Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

50 Book Challenge 2017 Part One

999 replies

southeastdweller · 01/01/2017 10:12

Welcome to the first thread of the 50 Book Challenge for this year.

The challenge is to read fifty books (or more!) in 2017, though reading fifty isn't mandatory. Any type of book can count, please try to let us all know your thoughts on what you've read.

Who's in for this year?

OP posts:
MrsDOnofrio · 06/01/2017 22:11

Happy

My stepmum has offered me the follow up to Harold Fry; can't remember what it's called but it's Queenie's story.

I am determined to finish If this is a man. I knew last time that I owed it to him to get through it.

EverySongbirdSays · 06/01/2017 22:13

ears prick up

DID SOMEONE SAY STATION ELEVEN?

CoteDAzur · 06/01/2017 22:14

Good to hear that you enjoyed Cloud Atlas, Monty Smile Here is the Cloud Atlas thread that Satsuki was talking about. Take a look and feel free to add to it. I'd love to hear your thoughts.

David Mitchell writes beautifully and his other books are way above average, too, but Cloud Atlas is his best. Bone Clocks is incredibly similar to Cloud Atlas (both in format and content) to the extent where I wondered what the point of writing it was - he already said all that much better in CA.

The similarities between Cloud Atlas and The Bone Clocks are quite extensive, to the point that the latter feels like an imitation of the former:

Both books feature:

  • 6 stories
  • ... all of which are first-person accounts
  • ... spanning decades
  • ... starting in the past (1984) and extending far in the future (2043)
  • ... and ending on a roll rather than winding down, as if they were cut prematurely

The themes are similar, too:

  • Man's selfishness & cruelty, especially towards each other
  • The yearning for safeguarding our knowledge/self/experiences for posterity
  • Growing old
  • Dystopian future

Cloud Atlas was original, gripping, and well... perfect smile First halves of the stories marched towards an inevitable conclusion, with the dystopian and post-apocalyptic two feeling incredibly real. Then came the second halves, and the reader is locked into the epic ensemble, with no escape from the author's logic as shown over and over in a variety of ways across continents and centuries. People are cruel and exploitive, we kill and enslave when we can; we have not changed, will never change, and this will be our downfall. Our technology will disappear in a single generation, just like our experiences and memories do as we grow old and die. It is a powerful blow to the gut, made all the more painful because of the hopeful note it ends with (1st story, so 1850s... but the reader already knows how the human story will end sad because the last story was laid out in full in the middle of the book).

A similar theme plays out in The Bone Clocks in a very similar format, but in a less effective way imho and for it I blame its fantastical/supernatural subplot of warring immortals.

I'm not quite sure why the author has felt the need for this subplot, especially since it takes up almost 25% of the book and imho doesn't add much to it, while the other 5 narratives take up between 14%-17%.

VanderlyleGeek · 06/01/2017 22:14

Oh. Um. Whoops. I was wrong. We're reading...something else. No need to drag up a contentious topic-- that's what HHhH is for. Ignore me! Grin

Remus, thanks! Off to check my messages.

RemusLupinsChristmasMovie · 06/01/2017 22:16

Too late. I've found my Station Eleven review.

My biggest problem with it (other than the fact that it is boring as fuck) is all the banging on about that actor geezer and his love life. I don't object to feelings as such, but I honestly have no interest in feelings that happened years before the time that the story is supposedly set in, of a character who's dead on the first page.

And all that crap about the first cello likes the fourth flute but the fourth flute doesn't like the 17th drum and on and on and on interspersed with loads of lines from Shakespeare (so the writer can Google Shakespeare quotes - awesome!) then meandering back to the night when an actor who's been dead for 20 years was having a glass of wine and a shag 20 years before THAT is really, really not what I want to be reading. I'm getting angry just thinking about it, as you can see! Tosh.

VanderlyleGeek · 06/01/2017 22:19

I think the author is coming to the book club discussion. Perhaps I shouldn't mention this thread. Wink

CoteDAzur · 06/01/2017 22:21

Ha! Vanderly how have you managed to miss the Station 11 wars discussions on 50-Book threads?

I dug up my review of Station 11 for you. Enjoy Grin

CoteDAzur · 06/01/2017 22:23

Remus - Our tastes in fiction rarely overlap but I love how we tend to hate the same books with comparable levels of venom Grin

EverySongbirdSays · 06/01/2017 22:23

I wrote a scathing review of it online but it's under my real name sadly Grin

Would love to share otherwise

Sadik · 06/01/2017 22:24

Loving "How to be a Heroine", Remus - thanks for the rec (it was even in our very tiny library!).

SatsukiKusakabe · 06/01/2017 22:25

3. His Bloody Project by Graeme Macrae Burnet

This was really good! I like this kind of thing anyway, faux-historical archive, medical reports, newspaper clippings, a dubious confession, but it was well done and I really enjoyed it. I was so drawn into Roderick Macrae's "memoir" of the circumstances leading up to the crime of which he is accused, that I read the description of the act itself with my heart pounding, and my expectations completely turned around. I was left at the end with lots to think about and many things unresolved in my mind, which, for me anyway, is no bad thing at all.

RemusLupinsChristmasMovie · 06/01/2017 22:27

Glad to hear it, Sadik. I thought some sections worked better than others but overall, well worth a read.

