Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Weight Watchers

Share experiences, tips and results from following Weight Watchers. Mumsnet hasn't checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. You may wish to speak to a medical professional before starting any diet.

Just joined WW, consultant explained nothing. I'm so confused about the plan!

49 replies

Rabbishes · 12/02/2015 20:03

I thought how it worked was you get so many points a day and you eat within them but now there pro points? And filling healthy? It's all so confusing! I'm already pissed off with it and I haven't even started yet Blush

OP posts:
Rabbishes · 14/02/2015 07:47

Can you do that from the beginning though? The consultant didn't explain the plan but did say to stay away from the healthy and filling because it's only for established members.

OP posts:
tobysmum77 · 14/02/2015 08:11

It's a free country so you can do what you like. I did it online so I didn't have a group leader telling me what I could and couldn't do. Ultimately as you say different approaches work for different people.

Personally I found the pointing helpful as it lead me into choosing foods from h&f but I can't see it would have made a difference to do it from the start.

SomewhereIBelong · 14/02/2015 08:20

Yes, you can do it from the beginning IF you have some self control on portion size - for instance crumpets are on healthy and filling list - one or 2 would be fine, but if you tend to eat a whole packet, then you need to be pointing, not F+H, it all depends on the type of person you are.

I sit at my computer/iPad every morning dealing with emails, facebook, maybe playing a game or 2 etc etc so I also think about my food for the day - I do the points, I do it all with the online planner - so will put in my breakfast, lunch and probable dinner (let the computer do the looking up and pointing) - see what that leaves me and whether I want to change any of those meals for something lower.

After 2 weeks of pointing, most of my "usual" choices were in the computer on my list so you just click on your list and move it to your day's planner. Now - 5 weeks in - it is easy peasy, I am losing weight at a 1-2lb weekly rate, which is sustainable because I am not hungry.

You just need to give it some time. 2 weeks is not unreasonable to "get-it" when starting a diet.

tobysmum77 · 14/02/2015 08:26

but presumably the portion control would also count for slimming world?

Of course you can also point sporadically op, so if you basically do h&f then you can swap if you need to for a day. I also used to point backwards to see if it was less to get a few extra weeklies Wink .

Rabbishes · 14/02/2015 09:42

I'll give the h&f a go and see how that goes then :)

OP posts:
Fudgeface123 · 19/02/2015 11:23

you can eat as much as you like from the list

I disagree with this, you should be eating from the list until you are comfortably full and not stuffed. If you're stuffed, you're eating too much.

A good guide for your plate on F&H is half veg, quarter carbs, quarter protein. Don't forget that fruit is 0 points, that doesn't mean you should stuff yourself with it, you should only be eating in between meals if you're hungry, not just because you can.

You also have your 49 weeklies to use for anything not F&H. I mainly use mine for sauces, proper butter, fruit yogurts

SuperDuperJezebel · 19/02/2015 16:10

Ah bugger I replied to this but on your other post, I thought you had no answers. Your leader sounds like shes not that amazing tbh. WW doesnt work for everyone, and not every leader is great, so you could maybe try a different meeting until you find the right match? Mine is amazing and I definitely couldnt have done it without her. I lost 8 stone 4lb and I knew she had my back every step of the way.

tobysmum77 · 19/02/2015 17:26

Why would you want to eat more than makes you comfortably full? The point of h&f is that it should lead to your body self-regulating. At least that is what happened to me personally. I also don't even stick to it that strictly because if I did I would lose more weight.

Rabbishes · 19/02/2015 19:26

I got weighed and I've lost nothing at all. The leader looked at my tracker and agrees I'm doing it right but can't explain why I've lost nothing. She's suggested I drop the extra points I get for breastfeeding but I'm a bit wary about doing so as I'm still doing g at least five feeds a day and I've been using those extra seven points for dairy.

OP posts:
SuperDuperJezebel · 19/02/2015 22:41

There was a reason I was 8 stone overweight Tobysmum, because weirdly I used to love that painfully full, absolutely stuffed feeling. My friend joined at the same time as me with the same to lose, and she also had that. It's something we had to train ourselves off of!

honeyroar · 19/02/2015 23:18

Give it another week Rabbishes, sometimes it doesn't come off when we hope - you may lose more next week..

Out of interest what sort of things did you eat?

Rabbishes · 19/02/2015 23:38

I did the curried butternut squash soup from the app and made enough to fridge so we all had it for tea one night and I had a bowl lunch the next day and for tea the following night, also did the spag bol and had a small portion for lunch next day. I had a couple of tuna salads over the week as lunches. Egg white omelette with grilled bacon medallions. Peppers stuffed with spicy chicken rice (boiled rice, chopped tomatoes, chicken pieces, spices).

