makes me want to visit Pompeii now.

57 Ballad of Peckham Rye by Muriel Spark
Young woman was abandoned at the altar. This becomes the ballad of Peckham Rye and the novel tells what happened. Usual assortment of weird characters and slightly odd things happen. Can't say more without spoiling the plot.

58 A Time of Love and Tartan by Alexander McCall Smith
The latest in his 44 Scotland Street books. Enjoyable but uneven. There is, as always, an extremely unlikely plot development which has positive results for one or more of the main characters.

59 The House of Unexpected Sisters by Alexander McCall Smith
The No 1 Ladies Detective Agency series are barely about mysteries or detecting any more. I enjoy reading them to imagine the heat of Africa and to find out what happens next to the main characters. Funny and sad as usual.

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 02/11/2018 13:39

94: Adventures of a Young Naturalist - David Attenborough

This came up as a ‘Recommended based on previous purchases’ on Kindle and was only 99p. It was just lovely. A v young Attenborough travels to Indonesia and a couple of other places, tracking down armadillos, orangutans, komodo dragons and various other exotic species, meeting a wonderful collection of people on the way too. Loved it. Unfortunately its sequel is a whopping £16.99 on Kindle!!!!!!!!!!!

southeastdweller · 02/11/2018 14:41

How can Amazon justify that?! The hardback price is £7.99!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread