Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Weight loss chat

A space to talk openly about weight loss journeys and challenges. Mumsnet hasn't checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. You may wish to speak to a medical professional before starting any diet.

Why Weight Loss is a Psychological War.

13 replies

Slawit · 12/04/2026 17:35

I need to write a short essay for an adult college class I’m in, without going into detail about the class this is what I have come up with, drawn from my personal weight lose journey over the last 18 months. This is only a rough draft but if it doesn’t make any sense now there’s no point in polishing it. I would love some feedback and thoughts about it and in particular if you can relate to any of it. Honest answers please I have to stand up in front of a class with this and I’m terrified of falling flat on my arse.

Why Weight Loss is a Psychological War.

The Debt of Indulgence:
Most diets are built on a simple, clinical swap: stop eating the high-calorie foods you love and replace them with "healthier" choices. But 99% of these plans fail because they ignore the psychology behind why we eat and the heavy emotional burden of walking away from the foods that give us comfort.
If you want to change your body, you have to change your mindset. Here is the reality of the psychological shift required to succeed.
1. The "Bank Loan" of Weight Gain
Why do we eat unhealthy food? Simple answer is, it taste nice, it taste divine, but were you conscious that you would have to pay your body back?

If you think of your weight as if it was financial debt. Every time you indulged in a large Chinese takeaway or a rich curry, you were piling on the pounds or “dept”. Now that debt has piled up ( literally), and unfortunately it’s payback time through the "frugal living" of healthy eating.
Just like someone who has overspent and can no longer afford designer clothes or flash cars, you have to accept that the "tasty" life is currently beyond your means. This isn't a temporary fix for a week or two; it’s a long-term repayment plan. Indulgences like takeaways shouldn’t be part of a monthly menu—they are quarterly or bi-annual treat.
2. Stop Living to Eat; Start Eating to Live
We are under constant siege from advertising, from colourful packaging and TV chefs who that make delicious fat-rich, butter-laden masterpiece. We’ve been conditioned to think that every mouthful must taste like "heaven on a fork."
And let’s be honest: healthy food no matter how tasty is not a patch on a good curry and never will be, this is a fact you have to accept. You have to break the cycle of "living to eat." Stop expecting Monday morning porridge to be as exciting as a Sunday roast. When you stop chasing maximum pleasure at every meal, you regain control.
3. The Enemy Within: Instant Gratification
Inside all of us is a "little devil" whispering, "Go on, have the cream bun, you’ll enjoy it." This is instant gratification. It is a powerful enemy because it only cares about the next ten seconds of pleasure; it doesn't care about the hours of self-loathing that mayfollow, or the fact you’ve just wasted a week of dieting.
The danger lies in the lack of immediate consequences. If you eat a donut, you don’t wake up five stone heavier the next day. Similarly, if you eat a salad, you don't wake up thin. Because the results are delayed, it’s easy to lose heart. But remember: nobody gets a 25-year mortgage, looks at the balance after three months, and decides to quit because the debt has hardly changed (or even gone up).
4. Challenging the "Hunger" Myth
We’ve been programmed to eat three meals a day simply because the clock says it’s time. But there is no shame in skipping a meal. The next time you reach for food, stop and ask yourself: "Do I really need this right now?"
Try these two psychological tricks:

  • The Water Test: Drink a large glass of water and wait ten minutes. More often than not, your "hunger" was actually thirst or boredom.
  • The "Worst Food" Test: Think of the food you hate most in the world. Ask yourself: "Am I so hungry I would willingly eat that right now?" If the answer is no, you aren't hungry—you're just craving a hit of dopamine.
The Ultimate Choice This is not a "diet" for a month or two; it is a lifestyle change for the rest of your life. You have two choices: accept you now need to “Eat to live” and the psychological discipline that you need or go back to "living to eat" and accept the potentially shortened, heavier life that comes with it.
OP posts:
weighmoreweighless · 12/04/2026 18:10

I think we need more context but I read that as you telling everyone you have a very disordered relationship with food, if not an actual eating disorder, and I’m not sure why people in your class would want to know about it or your navel gazing amateur psychology.

If it’s a class for those with eating disorders then my opinion might be slightly different.

