2 The Heart Goes Last by Margaret Atwood.
I know some of you read this last year. Generally , Atwood is the master of a good dystopia Handmaid Oryx etc but I confess I was a bit let down by this. I found it flawed and frustrating.
I didn't buy Positron/Consilence as a central conceit, not because I didn't think desperate people would try anything, but because the idea itself, as a working principle, both as it initially stands and with later ideas added in, just didn't add up as a "designed utopia"
There were massive "gaps" - plotholes i thought, in the overall set up of the universe.
The third act is.... bad. It suddenly turns into some kind of Bedroom Farce with a Shakespearean comedy type ending. Yet one that feels seedy. Any initial menace is gone and everything is a bit overdone. I didn't like the last line twist thingy, but at that point I was glad to be done.
As an aside the book still does have some very thought provoking scenarios and elements but overall feels disjointed, like it's a failed comedy, as it's not funny, if that is what it is aiming for on some level, but also fails to be truly disturbing as a result of the farce element.
I forget what others thought not sure which threads I need to go back to.