I've been having fruit salad for breakfast and if I wanted a snack I was having either fruit or a WW bar.

I've been having half a pint of whole milk each day and a muller light, combined that's my 7 extra points for breastfeeding and I wanted to use them on dairy foods for the calcium.

I've been within my points each day, I haven't touched the 49 extra points and I also had 40 activity points that I hadn't touched.

It's a bit a lot disappointing really.

OP posts:
honeyroar · 20/02/2015 00:25

You really should have lost then. I've eaten similar and lost 10.5lbs in the first month. Keep at it, see what next week brings. I wonder how breast feeding affects things? It's not your time of the month is it? Sometimes that balloons me a couple of pounds that comes off a couple of days later..

tobysmum77 · 20/02/2015 07:26

this is it superjezebel, when people give advice it's from their own perspective. Everyone's different.

SuperDuperJezebel · 20/02/2015 07:41

I wonder if you need to dip into your weekly 49. Or try a more substantial breakfast. I always seem to have a better loss if I start off the day w a good solid breakfast. The weeks where I stick to just a yogurt/ 0pp fruit are not always so good.

redvelvetcupcake · 21/02/2015 18:29

Hi sorry been a busy week!! 'magratshair" yes fitbit started working.. it seems to show up once you have done enough to warrant it! One day I did a 3 hour bike ride on top of usual activity and earned 35 pro points!! to be honest it seemed silly and at the end of my first week I had 77 pro points earned which I didn't use. I only lost 2lbs in my first week and showed consultant my app. I felt if i had eaten all those points I would have had a weight gain. She didn't know what to say other than my body must be used to exercise but that didn't make sense... any thoughts anyone??

Rabbishes · 21/02/2015 18:34

redvelvet I don't get it either. I walk six miles a day minimum as school/preschool is a mile away so I go a mile and back in the morning, a mile and back at lunch time, and a mile and back in the afternoon. Then if we go anywhere else - park, shops, library, etc - I do extra walking.

OP posts:
redvelvetcupcake · 21/02/2015 18:48

Rabbishes ... I do insanity and metafit classes (circuit classes) spinning, body pump etc etc.. on top of that I usually do 15,000 steps a day. I accept this is usual for me though I have added on additional classes, tried to walk more etc..
I do eat a banana, an apple and maybe 2 other pieces of fruit a day usually after exercising as I'm hungry then, so maybe I am just eating too much fruit? I only used 6 of my weekly points as well all week! That's why 2 seems not enough as if I had a bad week i could easily gain??

vickibee · 02/03/2015 11:16

I also joined last week and have lots to lose, I have been alloc 39 points per day, I do no know how to work out points in stuff that is not listed in the guide. When you are this overweight it seems an impossible goal so I am trying to break it down into 7ib losses.

I had a ryvita with low fat Philly but no idea ho to work out points? or Gravy with my chicken and veg

Fudgeface123 · 02/03/2015 11:21

there is a database that has most foods listed, if you've joined at a meeting and signed up for monthly pass, you get access to the online tools. If you've joined online you also get all the online tools. All foods have nutritional information so you can use this + the calc online or a handheld pp calc to work out points

vickibee · 02/03/2015 14:24

Eating out? I am visiting my BF on Sat and she is taking me out for a meal at a posh Manchester Bistro, how do I choose best option from the Menu, even if you pick salad based dishn it could be covers in some fancy dressing?

lynniep · 02/03/2015 14:39

Some diets just don't suit people (I'm sure ww would have my guts for garters for saying 'diet' and not 'eating plan' but that's what it is)

I tried SW back in September. My weight basically fluctuated up and down until January, but I never actually lost. I understood the plan and followed it, but I didn't like it, and my body did not respond with weightloss. SW places no restrictions on certain foods, including carbs. This was never going to work with my body. It concentrates more on sugar and fat reduction, although they don't say as much.

I started WW 3 weeks ago and I have lost 4.5lb (next weigh in tonight). This plan suits me much better because I am restricted in 'input' BUT I can eat what I want. Even if I want to have a mars bar for breakfast (who, me?)
My body responds to that. I don't do that much exercise. I use all my daily and weekly pp (but not activity pp - not that there are many)

If you haven't lost anything in your first week at WW then I don't think it can suit your body and I would try something different. Maybe give WW a bit longer, but don't flog a dead horse like I did with SW.

lynniep · 02/03/2015 14:41

vickibee you do need a pp calculator which you can buy from your class, or use the app or the online stuff. (Philly low fat is 1pp per 30g, and one ryvita is 1pp - gravy depends on what youre having)

You do need to get used to pointing - guessing rarely works, although some foods (like tesco healthy living) are pointed for you.

honeyroar · 03/03/2015 14:10

How are you doing OP?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page