Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Weaning

Find weaning advice from other Mumsnetters on our Weaning forum. Use our child development calendar for more information.

Annabel karmel - I'm annoyed by her advice as it's WRONG!

29 replies

lovely74 · 29/04/2010 10:57

A friend has kindly lent me one of AK's puree books (Top 100 Baby Purees) for inspiration. I'm doing BLW for my DS but am not a great cook so am looking in lots of places (including Aitch's blog which is great!) for ideas of what to cook for us all (my normal diet is rubbish so needs a good healthy shake up!)
Anyways - I read the intro to the book last might and it states;

"Signs your baby is ready:
-still hungry after a full milk feed
-demands feeds more frequently
-wakes at night after a feed having previously slept through"

The NHS / Unicef leaflet I have states;

"It is normal for babies aged three to five months to begin waking in the night when they have previously slept through. It is not necesserily a sign of hunger and starting solids will not make your baby more likely to sleep through the night again"

and....

"If your baby seems hungrier any time before six months, it may be a growth spurt and extra breast milk or formula will be enough to meet their needs"

I did loads or research about weaning, particularly as I have chosen to do BLW, and as most of my friends started way before 6 months, and am positive AK is just plain wrong. My DS had a huge growth spurt (I think!) at four months and was waking every 1.5 hours to feed for 3 weeks. It was horrid, the HV suggested solids, but we got through it and he settled back into his usual routine.

How does AK, "baby feeding expert", get away with putting advice into her book that is completely the opposite to that if the NHS / UNICEF (and by the NHS I mean the well researched leaflet, not the dodgy advice doled out by HV's). I know she's out to sell as many books as possible, and succeeds hugely, but what is the point????

And I know she does relay the advice that solids should be started at six months, but the issues above come up before then and that is why people start to wean early, and she knows this.

Oh this has really irritated me!!!!!!

OP posts:
Allidon · 05/05/2010 11:56

When was the book published? You say your friend lent it to you so there is a possibility that the advice changed after it was published iyswim. I was given a leaflet by the HV (from the DoH I think) 3 months ago which stated the same advice, it was published in 2007 or 2008 and when I checked all the websites it listed they had all been changed to the new advice.

Like a PP I found the proportions/combinations handy when weaning DS2 (DS1 weaned onto jars), but didn't bother with the meal planners etc. DD has been pretty much BLW as she hates being spoonfed so AK hasn't had much of a look in this time.

lovely74 · 05/05/2010 17:29

Lucky, that's why I borrowed it, so I could see some combnations of food I could do, what goes together etc. I'm no kind of cook myelf, believe me! And Allidon, the Toddler and Meal planner which my friend also lent me was published in 2009, and contains exactly the same incorrect information.
It's this approach that gets my goat, that she proclaims to be a baby feeding expert but has not bothered to update the basics. People will trust her (and spend money on useless things like the foon...)
I have no issue with people being given information on the basics such as how to steam veg, but beyond that the aim should be teaching children to eat nutritious NORMAL food, not stuff that you need to buy in specially then turn into some kind of veg shaped choo choo train.

OP posts:
Missus84 · 05/05/2010 17:35

I loved her reaction on Panorama when asked why her baby ready meals were rammed full of salt and sugar - but it tastes nice, basically! And if you don't put lots of salt and sugar in then children won't eat

MrsPurr · 06/05/2010 09:29

I bought Annabel Karmel thinking I would probably just do it the way everyone else does it, had a read and it was all so nuts it actually made me decide to do BLW. Recipes for puree, FGS. I can't be bothered. Puts lots more pressure on the baby to eat if you slave over guava and starfruit purees and he rejects it. I gave him a banana this morning and he was mad for it.

Such a funny thing about having a baby that you find yourself taking the advice of morons you wouldn't usually give the time of day to.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page