VanderlyleGeek · 06/01/2017 22:41

I think it was before my time, Cote. I certainly wouldn't have forgotten such a lively discussion. Grin

Maybe I'll skim a copy from the library if I have time. I'm kind of curious to see what the book club members think of it. On the whole, they don't mince words.

AnneEtAramis · 06/01/2017 23:11

How is everyone reading so much and keeping up here?

cantstand why don't you just download Anna Karenina in your kindle?

Happy flappy Re: perpetrators during the Holocaust, have you read Christopher Browning's Ordinary Men about a retired police battalion that was responsible for face to face killing before the camps. Daniel Goldhagen wrote another called Hitler's Willing Executioner although Browning's is far superior in my opinion. My favourite (for want of a better word) fictional book is The English German Girl.

Chessie, you might like Greg Jenner's A Million Years in a Day although it is a bit silly, it's very funny. It's structured as a standard Saturday and takes you through the day over the course of a million years.

Finished book 1 yesterday.

  1. The Universe versus Alex Woods

This book made me feel like I don't read enough contemporary fiction. It's about a friendship between a socially awkward, smart boy and a grumpy old man. They go through various things together and it was just a lovely, heartwarming story. What stood out for me were the characters. They were all really well formed and you disliked them, liked them, empathised with them at different times. In the vein of Harold Fry and similar.

ElizaBenson · 07/01/2017 00:03

Happyflappy you have just reminded me I need to get back to An interrupted life I started it last year, got a few pages in and then got sidetracked by being made redundant. I really need to go back and start again

The Clara Benson books I mentioned upthread have arrived and I finished the first one in the Angela Marchmont series this evening The murder at Sissington Hall it was a nice read, the plot wasn't overly complicated but there were some good personal relationships in it and the murderer wasnt too obvious, there was a plot twist but it was fairly straight forward for a crime novel. An enjoyable read though and I'm starting on the second one in the morning,

diamantegal · 07/01/2017 00:36

Best I'd recommend the rest of the Hunger Games, but just be prepared for the tone to change as bit as you work your way through. Enjoyable in a daft kind of way though. The films are on Film4 this weekend if you want to compare and contrast - I thought they were a pretty faithful adaptation, although I've only seen the first two.

And I read Cloud Atlas a couple of years ago but found it really hard going. You know how you have to be in the right frame of mind to read something? I was reading for 10/15 minutes each night and just couldn't get in to it. I'm sure it's a great book - but if you're planning to read it give it the time it deserves and do it properly!

ChessieFL · 07/01/2017 01:15

Anne thanks for the Greg Jenner recommendation, I have already got that from Audible so will be listening to it at some point!

DeliveredByKiki · 07/01/2017 02:04

Gosh it's so hard to keep up with the thread!

Off to a good start:

  1. The Carpet People by Terry Pratchett, downloaded on overdrive (app in the US which let's you borrow from the library's book catelogue) to play in the car for DC, they weren't interested but I loved it, read it when I was about 10 I think so was nice to revisit
  1. White Tears by Hari Kunzu - I'm directing this in audiobook form on Monday so had to read it at breakneck speed ahead of producer meeting today, it's not unpublished! It's brilliant, weird and complicated and brutal but excellent, am going to hunt out his other work now

Back toSwing Time....

DeliveredByKiki · 07/01/2017 06:02
  1. Danny the Champion of the World - Ronald Dahl classic reading to the DC,but I've never read it before and I loved it. we've moved onto Charlie and the Great Glass Elevator.
SatsukiKusakabe · 07/01/2017 07:56

I thought the first Hunger Games was ok, the second was more of the same and I don't have any good things to say about the third, sorry. It was like she was made to stretch her one idea over three books and it got worse and worse. Some people love them though!

StitchesInTime · 07/01/2017 08:15

Agree the first Hunger Games book was the best of the three.

Although the biggest issue I had with it was that I'd previously read Battle Royale and couldn't stop myself from comparing the two. Unfavourably as far as The Hunger Games was concerned. They're similar in that Battle Royale has a class of teenagers taken to an island and forced to kill each other until there's only one left. I thought that Battle Royale did the whole "teenagers forced to kill each other" theme a lot more effectively.

ClashCityRocker · 07/01/2017 08:18

Hmm, I didn't mind station eleven ....I wouldn't read it again but it was OK as a holiday read

I enjoyed the hunger games right up until I read Red Rising. There are some similar ideas in both but RR is less YA-y so you get to skip the teen angsty shite. The world-building is also one of the best examples I've seen.

Right finished no. 3 The Fireman by Joe Hill. Lots of problems with this, not least the constant references to The Stand. Spread by a spore, the 'dragonscale' virus causes people afflicted with it to develope strange markings on their skin and, eventually, to spontaneously combust. It's highly contagious and spreading like, well, wildfire. Sounds exciting? It isn't.

I'm going to give The Road by Cormac McCarthy a bash next as it was recommended to me by a friend.

BestIsWest · 07/01/2017 08:35

I had seen the first of the Hunger Games films and agree it's a pretty faithful interpretation. Wasn't sufficiently impressed enough to watch the other two though.

CoteDAzur · 07/01/2017 08:54

I would definitely recommend Red Rising. I hear a film is on the way, too Smile

CheckpointCharlie2 · 07/01/2017 09:23

Just finished #2 I let you go by Claire Mackintosh it was ok, admittedly gripping, but a bit like all the other nasty crime stories I've read.

I loved Station Eleven!