Active discussions

Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Talk
What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

Original poster

"Fingersmith" - the discussion

25 replies

Freddiecat · 26/04/2004 14:33

Open for discussion!

I don't have a great deal to add yet as I am only a few pages in. I think the dialogue is great though.

I think we should wait a couple of weeks for the live discussion - give people a chance to get on with it. How about if I suggest Monday 10th May at 9pm for now and we can shift it around nearer the date if people can't make it.

In the mean time - discuss all you like here!

OP posts:
rsv1000r · 26/04/2004 17:32

I couldn't put it down, ds and dd had gone to France with grandparents for a week over easter so I made the most of some me time and sat in the garden in the spring sunshine and read the whole thing!

charlieplus3 · 26/04/2004 17:41

On third chapter, wouldnt put it down if it wasnt for the kids needing looking after. Pains!

BoxofFrogs · 26/04/2004 19:51

I loved it, and finished it really quickly. I thought that the writing style was fantastic, and descriptive without being too involved so as to be dreary. My only 'complaint' is that I guessed alot of the surprise twists in the story.

suzywong · 26/04/2004 19:56

can I join in, I read it a while ago, bit I thought it was fantastic.

glitterfairy · 27/04/2004 21:15

Havent finished it yet as am trying to read too many books at once! Really enjoying it though although I do not like any of the characters too much at the moment which makes it a bit off putting. Will keep going though as I think maud may be interesting.

Original poster
Freddiecat · 28/04/2004 12:05

I have just reached the end of part 1 so being v slow this month.

Did not see that plot twist coming!

Funny how both this book and the last had central characters called Maud (entirely irrelevant to discussion I know!)

OP posts:
sassy · 28/04/2004 19:37

I've finished it!
Enjoyed it so much more than Possession; even though I did n't like anyone in it (like you, glitterfairy!) I still thought it was a rattling good yarn. Quality fiction without being too worthy. Thought the first twist was very unexpected, but began to anticipate later ones - you kind of get on the writer's wavelength after a while.

charlieplus3 · 28/04/2004 19:43

Think ive worked out what is going to happen, but we will see!

Julietclaire · 30/04/2004 01:33

I read it very quickly, it was a compelling read, but I agree, the problem was that I didn't like any of the characters. I felt no empathy with them - they were all liars and cheats (except maybe poor Charlie). The end was an anticlimax. I didn't care whether they found each other or not. I do like to be inspired by a book and although it was a clever read and well researched, I don't want to try to get hold of her other books.

Tex111 · 30/04/2004 09:01

It took me a while to get into it but I'm enjoying it now. It's a bit soap opera-y for me but entertaining. I'm reading the second bit now where it's all from Maud's point of view and I keep flicking back to re-read Sue's view of the different situations. Interesting but I won't rush out to read more of her novels.

charlieplus3 · 30/04/2004 09:23

Well ive just got to chapter 7 and i cant believe the twist in the story. Was totally not expecting that. Cant wait for kids to have afternoon nap so i can read some more

glitterfairy · 30/04/2004 20:44

Nope dont like maud either but is a good read whihc surprises me as usually if I dont like the characters I cant read the book.

Original poster
Freddiecat · 30/04/2004 22:59

I've just finished it! Really enjoyed it. Agree that the characters are not all that likable - although I found myself rooting for them which was odd. I am so thick I didn't anticipate a single plot twist (reading crap thrillers and detective stories is great for me as I am constantly surprised).

I keep finding myself comparing it to Possession - is this normal in book clubs?

OP posts:
charlieplus3 · 04/05/2004 20:01

Finished it and i loved it, i didnt see any of the twists coming either. Was a bit dissapointed when finished, would have liked a bit more of what happened next.

Tex111 · 06/05/2004 08:03

Finished it last night. Didn't really enjoy it in the end though. Can't wait for the discussion to really get going!

Original poster
Freddiecat · 06/05/2004 14:26

Still up for live discussion on Monday at 9pm (UK time)?

OP posts:
Tex111 · 07/05/2004 22:27

Definitely up for it.

Tex111 · 08/05/2004 20:14

Just realised that the discussion is booked for the same time as the live C-section on channel 5.

Original poster
Freddiecat · 10/05/2004 14:42

Am I guessing that this is not going to be a good time then?

How about we rechedule for Wednesday at 9? Will not be watching live C-section myself I don't think!

OP posts:
Original poster
Freddiecat · 12/05/2004 21:03

Anyone here?

OP posts:
popsycal · 12/05/2004 21:04

I am freddie - but not to discuss books!!lol

marsup · 12/05/2004 21:06

I nearly missed a connecting flight because of this novel... it should come with a warning.

Original poster
Freddiecat · 13/05/2004 14:01

I missed these last night! The active discussions must have been moving quicker than I thought. I really enjoyed it too marsup.

OP posts:
motherinferior · 13/05/2004 14:16

Read it ages ago, it's totally wonderful and also a very interesting take on several 'real' 1860s gothic novels (they were a whole genre in themselves) notably Wilkie Collins' The Woman In White.

scoobysnax · 18/05/2004 12:54

What's the definition / characteristics of a "gothic" novel - can anyone enlighten me?!!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page