SilenceInside · 12/04/2026 18:12

Is it an essay about the title, or is it advice about how to lose weight given that it is apparently a “psychological war”? It’s not clear what sort of essay it’s meant to be. Are you trying to show that weight loss is a psychological war more so than a physical one, or at least equally so, or significantly so? Or are you accepting that there is a psychological war and then making suggestions for how to “win” that war, without considering if that’s even true?

Slawit · 12/04/2026 19:58

SilenceInside · 12/04/2026 18:12

Is it an essay about the title, or is it advice about how to lose weight given that it is apparently a “psychological war”? It’s not clear what sort of essay it’s meant to be. Are you trying to show that weight loss is a psychological war more so than a physical one, or at least equally so, or significantly so? Or are you accepting that there is a psychological war and then making suggestions for how to “win” that war, without considering if that’s even true?

I have been on a life changing weight loss journey, it’s been hard and emotional and along the way I had this realization that dieting is 99% more about psychological than physical (at least that’s my opinion) so I wanted to put something onto paper “as I saw the world of dieting” it’s obvious to me now the format is confusing and like you asked, have a considered if it’s even true. Thanks again

OP posts:
NinthBestOption · 12/04/2026 20:14

So it's a personal reflection on your path to success. That could be good but in this you're mixing your experience, your opinion and weight loss tips.

Go with your experience alone, successes, failures, how it felt when you found what worked.

We're you to write an essay on anything at all? In any form?

Lemonthyme · 12/04/2026 20:39

I'd use google scholar to back up some of your comments. For example, there are some famous studies linking weight gain to trauma. That might be relevant to some of your comments on emotional eating.

If you're going to write about weight loss right now, then it's hard to ignore the GLP1 in the room. Even if you've not taken them, perhaps commenting on why and how much people are prepared to pay. People really want to lose weight.

It might also be worth reading up on other psychological "tricks" to support behaviour change or, that can work against you. The ABC of behaviour change might be useful for you.

A = Antecedent
B = Behaviour
C = Consequences

If you think of someone in our environment now. They might be buying food in Lidl. The first thing they pass is the bakery counter. The smell of freshly baked goods is strong. So they put a doughnut in a bag.

The antecedent was the smell and location of the treat. The behaviour was buying one. What are the consequences?

The doughnut gets eaten. Immediate consequences are that sugar rush which gives a little lift and high. A burst of energy.

The long term consequences could be (if repeated) weight gain.

BUT as humans we prioritise short term gains over long term gains. That's how the ABC model works.

The Antecedent-Behavior-Consequence (ABC) Model in Reinforcement Systems: A Deep Dive into Change Management

Slawit · 13/04/2026 18:04

Thank you all, this will give a me a good grounding

OP posts:
SilenceInside · 13/04/2026 18:06

Can I ask, is some of your original version written by AI?

MagpiePi · 13/04/2026 18:15

I agree with @NinthBestOption about the mix of focus.

It seemed particularly jarring with points 4 and 5 which sound as though you have copied and pasted from another source. .

RobinEllacotStrike · 13/04/2026 18:28

”food as entertainment” & “ food as reward” & “food as comfort” all came along at the same time as high upf foods.

disaster for us as a population.

also link with food lobbies & govt.

the “food pyramid” we have been taught was healthy for decades is wrong.

psychological warfare against healthy bodies waged by huge upf highly profitable manufacturers.

ClashCityRocker · 13/04/2026 20:41

What is the scope of the assignment?

At present it reads more like a magazine article or personal blog than an essay, which might be fine if the purpose is just to get you writing something and reading aloud, for example, but not if you're expected to write an academic essay.

You might get more helpful advice if you post (a generalised) aim of the course.

I will say it does look like you've started off with AI and then edited it significantly, as the structure and some of the 'headline' phrasing feels quite chatgpt. Lose the headings - the paragraphs should tell you what you're reading about, so they're superfluous.

stardqoes · 13/04/2026 20:45

It doesn’t read like an essay of your personal experience at all.

ProfessorBinturong · 15/04/2026 00:34

I agree this looks like an AI motivation piece. It doesn't match the title or read as an academic essay.

Without knowing the actual brief, or standard nd topic of the class, it's hard to give specific advice beyond thinking about what purpose of the piece is and writing it yourself.

highlydoubtful · 15/04/2026 06:30

You should definitely remove the telltale AI signs!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread