Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

Book Swap: Hide and Seek by Clare Sambrook

7 replies

WigWamBam · 28/07/2006 18:09

I can't find a review of this - if anyone's posted one already then I'm sorry! I would love to hear what previous readers in the swap have thought about this though.

This is a stunning book. I wasn't actually going to read it because I knew from the synopsis it would have me blubbing like a baby but I did, and once I picked it up I quite literally couldn't put it down - I read it in 5 hours flat. And I will carry the feelings it evoked around with me for quite some time.

It's written from the point of view of Harry, a 9 year old whose 5 year old brother Dan goes missing on a school trip, and who feels to blame. It's beautifully written and very carefully observed; the characters are well-rounded and very believable and the pain of loss and of Harry's misplaced guilt is almost palpable.

It put me in mind a bit of Roddy Doyle's Paddy Clarke, Ha Ha Ha in that the narrative puts across some very complex emotions in a child's voice, with both the limitations and freedoms that come with that style of writing. The writing is gorgeous, descriptive and very powerfully emotive - you really do feel that this could so easily be from first-hand experience.

It's very sad, as you'd expect given the subject matter - it moved me to tears which is unusual for a novel, and at one point I bawled my eyes out - but it's also very tender and extremely funny in parts too. It's quite shocking in places; Mo's breakdown and the effect it has on her and the family is gradual but harrowing, and although it seems extreme it's also very believable.

It's also very funny, strangely enough. It relies quite heavily on farting for some of its humour (as you'd expect from a 9 year old protagonist!) but some of the humour is much more subtle and comes quite naturally despite the sadness.

It's a beautiful piece of writing, and I'm really glad that I read it.

OP posts:
kickassangel · 04/08/2006 13:31

i liked this book best of the ones so far. very simply written - i only had one evening to read it in, and managed to get through it in under 4 hours, but somehow manages to be very simple and totally engrossing at the same time.
when i saw what it was about, i thought i wouldn't like it, particularly as it's in 1st person narrative from a child's pov. i feared it would either be way toomushy, or too emotional, but it manages to avoid both those pitfalls, and simply tells a story, and doesn't waffle on too much.
i realised about 3/4 of the way through that i HAD to know the ending, so a good thing i had an excuse to stay up late reading. dh was not amused, so please don't send me any more good books!
i would recommend choosing a free evening if you are the kind of person that needs to know what happens,

WigWamBam · 04/08/2006 13:33

Oh dear ... the next one is a cracker as well ... you'd better warn dh now

OP posts:
kickassangel · 04/08/2006 13:49

now i'm all excited. don't tell me what it is, or i'll be ready the thread on it instead of packing.

panicpants - just read through this and i have to say FINISH Eden Close - the ending is a corker!

WatTylermoonfiend · 09/08/2006 17:31

I too read this in one evening, and found it very moving and funny. I expect I over-empathised, having two boys of a similar age to the book. I am very grateful to have had the opportunity to see this book, as I had never heard of it or the author. The author's 'voice' of 9-year-old Harry is amazing. Loved it and thank you!

PeachyClairHasBadHair · 31/08/2006 10:28

Almost passed this on, as I had heard of this book and having a SN child of a similar age with no sense of danger and an idea of invulnerability... well you get the picture.

In the rend I gave it a go and read it in 3 tear soaked middle of the nigt hours.

Painful, powerful and immensely well written.

Next day I gave both my boys strict refresher talks on stranger danger!

PanicPants · 11/09/2006 20:00

Read this quickly as I couldn't put it down, found it unsettling as all of you seem to have done. It was interesting reading it from Harrys' point of view, especially the confusion that a child would have, not knowing the whole story.

I really wanted there to be a happy ending, but of course there wasn't one. The inevitable breakdown of the family was, I thought, predictable, but expected in the situation.

It was so, so sad, and it was not knowing what happened to Dan which made it unsettling for the reader, not just the characters in the book.

Thoroughly reccommend it.

KISSassangel · 12/02/2007 16:31

bump

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread