Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

Book Swap Review: The Dark Room by Minette Walters

6 replies

WigWamBam · 02/06/2006 20:20

PLEASE don't read this until you've read the novel yourself ... I don't think I've given away any of the plot but I would hate to think that I had spoiled the enjoyment of the novel for anyone else.

I really wasn't sure I was going to even finish this book - the format is slightly unusual in that as well as narrative, it contains newspaper reports, police reports and other similar things which tended to make the first few chapters very repetitive. This continued throughout the novel, which to start with made me feel that the narrative flow was being interrupted, and the novel seemed bitty. It also meant that the same facts were being repeated over and over again, and initially I felt that this was going to make for very boring reading.

It did pick up though, and I found myself more interested in the story - although I wasn't too keen on the writing. As a psychological thriller it was neither psychological nor thrilling enough for me, although the story itself was interesting in parts. The way the plot panned out was well done; from hazy beginnings the threads are brought together in a skilful way. However I found the storyline improbable and rather surreal, and the ending was pretty disappointing as it was rather convoluted and came from nowhere - on the one hand it kept me guessing, but on the other hand it's nice to be able to work out whodunnit (and what they actually did!) yourself, and I felt slightly cheated that the ending came so far out of left field.

Some of the characterisations within the novel are interesting; Walters cleverly keeps the reader's view of the heroine very ambiguous, and right up until the end the reader is never quite sure whether she really is as she seems, and although her father is an important force within the novel, we never meet him. I did feel that some of the characters were rather one-dimensional though, and there were certainly some lazy stereotypes.

This is not a novel I would have chosen, and if it weren't for the fact I needed to write this I probably wouldn't even have finished reading it. On the whole it was reasonably enjoyable, if not the finest piece of writing ever - although I won't be in too much of a hurry to buy up all of Minette Walters' other novels!

OP posts:
UCM · 21/06/2006 22:48

bump

Dior · 21/06/2006 22:51

Message withdrawn

katyrocks · 12/07/2006 22:18

although i didn't finish this one, due to lack of time, I'm not altogether diappointed that i didn't. I found the writing style tedious, repetitive and quite dated. what year was it published? I couldn't get to grips with the contstant complex conversation and lack of narration I began to get bored with the main character and confused about who was who because they were all so similar. i found myself losing my place often and re-reading chuinks and even though i skim read some of it in an effort to get it finished on time, (something I would never normally do) i found that I hadn't missed a thing! disappointing. Not even particulalry intrigued to find out who dunnit.
certainly not thrilling. i expected more, from the title, but then, to be fair i didn't read it all. IMHO not riveting enough for me to go to the library and get a copy so that i can read the end!

WigWamBam · 12/07/2006 22:24

It was apparently published in 1996 - I felt the writing was quite dated too but can't quite put my finger on why. Perhaps it's because I found it a bit formulaic and unoriginal - almost as if I'd read it all before.

OP posts:
kickassangel · 25/08/2006 16:27

enjoyed this more thatn the empty chair - at least it didn't have needless cliff hangers at the end of every chapter. i thought the newspaper clippings were meant to make sure we were 'keeping up', almost as though she thought we might get lost. i liked the ambiguous ending. i thought all the characters were possible suspects, particularly as she didn't give physical descriptions of many, so the police descriptions were of no help, but i had spotted the killer as a potential from quite early on (or was he?) i thought the idea of a 'lookalike' was a bit lazy though.

Now for my big confession - i scare very easily. i started reading this when it was windy & rainy & dh was out. like joey from friends, i wanted to put the book in the fridge! luckily no nightmares though.

KISSassangel · 12/02/2007 16:32

bump

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread